@CaptGTaylor@jaynordlinger I was born in Tennessee over 40 years ago. You chose to assume otherwise.
It is not an argument for unlimited immigration - 1B Indian immigrants would not benefit growth
It is an argument against indolence and freeloading. It's a better look to earn a job than to beg for one.
@LeylaKuni@Camp4 Regardless (a) people who do that are still likely relatively high performing students (b) the arbitrage opportunity would eventually diminish (c) poor performing schools benefit and improve from this
@CaptGTaylor@jaynordlinger This is a zero-sum / fixed mindset and it supports lowering the bar. If the bar raises, America will be more productive, and vice versa. If America is more productive, there will be more jobs. Attack leaders who limit growth rather than individuals who raise the bar.
@CaptGTaylor@jaynordlinger They are American children. They are raising the bar - this is a good thing. Other American kids can rise to meet that bar should they desire - that would be good for America and Americans.
@According2_Sam@n3ro@robbysoave Not all Indians are Hindu. Not all Hindus venerate everything that comes from cows. Also that’s probably beer which is entirely common but continue on with the racism and bigotry against other Americans
@just_in_brown@thomaschattwill@wil_da_beast630 Their homes didn't turn into New Delhi - what does 'homes turn into New Delhi' mean to you and have you been to New Delhi? Also giving racism a voice doesn't mean there is political traction - it just means a vocal minority believes they can be more vocal.
@just_in_brown@thomaschattwill@wil_da_beast630 Also how is this a very narrow category of academics? Spelling? Math? Science? Where are they not high-achieving? Instead of reducing excellence in this country by bringing them down, why not actually drive under-achievers to step up?
@NeonWhiteRabbit Spend more time trying and less time crying. Also your IQ measure is someone’s estimate of an average across 1B+ people, not the selection that moved to the US. You either know that and are disingenuous or you don’t deserve to have their jobs.
@avidseries Excellence isn't under threat because <15% of people represent < 12% of college enrollees at non-HBCUs. Every demo except Asians flattened or declined in academic proficiency (math & reading) vs. 20 years ago. There are bigger fish to fry than your white whale (puns intended).
@abemurray@GremlinIndustry@bryan_caplan To clarify - unhelpful comps being current comps - other people living in a way that may feel out of reach. Agree that a sense wonder and focus on self-progress is best.
@abemurray@GremlinIndustry@bryan_caplan Your grandparents knew wealthy people existed and maybe knew a fee names. Today you can know of 100 billionaires and exactly how they exploit that wealth/influence.
Agree stoicism works - best advice may be to avoid exposure to unhelpful comps and focus instead on progress.
@abemurray@GremlinIndustry@bryan_caplan Also it’s an odd thing to make comparisons to generations past when humans are and have always compared to their peers in their assessments of economic safety. Why not go to a logical extreme and not simply compare to 300k years ago? Because that would arguably be disingenuous.
@abemurray@GremlinIndustry@bryan_caplan I don’t think you have evidence that people didn’t complain or worry, which is a completely human thing to do. Also preaching to others that they should be thankful when you have more is not going to be particularly convincing or empathetic.
Mike Macdonald reveals that before he got into the NFL he spent 2 years begging Georgia for a job, he would show up to their football offices everyday asking for an opportunity, then eventually just took out a loan to work for free
“I kind of weaseled my way onto the Georgia staff. It took two years. Every Tuesday for about two years, I had a hole in my schedule, so I’d go over to the building. It was always inevitably during Coach Richt’s staff meeting.”
“I’d sit outside and read the NFL list and try to memorize all the Dawgs in the NFL until Joe T got out, and I would just try to pepper him for an opportunity.”
“Finally, right before I graduated, they let me come aboard. So I took out a big loan and got an apartment and went to work. I joke I was the first graduate student assistant. There were graduate assistants that got paid. I was a graduate student acting as a student assistant.”
“I was working for free. I was volunteering. But I was just like, ‘You know what? I’m just going to do what the guys do. No one’s going to know the difference.’”
“I’m just going to go to work, and I want to be the go-to guy. It took me a couple years to get there, but that was the goal.”
@justinskycak Picasso is a perfect example. Strict/rigorous classical training from his professor father, Barcelona Academy, and the Royal Academy before breaking the mold with cubism, assemblage, blue period, etc.