Hi Kelly , We actually agree on the most important point. Catholics also believe that Jesus is the only way to the Father — “No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). That’s not a Protestant distinctive; it’s shared Christian teaching.
Where we differ is on how that salvation is received and lived out. The Catholic Church has never taught that people can buy their way into heaven or earn salvation by their own efforts apart from Christ. The 16th-century sale of indulgences was a real abuse that needed correcting, and the Church later reformed those practices. But the deeper disagreement has always been about whether justification is by faith alone, or by faith working through love, and about the role of the sacraments and the Church.
Happy to leave it there 🤗 glad we can both celebrate Christ as the only Saviour.
John 14:6 says:
“I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”
The Catholic Church teaches exactly this: Jesus Christ is the only way to the Father. There is no salvation apart from Him. This is not a Protestant distinctive — it is shared Christian belief.
No. I said the English imposed a single administration through conquest. That is not the same as a voluntary national union.
And no nationalists did not “cause” partition. They wanted the island to leave the UK as one unit. The border was created because a regional minority refused to accept the island’s majority preference and Britain chose to accommodate them.
You’re rewriting what I wrote to fit your narrative.
The English brought the island under one administration through conquest and plantation in the 16th–17th centuries. That was not a voluntary national union.
You’re correct that unionists were a majority in the six counties. They were a minority on the island as a whole. From the 1880s they opposed any form of Irish self-government and prepared to resist it by force. Nationalists wanted self-government for Ireland as one unit. Britain chose to exclude the north-east rather than require the unionist minority to accept a Dublin parliament.
So yes without the demand for Irish self-government there would have been no partition. But without the unionist refusal to accept the island’s majority preference, there would also have been no partition. The border was Britain’s solution to keep the north-east in the UK.
The Act of Union did not “unite Ireland.” It abolished the Irish Parliament and folded Ireland into the UK after 1798. Ireland was already under the British Crown; the Union just removed the last separate legislature.
Unionists wanted the whole island to stay in the UK.
Nationalists wanted the whole island to leave the UK as one unit.
What actually happened: a regional minority in the north-east refused any Irish self-government, armed themselves, and Britain chose to partition the island rather than force them in. The border was created by the British Government of Ireland Act 1920. Nationalists never demanded or voted for that border.
Wanting your country out of a larger state is not the same as dividing the country. Partition was Britain’s solution to keep the north-east.
The English (later British) state brought the whole island under one administration through conquest, plantation and the Act of Union 1801. That is not the same as “uniting Ireland” in any voluntary or national sense.
Partition was not created by Irish nationalists. It was created by the British parliament in the Government of Ireland Act 1920 and confirmed in the Anglo-Irish Treaty, after Ulster unionists made clear they would not accept inclusion in an independent Irish state. Nationalists wanted the island to remain one political unit (under Irish government). Unionists wanted the north-east to stay in the UK. Britain chose partition as the solution.
So the sequence is: British rule imposed a single administration → majority on the island sought independence → minority in the north-east refused to leave the UK → Britain partitioned the island.
Claiming “Irish nationalists divided it” reverses cause and effect.
Mary Lou McDonald has every right to represent Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland.
Sinn Féin is an all-island party. It is registered and fully legal in both jurisdictions. It contests elections in the North (Assembly, Westminster, local councils) and has elected representatives there. As party president, she is the leader of the whole organisation, not just the southern part. There is no legal or constitutional bar stopping her from campaigning, speaking, or representing the party north of the border.
Michelle O’Neill is the party’s northern leader and currently First Minister, but that does not remove McDonald’s role as overall president. Leaders of all-island parties routinely operate across the island.
This is normal politics under the current constitutional arrangements.
You’re rewriting history to fit a lazy narrative.
Ireland was Britain’s first colony. Centuries of conquest, plantation, penal laws and economic subjugation came before the modern Catholic/Protestant divide was even the main marker.
Irish republicanism isn’t “new.” United Irishmen, 1790s. Fenians. IRB. 1916. It’s older than the state that produced you.
And no one “united Ireland.” Partition happened. The Troubles weren’t a 1980s religious spat they were a 30-year war over whether the North stayed in the UK or not.
Pretending the colonial reality never existed is the actual insanity.
Ireland ranks as one of the most pro-Palestinian nations in the world, and is frequently described as the most pro-Palestinian in Europe or the West. so definitely don’t believe it was Hamas militants, that’s actually laughable that who ever was behind this would think we’d be that gullible. Anyway shape or form it’s disgusting carry on.
@ConaireMclaugh1@KellyMatshall So do you know Kelly ? I think it’s below the belt saying that to anyone. She has
Enough on her plate and she is doing a great job of it and credit to her too. just because she doesn’t agree with you and you’re Ideals doesn’t mean she deserves to be talked to like that !!
Really Kelly, let sleeping dogs lie !! or are we forgetting about what actually happened here nearly 30 years ago murder of the innocents and the brutal attacks and suffering all brought on by loyalists why antagonise a situation. And
I’m not even emotionally involved I live in the republic,I see it for what it is !!