Min Hee-jin’s Masterplan: How SNSD, f(x), Red Velvet, and NewJeans Follow a Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis Evolution
If you’ve been following Min Hee-jin for a while, you’re probably familiar with her thesis-antithesis-synthesis approach to crafting girl groups—where each group builds on the previous one by challenging norms and blending contrasting elements. Let’s take a deep dive into how this plays out with SNSD, f(x), Red Velvet, and NewJeans:
Disclaimer: This is purely a personal analysis and interpretation of Min Hee-jin’s creative approach. It does not represent her actual views or intentions.
SNSD: The Blueprint (Thesis)
SNSD was the ultimate K-pop girl group template. They were polished, elegant, and designed to be loved by everyone. Their music was catchy, their image was the perfect balance of cute and mature, and they set the standard for what a successful girl group should be. They embodied the ultimate “girl next door” image, approachable yet aspirational, making them the perfect introduction to K-pop for a global audience. They were the “thesis”—the classic, the ideal.
f(x): The Rebellion (Antithesis)
Then came f(x), and Min Hee-jin threw the rulebook out the window. Where SNSD was all about mainstream perfection, f(x) leaned into the weird, the experimental, the edgy. Their sound was more electronic, their visuals were bolder, and they weren’t trying to be “perfect idols” in the traditional sense. Instead of the standard “idol personality,” f(x) had a more mysterious, nonconformist image, which made them feel different from any other girl group at the time. If SNSD was the established order, f(x) was the rebellion, the “antithesis”—the challenge to the norm.
Red Velvet: The Best of Both Worlds (Synthesis)
With Red Velvet, Min didn’t just pick one lane—she merged the best of SNSD and f(x). The “Red” side had the bright, bubbly appeal of SNSD, while the “Velvet” side leaned into the smooth, artsy, R&B vibes that f(x) hinted at but never fully embraced. It was the “synthesis”, a group that could do both—mass appeal and artistic depth—without having to choose.
NewJeans: Everything, All at Once
Then we get to NewJeans, and here’s where it gets crazy. They’re not following the thesis-antithesis-synthesis model in steps anymore. They ARE the model. They take SNSD’s universal appeal, f(x)’s defiance of norms, and Red Velvet’s balance between mainstream and alternative—and blend it into something that feels effortless and natural.
They seamlessly shift between the three steps—embracing tradition, breaking the mold, or blending both—without it ever feeling forced. That’s why, when NJZ (formerly NewJeans) unveil a new concept, it never feels like a sudden reinvention but a continuation—fresh yet familiar.
Given their recent struggles, their redebut seems to lean into antithesis—an act of defiance against the system that always tries to hold them back.
NewJeans/NJZ doesn’t feel “manufactured” in the way K-pop sometimes can. Instead of waiting for K-pop trends to shift, they ARE the shift.
In conclusion: Min Hee-jin is a genius.
HYBE CEO Lee Jae-sang on NewJeans:
"It will take some time, but we will stick to regulations and respond calmly. HYBE is a company that follows the rules and pursues precision management. Looking back, those who follow the rules always end up as the winners."
THIS DID NOT AGE WELL… 🤷
#HYBEDOWNFALL news: hybe is part of the list of 27 companies/individuals under a special tax investigation by the national tax service.
hybe is already under investigation for stock manipulation, illicit profiteering, illegal trading.
Bang Si-hyuk’s Prosecution Fallout… HYBE Drops Out of ‘K-Brand Index’ Rankings
https://t.co/i4jIvaeXrb
By Lee Jung-guk
SM Entertainment Takes 1st Place in Asia Brand Research Institute’s Ranking of Publicly Listed Entertainment Companies
Following recent developments including the prosecution report filed against HYBE Chairman Bang Si-hyuk, HYBE has dropped out of the rankings in the “K-Brand Index” for publicly listed entertainment companies — a major blow amid ongoing internal and external controversies. On July 29, big data evaluation agency Asia Brand Research Institute announced the latest K-Brand Index rankings for listed entertainment companies based on data from June.
The K-Brand Index quantifies brand influence by aggregating various indicators including trends, media exposure, social media activity, positive/negative sentiment, and community engagement. This latest evaluation was based on an analysis of 7,326,298 online big data entries collected from June 1 to June 30, 2025.
HYBE, which previously held the No. 1 spot in the last evaluation, saw a sharp rise in negative sentiment indexes due to the escalating controversy surrounding Chairman Bang, ultimately resulting in its exclusion from the rankings. Han Jung-geun, the head of the Asia Brand Research Institute, stated, “HYBE was excluded from the rankings due to a sharp spike in negative indexes stemming from the social controversy involving Chairman Bang.”
In this cycle, SM Entertainment took first place. It was followed by CJ ENM, Fantagio, TN Entertainment, SAMG Entertainment, YG Entertainment, KeyEast, CUBE Entertainment, Ascendio, and JYP Entertainment, rounding out the top ten.
Han further explained, “SM maintained strong brand competitiveness based on solid fandom activity from groups like aespa and NCT sub-units, while CJ ENM received stable responses thanks to a diversified portfolio spanning broadcasting, live shows, and artist management.” Detailed metrics and analysis are available on the institute’s official website and Instagram.
Meanwhile, Chairman Bang Si-hyuk has been reported to the prosecution by financial authorities on charges of fraudulent trading during HYBE’s IPO — allegedly deceiving early investors and making unjust profits amounting to hundreds of billions of KRW. The police are also investigating the case. On the 28th, Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency’s Acting Commissioner Park Hyun-soo reaffirmed their commitment to the investigation, stating, “We will proceed in accordance with the law and principles.”