For the Anabaptists, the Platonic dualism between matter and spirit was mapped onto the New Testament contrast between the flesh and the Spirit.4 Everything external, ordered, ordinary, structured, and official was “man-made,” as opposed to the internal, spontaneous, extraordinary, informal, and individual testimony of the Spirit within. So when Immanuel Kant said that the revelation we can really trust is that which is inside us—reason and “the moral law within”—he was not following Luther but the “spirit” of enthusiasm. When he extolled “true religion”—namely, duty to the universal law we know deep down—over against “ecclesiastical faiths” with their particular creeds, miraculous claims, doctrines, and rituals, he was basically following the script of the Gnostics and the Radical medieval sects that led to the early Anabaptists. The enthusiast in all of us does not want to hear an external word, confirmed by external sacraments, submitting to the external discipline of a visible church. We want to be autonomous, extending our domain from the little throne of our own free will, works, reason, and subjective experience. Apart from God’s conquering grace, we will never allow ourselves to be told who we are by God in his law and gospel.
New episode out now looking at Calvin's clash with Pighius. I decided to have some fun and clone my voice for this episode and OH MY GOODNESS it is insanely accurate. Link to spotify link above.
"The doctrine of the Trinity is not merely a speculative doctrine. It is a doctrine of tremendous daily practical importance. It enters into the very warp and woof of our experience, if our experience is a truly Christian experience."
—R. A. Torrey, Fundamental Doctrines, p. 160
I'm slowly writing more material for the Calvin Podcast which I'm looking forward to sharing this year. In the meantime, I'm also writing about the book of common prayer. I won't be mentioning it very much on this channel but for those interested:
https://t.co/FWMwYWE3VR
@MasonSCraig That said I think LA is a legitimate outworking of the foundational commitments in Calvin's theology even if he didn't directly address it in his day.
Interesting question! The extent of the atonement wasn't a live debate in Calvin's day. He's very happy to use universal language when speaking of the atonement similar to John's gospel. But he's clear that the benefits of Christ's person and work are only of benefit to the elect.
The wait is finally over! The first message from the Credo Conference 2025 is now available at https://t.co/y8h60M5XPv. Don’t miss @mike_reeves's opening message where he says the doctrine in the Nicene creed binds us together in Christ.
Watch here: https://t.co/3lA4ndCmSy
Matt here: My apologies for the radio silence recently. I've had some unexpected health/spinal problems with a second surgery on the table but I'm looking forward to getting back in the Calvin saddle as soon as I'm able.
Thanks, the two premises it sounds like you are operating with are 1. God is a monad (alone), and 2. That Jesus is not God incarnate. Do correct me if that is not accurate.
In answer to your question about the apostolic salutations, no I don't think that Peter and Paul are concerned with affirming that God is a monad, but rather with affirming the shared communion between Jesus and the Father.
Re my own premises you are right in the sense that I have a trinitarian hermeneutic - but I would suggest that my hermeneutic is driven by questions the texts themselves open up - especially the difference-in-unity they posit between the Father and the Son.
No worries, and to you! I think you are starting from a premise and reading that premise into these texts. When Peter and Paul describe the Father as "the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ" it establishes trinitarian theology rather than undermining it. These salutations aren't concerned with polemically affirming that God is a monad as you suggest, but rather with expressing the communion and connection between Jesus and the Father, which is the root and ground of trinitarian theology.