@DrCyrusRazavi @bmay I agree with you there, but my recollection of the time was that Labour were planning huge spending cuts themselves, if they won the election, and did little to oppose Austerity as a policy before 2015.
@mark_russell93 @DrCyrusRazavi @bmay Undoubtedly true and it’s also undoubtedly true that social spending increased hugely under Labour.
But the economy was over-dependent on the financial sector and instead rebalancing it, they used it as a cash cow to finance their spending. It was always going to end badly.
@DrCyrusRazavi @bmay As the note left by Liam Byrne famously said, there was ‘no money left’ when Labour left office in 2010 - they had spent it all bailing out the banks!
Austerity was the direct result of this. A fact that should not be forgotten when assessing Blair’s legacy.
@LukeEdwardsTele I don’t see how abandoning popular policies designed to help the many (help which so many people desperately need) In favour of continuing with failed policies that clearly only help the privileged few, is learning lessons…..unless it is, “if you can’t beat ‘em join ‘em!”
@LukeEdwardsTele Starmer is right, we need to learn the lessons of the 2019 defeat. To me these were:
The Brexit policy was badly misjudged
The smear campaign against Corbyn worked, making him unelectable for many.
Brexit aside, the manifesto was very popular and those policies should be retained
@MarinaPurkiss Neoliberalism has clearly failed - trickle down economics doesn’t work, privatising essential services doesn’t work and leaving ‘market forces’ to deal with climate change is insanity.
Labour needs to offer more than just better management, it needs to offer a better direction.
@kehoe_des@Daniel_Grigg@UKLabour Surely anyone with even a shred of humanity has already left the Tory camp? Those that remain are staying put!
If Labour don’t win the next election it will not be because they didn’t do enough to woo people from the right, it will be because they went too far and lost the left!
@Daniel_Grigg@UKLabour The reasons Labour lost in 2019 were 1) Brexit and 2) the unpopularity (manufactured or otherwise) of Jeremy Corbyn.
It was not the manifesto. Brexit aside, those ideas polled very well then, and would be even more welcome now. So why have Labour abandoned them?
@Junkenstein72@WineLovingBear@doctor_oxford@MattChorley The relative prosperity of the Blair years was built upon a prolonged boom in the financial sector, the huge tax receipts this generated paid for their social program.
If they don’t deserve to be blamed for the bust, should they really get so much credit for the boom?
@DPJHodges When a campaign makes claims that are factually incorrect (eg the £350 million), or simply implausible (eg that Britain could negotiate better trade deals on its own) you would expect a ‘Public Service Broadcaster’ to make this clear to its viewers
@GetHerHome@Hold2LLC@DrNeilStone Boris Johnson was ideologically opposed to Lockdown, he even gave a speech outlining the huge economic benefits of being the country that ‘stayed open for business’
We only locked down when it became glaringly obvious, even to him, that the NHS would be overwhelmed if we didn’t.
@GetHerHome@Hold2LLC@DrNeilStone FFS have you lot got amnesia??!!
Flu has a r rate of a little over 1, Covid had a r rate of about 3, which meant that by the time your flu bug had infected 50 people, your Covid bug would have have infected 50,000! Which is why the WHO recommendations were completely different!
@2358Gjl @DrNeilStone We should have locked down in early March, instead we waited until 100,000s had been infected. We did not, ever, introduce proper screening at our borders, and we actually stopped community testing completely in late March
@Hold2LLC@DrNeilStone Just looked that up…… it’s for a flu epidemic. Covid was not flu and our attempts to treat it like it was caused many of the problems!
@DrNeilStone Boris Johnson gave a speech in Feb 2020 talking up the huge economic benefits of being the country that toughed it out! That stayed open for business! - He clearly didn’t want to lockdown.
We only locked down when it became obvious just how bad things would get if we didn’t