I play games, finish them, and say exactly what I loved and hated.
No fanboying. No sugarcoating.
Current game: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026)
That doesn't justify it. The fact that the original was never nominated doesn't change that.
Whether modern games can outperform a remake is completely irrelevant to my argument.
My issue is that remakes are competing for nomination spots that could otherwise go to entirely new games.
I'm pretty sure developing an entirely new game generally costs more, though, since remakes already have much of the groundwork laid out for them.
Additionally, nobody said companies would remake games TO win awards. I said they could remake games AND win awards.
Reading is a hell of a thing.
@Nerdstoner59@SergioB_@geoffkeighley It isn't about having fun. We're discussing award nominations here, whereas you're talking about something entirely different: enjoyment.
On that note, I actually agree with you. I love remakes myself.
Again, you're confusing sequels with remakes.
Hades II builds upon the original while introducing a new protagonist, story, environments, and gameplay additions. It's a new installment, not a recreation of Hades.
An Ocarina of Time remake, on the other hand, is still a recreation of Ocarina of Time.
In fact, Nintendo's own developers explicitly stated that their guiding principle for the remake was:
"The visuals may change, but the experience does not."
They even explained that their goal was to preserve the original game's identity rather than turn it into something fundamentally different.
Sharing characters, lore, or mechanics doesn't suddenly make a sequel a remake.
A sequel can reuse characters, lore, and an established universe while introducing an entirely new story, locations, mechanics, quests, and experiences.
A remake, on the other hand, is fundamentally a recreation or reinterpretation of an already existing game.
For example, Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom share Link, Hyrule, and much of the same world. Does that suddenly make them the same game?
A new Zelda installment is a new entry in the franchise. An Ocarina of Time remake is still Ocarina of Time.
Reusing elements of an established franchise is not the same as remaking an existing installment.
Your 'gotcha' didn't work.
@Nerdstoner59@SergioB_@geoffkeighley So you're telling me you'd be perfectly fine with previous GOTY winners being remade and nominated for the same awards over and over again, potentially winning multiple times for what is fundamentally the same game?
First of all, I wasn't even replying to you. I was responding to someone else who apparently doesn't understand what a hypothetical is.
And how exactly am I moving the goalposts? My argument has remained the same from the beginning. The hypothetical simply illustrates the precedent that allowing remakes to compete for the same awards sets.
As for your question, I've explained this repeatedly. Remakes, regardless of how extensively they're rebuilt, still rely on an established creative foundation. The story, characters, world, level design, and core gameplay concepts already exist.
Rebuilding a game from scratch is not the same as designing an entirely original game from scratch.
I'm not denying the tremendous work that goes into remakes, nor am I saying they don't deserve recognition. I'm arguing that they deserve their own category rather than competing against entirely new games for the same awards.
And your distinction between remakes and ports doesn't address that argument. You're judging the technical work involved, while I'm questioning the originality of the work being recognized.
So your argument is that because the original game is 28 years old, its remake deserves to compete for the same awards again?
What's the cutoff, then? 10 years? 20? 30? And who determines that?
As for your other point, just because something has happened before, whether in gaming, film, or television, doesn't mean it's a good practice.
My issue is the precedent this sets. Hypothetically, what's stopping previous GOTY winners and nominees from repeatedly remaking their games and competing for the same awards over and over again?
Yes, that's exactly what I've been arguing as well. You're absolutely right about the additional content. In that sense, some remakes can almost feel like expansions.
There should honestly be at least two separate categories: "Best Remake" and "Best DLC."
That way, both get the recognition they deserve without competing directly against entirely new games. It would also give players more incentive to check them out.
@SJCFutures@thegameawards Can you point out where exactly I defended GTA in that comment?
I'll save you the trouble. You can't, because I never did. You're arguing against something you made up.
Your marshmallow analogy is a physical impossibility. Mine is an entirely possible scenario used to illustrate a flaw in the current rules.
And nobody said companies would remake games solely to win awards. You're arguing against something I never claimed.
Whether my hypothetical actually happens is irrelevant to the point it's illustrating.
@DispyDispy@Jamag92@Entity__4@DiscussingFilm Do you understand what "hypothetically" means?
And how is releasing entirely new GTA games comparable to repeatedly remaking the same game?
You're arguing against a point I never made.
@DispyDispy@Entity__4@DiscussingFilm The precedent it sets.
What's stopping previous GOTY winners and nominees from hypothetically remaking their games repeatedly and competing for the same awards again?
@Ys_soki@TINTINVMAKES@thegameawards That's literally the point of a hypothetical. It doesn't have to happen in real life to expose a potential flaw in a principle.
You're dismissing the scenario instead of addressing the argument.