@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 …your philosophy, and then complain when someone applies actual legal standards. The pigeon analogy is amusing, though perhaps not quite the checkmate you imagined.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 I haven’t abandoned my Bruen argument. I’ve simply stopped repeating it because you haven’t meaningfully addressed it. And yes, I’m discussing legal terminology because you keep making legal claims. You don’t get to invoke constitutional law, redefine legal rights to suit your…
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 It’s actually quite simple: a contract creates contractual rights, a statute creates statutory rights, and the Constitution establishes constitutional rights. These are distinct, legally recognized categories. Your personal definition doesn’t invalidate them. Nice chatting ☮️
@thatERguy It’s likely true that most children you encounter aren’t walking around emaciated or in need of emergency medical care. However, there are children in both urban and rural communities who rely on subsidized school meals and might otherwise go the entire school day without eating.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 This exchange is precisely why discussing nuanced legal issues with laypeople who mistake their opinions for established law becomes a useless exercise. I just had time today.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 Because legal distinctions matter. A statutory right doesn’t stop being a right because it arises from legislation or an agreement. By your logic, contractual rights aren’t rights either. You keep substituting personal opinions for legal conclusions.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 Some CCIA provisions have been successfully challenged; others have survived judicial scrutiny. That’s a matter of actual court rulings, not how strongly either of us feels about Hochul, considering these were laws passed by the NYS Legislature of general applicability.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 particularly through excessively broad sensitive-place designations. But establishing a constitutional standard is not the same as holding that every subsequent law arguably inconsistent with that standard is unconstitutional.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 And you’re misstating the Supreme Court’s ruling. Bruen was decided before the CCIA was enacted. The Court struck down New York’s former proper-cause requirement, not “most, if not all” of a law that didn’t yet exist.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 You’re entitled to subscribe to the philosophical distinction between positive and negative rights, but that doesn’t make it the legal definition of a right. Statutory rights are still rights, even when they require someone else to fulfill a legal obligation. EMTALA is an example
@USADocumented Don’t engage in domestic violence and you can avoid orders of protection. Judges follow statutes enacted in all states protecting people from violence in homes. There’s more to this story.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 Also your claim that Second Amendment rights “cannot be taken away” is demonstrably false. The Supreme Court expressly recognized in Heller and reaffirmed in Rahimi that the right to bear arms is not absolute and that certain restrictions are constitutionally permissible.
@PoyyyP@AM_Star5 You’re confusing a philosophical theory of rights with how rights actually operate under American law. Rights can be constitutional, statutory, positive, or negative. They don’t cease being rights simply because they impose obligations on others.