@owenjonesjourno Sources and officials say it’s routine maintenance/patching on NSANet with no evidence of a cyberattack. Not every outage is a secret operation. Systems go down for updates.
I’m surprised you haven’t blamed it on Israel.
Labelling the whole IDF “zio-nazis” because of how they handle violent clashes doesn’t make the original claim true. The point was that shooting kids for throwing stones isn’t routine policy. Specific cases can still be criticised, but that doesn’t turn them into the normal pattern. The insult doesn’t change the evidence.
I’m not justifying shooting children for throwing stones. I’m saying the claim that it’s routine policy doesn’t match reality. Rocks can kill, a lot of the situations involve more than just stones, and the IDF doesn’t treat every stone-thrower as a target. Specific bad cases exist and can be criticised, but that still doesn’t turn them into the normal pattern. Calling people “zio-nazis” doesn’t change any of that.
Stone throwing isn’t just kids messing about. A rock can crack a skull or kill someone if it hits the right spot, and a lot of the time it’s mixed in with Molotovs, fireworks, or worse. Plenty of the “kids” in those situations are teenagers actively taking part in clashes, not bystanders.
The IDF doesn’t shoot every stone-thrower on sight — there are rules of engagement, and most cases involve live fire only when there’s a clear threat. You can still criticise specific incidents, but pretending it’s routine open season on kids for throwing stones doesn’t match how it actually plays out on the ground. And if your next move is to dig up one or two cases from a particular year, that still doesn’t turn isolated incidents into the normal pattern.
Most of the people held before 7 October were security prisoners — convicted of attacks, planning attacks, membership of groups like Hamas, or held on intelligence that they were involved in that kind of thing. The total was about 5,000 to 5,300, not tens of thousands. Around 1,200 to 1,300 of them were in administrative detention (no charge, held on security grounds). There were also some minors, mostly teenagers involved in throwing stones, Molotovs or worse.
A lot of the ones later released in swaps had been convicted of serious stuff, including murder or attempted murder. Israel has swapped people with blood on their hands for hostages or soldiers before — that’s how those deals work, it doesn’t mean the original detentions were random.
The numbers are there because of the attacks that keep happening and the groups organising them.
The 70-year ethnic cleansing thing doesn’t hold up when you look at the numbers. The Palestinian population in the West Bank and Gaza has grown massively since 1948 and 1967 — several times over in the areas under Israeli control. Actual ethnic cleansing shrinks populations, it doesn’t expand them.
On the human shields point: Hamas and Islamic Jihad have said themselves, and shown it over and over, that they put rocket launchers, tunnels, command posts and weapons stores in and under civilian buildings — hospitals, schools, houses. It’s in their own admissions and captured stuff, and you can see the pattern of launches from dense areas. That’s a war crime, and it’s the main reason civilian casualties are higher in Gaza operations than they would be otherwise.
Calling it “defending terrorists” skips the fact that the figures we’re talking about mostly come from periods when groups in Gaza were firing thousands of rockets at Israeli towns. Responding to that isn’t the same as targeting civilians. Israelis have been deliberately targeted as civilians for decades too — the gap in casualties reflects the scale of the attacks Israel was responding to, not that Palestinians weren’t carrying out violence.
And the “they hate Christ” bit: plenty of Jews and Israelis don’t. This isn’t a religious war against Christianity. Framing it that way just distracts from the actual record of rocket fire, the peace offers that were rejected, and Hamas’s stated goal of destroying Israel.
The data and the pattern of attacks are there if you want to look at them instead of slogans.
Those numbers are basically right per OCHA, but they don’t prove some unprovoked murder campaign. From 2008 up to September 2023 you’re looking at around 6,400 Palestinians killed in conflict incidents, and roughly 1,434 of them were kids. B’Tselem’s higher child count goes back further, starting in 2000.
Most of the deaths happened in the big rounds of fighting—2008-09, 2012, 2014, and 2021. Those weren’t random; they came after Hamas and Islamic Jihad fired thousands of rockets at Israeli towns. Just in 2014 it was over 4,000, and 2021 saw thousands more. They also put launchers, tunnels, and military stuff right in civilian areas on purpose.
In the West Bank a lot of the people killed were militants who were involved in or getting ready for attacks. Israelis were getting stabbed, shot at, and rammed with cars the whole time too. And there’s been plenty of Palestinians killing other Palestinians.
Just throwing out the raw totals without mentioning the constant rocket fire, the way the fighting happens in dense areas where the groups hide among civilians, or Hamas’s stated goal of destroying Israel doesn’t show one-sided slaughter. October 7 was a major step up in a campaign that had already been going on for years, not the beginning of it.
They weren’t being “murdered.” Before 7 October, Israel faced continuous rocket fire from Gaza and regular terror attacks from the West Bank.
Gaza groups fired thousands of rockets at Israeli civilians over the years — more than 4,000 in 2014, thousands more in 2021, and frequent barrages in between. Most major spikes in Palestinian deaths (2008–09, 2012, 2014, 2021) occurred during Israeli responses to those rocket campaigns and attempts to degrade the military infrastructure Hamas and Islamic Jihad deliberately embedded among civilians.
Between 2008 and September 2023, conflict-related data shows roughly 6,400 Palestinians killed versus a few hundred Israelis. The gap reflects the scale of the attacks Israel was responding to and the nature of urban fighting against groups that use human shields and place military assets in civilian areas. In the West Bank, many of those killed were militants involved in, or preparing, attacks. There was also substantial Palestinian-on-Palestinian killing (Hamas versus Fatah, internal executions, factional violence).
Israelis were regularly targeted as civilians — buses, restaurants, streets, homes — long before 7 October. Hamas and other groups openly stated their goal was Israel’s destruction, not coexistence. The low-level “routine” violence and periodic wars were the result of that rejectionism, not one-sided unprovoked slaughter.
7 October was the escalation of a long-running campaign, not the start of it.
Foreign Secretary, Palestinian leadership has repeatedly rejected two-state offers -the 1947 UN Partition Plan, Camp David 2000, and Olmert’s 2008 proposal among others. Groups like Hamas still reject Israel’s existence outright. Why frame these sanctions as ‘saving’ a solution the Palestinian side has consistently refused, while saying little about their rejectionism or the October 7 massacre?