@RonTidesOcean@Paris2024 The IBA doesn't take out any "real" scientific proof for this accusment. Shout out rumors without any proof loudly on the internet only make you look not smart🙂
不要過度簡化複雜的問題。性別可以用多種方式來判定,從生理外貌、染色體再到睾酮水準。
1️⃣ 生理外貌
根據身分證字號,林郁婷在 28 年前就被台灣政府判定為女性,這也表明外在因素表明她是生理女性。
2️⃣ 染色體檢測
林郁婷「並沒有」因為染色體檢測被判定為男性,唯一的爭議源自於國際拳擊協會(IBA)模糊且未公開的證據。但值得一提的是,IBA 與與台灣不友好的關係可能是原因之一,而且 IBA 也沒有提到染色體檢測。
3️⃣ 睾酮水準
林郁婷「有」通過了睾酮檢測並被判定為女性,這項檢測是國際奧委會(IOC)及多個運動員協會認可的,包括國際田徑總會。
上面三點都是事實。
那唯一的爭議是什麼呢?就是她的染色體到底是 XX 還是 XY?
首先,沒有證據表明她是 XY。即使她是 XY,XY 也可以被視為是女性,這就是為什麼國際協會如國際田聯(IAAF)和國際奧委會現在採用睾酮來判定的原因,染色體檢測單純就是過時了。
但這裡必需再次強調,林「並沒有」被檢測為 XY。
然後再強調一次,不要過度簡化複雜的問題,林郁婷的爭議可能是個單純的科學問題,也有可能是個複雜的政治問題。
--
Don't oversimplify the complicated questions. Male or female can be determined by various factors, from physical appearance, chromosomes to testosterone levels.
1. Physical Appearance
Lin *WAS* recognized as female by the Taiwanese government 28 years ago, as indicated by her social security number, which also suggests that her physical appearance aligns with being female.
2. Chromosomes Test
Lin was *NOT* identified as male by a chromosome test. The controversy comes from the IBA's sketchy and undisclosed evidence. It's worth mentioning that the IBA's unfriendly attitude against Taiwan may be the reason why they’re against Lin. And IBA did not mention anything about chromosomes test.
3. Testosterone Test
Lin *WAS* identified as female by a testosterone test, which is approved by the IOC and various athlete associations including IAAF (World Athletics)
These are the facts, as stated above.
So what is the only controversy? Is her chromosome XX or XY?
First, there is *NO* evidence shows that Lin is an XY. Even if she were, XY can still indicate female that’s why international associations like World Athletics (IAAF) and the IOC now use testosterone regulations. Chromosome tests are just simply outdated.
At this point I must emphasize again that Lin was NOT identified as male by a chromosome test.
And again, don’t oversimplify complicated questions, Lin’s situation can either be a simple science question or just the political one. We don’t know, so we discuss with facts.
Stop falling for Russian propaganda
No one had any problems with Imane Khelif and Lin Yu Ting when they started competing in boxing years ago until they beat Russian boxers, which was when IBA claimed chromosome problems. go figure 🙄
To the haters,
Imagine being born a woman, and one day, an institution claims to use outdated methods and declares you’re a man, without providing any evidence.
Then the whole world starts demanding that you prove you’re a woman.
Even though you carry reports, and even the Olympic Committee vouches for you, the world still demands that you prove you’re a woman. When you present the reports, they tell you the reports lack credibility; when you prove your identity, they accuse you of having surgery.
What you’re doing now, and what you may do in the future, is exactly this.
As Taiwanese, we won’t turn a blind eye to this kind of bullying.
@BaskiBloom@Paris2024 Lin was borned to be a girl.
Lots of her friends in Taiwan stand out for her and prove her female identity. IOA also proves that Lin is qualified and passed the test for Olympic games.
What makes you fail seeing these proof from Taiwan and IOA? Is skin color problem?
@piersmorgan Lin is not a DSD. The wrong premise leads to the wrong conclusion.
Lots of her friends in Taiwan stand out for her and prove her female identity.
What makes you fail seeing these proof from Taiwan and IOA? Is skin color or something ?
@antoniafrances Lots of her friends in Taiwan stand out to prove she is a girl indeed.
And Lin is a seasoned player who has had many games and passed all the tests, including this IOA.
Those trust IBA, an organization full of corruption and bribe affair, but question IOA...?
is skin color…?
Taiwanese boxer Lin Yu-Ting just won the Olympic gold medal by defeating a Polish opponent with her skills!
台灣女子拳擊選手林郁婷剛剛憑實力擊敗波蘭選手,獲得奧運金牌!
As a Taiwanese legislator, I want to tell the international community that Lin Yu-Ting has always been a true woman from birth to now, and I am willing to repeat this as many times as needed.
身為台灣的立法委員,我想告訴國際上的網友,林郁婷從出生到現在,都是貨真價實的女性,不管要說多少次我都願意。
Taiwan has long faced pressure from China, and we need many democratic allies in the world. It’s not easy for our athletes to compete in international events. This time, due to misinformation from the International Boxing Association (IBA), many people were misled. Many Taiwanese are very upset and angry.
台灣長期遭受中國打壓,我們在國際上需要很多民主國家盟友,台灣的選手要到國際賽事參賽都很不容易,這次因為國際拳總(IBA)的錯誤訊息,讓很多人誤會,很多台灣人都非常遺憾、甚至憤怒。
We will continue to fight misinformation and speak up for our Taiwanese daughter, Lin Yu-Ting!
接下來在國際輿論上,我們要持續闢謠、為我們台灣的女兒林郁婷持續發聲!
The Taiwanese government will work with lawyers and the International Olympic Committee to discuss how to take further legal action against the IBA. We won’t allow people to harm Taiwanese women's rights to participate in international competitions under the false claim of protecting women.
台灣的政府,後續會和律師以及國際奧會會商討論,如何採取對IBA進一步提告。我們不會讓惡意的人士打著保護女人的名義,實際上卻在做傷害台灣的女人參加國際賽事的權益。
#LinYuTing #GOLD
#IStandWithLinYuTing
#Olympics
#Olympics2024Paris
#Paris2024
#Boxing
Congratulation Linyuting. You beats the opponent with fantastic skills and show the world your hard-training results.
I'm so touched watching you win.
Congratulations!!!
#IStandWithLinYuTing#Olympics
@souichi_lai Some comments are…
Lin is a seasoned player who has had many games and passed all tests including this time.
And IBA doesn't even take out any report to prove their words!
What makes you guys fail to see the real facts declared from Lin's friends and IOA? the skin color ?
Lin Yu-Ting was born a woman. She has been female since birth. She is participating in the boxing tournament at the Olympic Games Paris 2024 with her strength and has complied with all applicable medical regulations set by the Paris 2024 Boxing Unit, which have been consistently applied throughout all qualification events.
Lin Yu-Ting is a victim of the sudden and arbitrary decision by the IBA. Up to now, the IBA has not provided any evidence. The IBA should establish a legitimate and clear gender testing procedure, instead of repeatedly and baselessly claiming that “Taiwan is a part of China.”
This cannot erase the fact that Lin Yu-Ting represents Taiwan as a female athlete.
We reiterate that everyone has the right to participate in sports without discrimination. Moreover, anyone who supports the rights of female athletes should stand against this bullying behavior.
The attack on Lin Yu-Ting is a form of international bullying. But she never gives up, and she has reached the final despite the eligibility dispute.
“The more we’re bullied, the stronger we become.”
We, the Taiwanese people, will always stand with her and be her strongest support. 💪