@Rtem1ss If anyone tells you a character is ooc just tell them it’s a fic. A character is going to be ooc regardless because they’ve never been written in this setting or with x y or z. Fics are purely self indulgent just write what you’d enjoy and someone will definitely enjoy it too
@staarvchaser And now you’re putting words in the authors mouth, no one is trying to police fics they’re just trying to make sure the signposts exists so no one gets lost. It’s a shame to the victim who wrote the comment even though it was anon they still exist
No? Why would anyone assume that. I assume if something isn’t tagged, it isn’t there and therefore is canon. Meaning it’s a strict t/b for Ilya and Shane. If a fic isn’t tagged cheating for those two I’m not going to assume there’s cheating cuz they don’t cheat in canon, right?
@staarvchaser Yeah two things can be true at once but don’t like don’t read was made and popularised because it was a principle to use when you saw fics on ao3 with tags you didn’t like. It doesn’t work if those tags never existed
@staarvchaser It doesn’t say top or bottom either way and that was the issue, if that was tagged or switch or strict dynamics then the comment wouldn’t have been made
@staarvchaser It was posted publicly to their followers to shame the commenter, that’s public shaming! Putting something public with the intent to shame
@staarvchaser How would they know their preferred dynamic isn’t there if it’s not tagged? Or it’s tagged as dom/sub and they’ve assumed it’s the stereotypical domtop subbottom cuz it’s not tagged otherwise. Dldr can’t apply without tags
@lalahona2 I feel it’s more 1-10k can be a one shot (10k one chapters go hard). 5k-50k is standard average (although probs more 5k-30k), 50k+ is worldbuilding and like takes a day to read.
@staarvchaser Dldr only works if you know beforehand. They were 30k words in, they’re allowed to be annoyed when they see a tag they hate after spending 2hours reading
@staarvchaser You haven’t touched my argument cuz you don’t want to chat that shit. Go write a fic and interact with commenters, maybe then you’ll understand readers aren’t out for blood
the hr fandom is truly insane because what do you mean "please tag your fic correctly" for the damn archive means "ew don't write this nasty trope I don't like"??????? those are not the same thing wtf
@staarvchaser Authors can tag however they want yes but it shouldn’t be taboo to ask an author to add a tag to their fic. If the author doesn’t want to we have the ability to ignore or delete comments
@staarvchaser ??? When do I act like this? They didn’t get doxxed? Don’t put words in my mouth that weren’t there, you’re arguing against yourself then
@staarvchaser It’s entitled to expect tags be used in an archive? And again dldr can’t apply if you don’t know if what you don’t like is in the fic. If I waste 2hrs of my life to find out a tag I hate is in a fic I would ask the tag be added. Again I don’t care for t/b, not my argument
@staarvchaser Yes because it features canon divergence topics such as infidelity which is also tagged, if infidelity is tagged you would assume every canon divergent topic is tagged.