Pied Piper? Now, I only need a crash course on the hotdog/not-hotdog app.
How to compress text to 1 bit per character | Compression is Intelligenc... https://t.co/AnFBOVvMLk via @YouTube
Don’t take my word for it, just look at the current state of affairs. People using AI already to get business or political advantage, for scamming others and posting automated internet content, and no sign of superintelligence doomsday thus far.
IMO, alignment is inherently unsolvable, in the same way human meaning is unsolvable. The question ‘aligned to who’ is posed but ignored. It is sufficient to show unsolvable.
Ryan Greenblatt – What happens once AI can automate AI research? https://t.co/m0nL7DMQWg via @YouTube
I also don’t believe that AI by its very nature will inevitably take over the world as a terminator scenario. The far more inevitable scenario is that it will be used by people against other people, both to inflict intentional harm and through competitive economic effects.
People have a tendency to return to the idea that there might be some sufficient approximation of a value-function because we have been conditioned religiously and politically to believe that morality exists as some tangible thing and they simply can’t give up that it doesn’t.
At the end of the day, take a lesson from the philosophers book. You can’t define an objective value-function that describes what is best for every living thing. Otherwise we would all be aligned with each other the meaning of life and everything.
In democratic societies, everyone has *some* responsibility on how the use of technology maximizes benefits and minimizes bad side effects.
The benefits of AI are real today, and will greatly expand in the future.
The bad side effects have, so far, been minimal.
It's on all of us to make sure it remains that way.
The catastrophe scenarios (extinction, employment apocalypse, etc) are totally ridiculous for anyone who understands how thing work in the real world.
And the p(doom) estimates are all pulled out of their authors' back ends. It makes no sense to attribute a probability to events over which we have complete agency. Whatever probability you come up with merely reveals your lack of confidence that your fellow humans will do the right thing. Confidence in humanity is one thing Geoff and I disagree on.
The other thing we disagree on is the primacy of intelligence. In the real world, intelligence is not synonymous with power and dominance. A virus, a poisonous snake, or a tiger can bring down a human. Lots of very stupid humans dominate much smarter ones (just look at the international political scene).
Superintelligent AI will work for us and do our bidding, subject to safety guardrails.
It will have no desire to take over.
I have made detailed technical proposals for AI architectures that can be made safe by satisfying safety guardrails at inference time.
I call it Objective-Driven AI Architecture.
NVIDIA letting Jensen go is a huge mistake, for America and for humanity. It's Apple firing Steve Jobs all over again, but much bigger, given the role of AI in defining the future of our world.
I've been keeping quiet on this out of respect for Jensen's family and team, who I've met and who are amazing humans, and because I personally hate infidelity. So my heart goes out to them in this difficult personal family moment.
But I can also say that Jensen is human, and makes mistakes like all of us do. Not that I matter at all, but I've known Jensen for a long time and have gotten the chance to spend a lot of time with him, behind the scenes, away from mics and cameras. I have seen him show kindness, humility, care to everyone around him, including strangers, including from the poorest most struggling parts of society, treating all the same with the same thoughtfulness and attention, because they are fellow humans and not because he has something to gain from them. That shows rare character, to maintain humility and humanity through all of it.
Another data point is what people who know him well have said privately to me about Jensen over the years. I've never had anyone tell me anything but how awesome he is or how much they love him. Probably over a thousand people at this point. This includes hundreds of engineers, CEOs, colleagues, friends, etc.
Also, since there was some spy talk. Jensen is as proud an American as it gets. I'm in shock frankly at all of this, including the mass hysteria around it. I love America, and I think NVIDIA letting Jensen go is terrible for America.
I stand with Jensen.
Love you all ❤️
@iangcarroll Anything other than perfect result is task failure IMO. Like giving a child a participation trophy for trying. Except you are giving said trophy to a piece of Silicon rock.
@elonmusk It’s so hilarious that this is ‘new insight’. Access control has been a thing since before I was born. All the companies were too busy building more complex ChatGPT 3 clones to care. You can’t create something worse than a human in error rate and not think of porting over these.
Bro we are so cooked. Linkedin, X, Insta, FB is 80, probs 90 % AI generated photo/video slop. it’s got worse every day. now at the point I know, but can’t tell.
Screw Adblock, come out with AI block…, I will be the first paying customer!!
The other thing, these are machines, why are they trying to buddy up with me. It’s not cute. I don’t try to create a reciprocal relationship with my family pet so why is my AI, a piece of code on silicon, trying to do so? It’s not human and I’m not a machine.