@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 Yea, thats fair. I don’t believe in God so I dont actually blame him. I’m arguing against classical theism. Just to clarify, do you believe in God, or were you just criticizing the flaw in the original post?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 The biggest theistic religions believe in a good and just God. Christianity, islam etc all believe in a good God who allegedly loves and cares about humanity. I am making my arguments relative to the major religions, but if you have a less traditional view of God, thats fair
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 it is innocent people who suffer the consequences of their actions, and there’s nothing we can do about it. If God was all good, he would save innocent people from having to suffer by the hands of the evil, which is my point, if that makes sense. Complacency to evil is also evil
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 Not saying God is to blame of the crime, but rather I am saying that God is complacent towards crime. He isnt the one doing the evil but he isnt stopping the evil from happening even tho he can. He COULD stop a child from being abused and tortured yet he doesnt. Isnt that wrong?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 The average person like you and me can’t actually do much against crime. I cant safely take down drug cartels even if i wanted to. I cant stop a school shooter safely. But if i COULD stop these with the snap of a finger safely, you best know i would, yet God can and doesn’t. Why?
@juanjco824@Danitelo28@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 I appreciate the response.I dont expect anyone to know the details of the afterlife but it just doesn’t sit right with me: If that theoretical heaven where evil and free will both exists yet evil has no power, why can’t God give us that world rn? Why do we need to suffer for now?
@juanjco824@Danitelo28@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 To clarify what I am saying, can’t God just stop us from sinning before we do? Why does he even let us choose evil in the first place? You might say “he gives us free will”, and I say “what about after judgement day when evil is destroyed?” Will there be free will in heaven?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 Lets create a hypothetical: you gain the power of an all powerful God. You have the ability to end child sex trafficking altogether, and save millions of innocent child. Or, you can sit, watch them suffer and do nothing. Which are you gonna pick, and why?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 Not speaking for myself but rather all the victims of history who have endured pain and hopelessness. The point is, there are many people who have suffered due to the hands of nature or other people. All i am saying is God is liable for suffering as he can prevent it but doesn’t
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 So was there no meaning in life in the garden of eden before sin? Will there be no meaning in life after sin is destroyed and God creates the new earth? Heavan is sinless right? Will there be no meaning or even free will in heaven?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 If I saw a child drowning, and chose to watch it die instead of helping, even if helping would cost me nothing, wouldn’t you say blood is on my hands? At the very least, you would see me as an evil man. God can prevent any child in the world from dying, yet he doesn’t.
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 Do you believe God is a conscious allpowerful being? He can choose to fix the system himself. He can get rid of death if he wanted. He can rid all suffering yet allows it. If i willingly allowed a murderer in your house instead of stoping them wouldnt u say blood is on my hand?
@CuriousMode@Krishna14109@KingKrow0@Noir15662 If i donated a million dollars to charity, but murdered many innocent people, would you over look all the bad that I did all because I also did good?
Maybe there is so much beauty in your life, but the same can’t be said for people who face nothing but suffering everyday.