@BookerRebirth Given all that’s been said about Karl & range of folks that have some type of animus for him… at best , he’s owed nothing but due process…
Hell, he probably didn’t read the book…He just liked the title & cover.
@AfroAmericanJay@tariqnasheed That’s not a “gotcha” moment. Yet, it’s worthy of examination... Context matters. In certain contexts how is any citizen born in America NOT from America?
In other contexts, being of people not indigenous to a land means your origin is not FROM there (ie settlers)…
@Queenofla2@tariqnasheed As for your last statement… well, I guess some folks relinquish who & what they are… & say “Toby” much easier than others.
I bet you wouldn’t have been so quick to cede if the example had Africans taking you somewhere, forming a nation & years later giving you citizenship.
@Queenofla2@tariqnasheed The appellation for the continent of Africa is in no way parallel to formation of a particular nation. Hence, the indigenous people of Africa are FROM Africa, in ways that indigenous people from Africa taken to the western hemisphere are not FROM the Americas.
@Queenofla2@tariqnasheed And what is the corollary of your statement… where would black people here before the founding of the USA be FROM 🤷🏽♂️
If someone enslaved your ass, took you to the moon, founded a country & years later made you a citizen… would you be FROM there?