@bcphysics I haven't heard that either, but I have heard, over and over again, how glad my ex students were that they had taken AP Physics when they saw their fellow students who had taken watered down Physics 12 struggling and failing in first year.
@bcphysics Also, although I imagine this may be an unpopular view, there is an extrinsic motivation factor at play: if student only have to achieve that 3.51 to get a “4”, which is likely a fairly low bar in most classrooms these days, they may not feel any need to really excel.
@bcphysics Assuming, of the sake of argument, they are on a linear continuum of achievement, how do you justify the 2.99 getting 2 and the 3.01 getting 3? Or some version of that.
@bcphysics One of the problems with a 4-point scale is that it may appear unfair. Students engage in complex evaluations through a school year and in the end are placed in one of 4 slots.