@rachelbsol18@lalshareef@AbdulElSayed Unfortunately, that's like trying to convince a Klansman that blacks and Jews should have equal rights to White Christians. However, hopefully, some of the people who voted for him will hear it and will think otherwise in the next election.
Dear Senator-Elect @AbdulElSayed
What you're suggesting is that Israel should abandon its Jewish identity to qualify as a state that respects equality, dignity, and freedom. But why should Jewish self-determination be incompatible with democracy when national identity and equal citizenship can coexist?
I'm speaking to you from a Muslim to a Muslim, let me remind you that Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel is not a modern invention. Its roots go back some 3,000 years, to the time of a prophet and king whom you and I recognize in Islam: Prophet David (Dawud), peace be upon him.
Now, here's my question: There are 57 member states of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, many of which explicitly identify with Islam in their constitutions, laws, or national identities.
Why don't you demand that they abandon their religious and cultural identities? Why is the world's only Jewish state expected to surrender its Jewish character to earn your approval?
I'm not calling you a radical, Abdul. But your argument echoes a central demand of radicals who refuse to accept Jewish sovereignty under any circumstances.
For them, the problem isn't Israel's policies. It's the very existence of a sovereign Jewish state.
And history has heard this argument before...right after Alexander the Great.
More than 2,000 years ago, the Seleucid rulers tried to suppress Jewish religious life in Judea. But the Maccabees resisted, reclaimed Jerusalem, and rededicated the Temple. Their struggle eventually paved the way for renewed Jewish independence under the Hasmonean dynasty.
And do you know what Jews around the world still celebrate in remembrance of that victory? Hanukkah.
Even Jesus, whom YOU and I revere, was in Jerusalem during Hanukkah, as recorded in John 10:22–23. This is how deeply Jewish history and the struggle to preserve Jewish identity are rooted in the very traditions we respect.
Hannukah is all about a Jewish refusal to surrender their identity, faith, and freedom to foreign domination.
And here's what makes your argument particularly troubling: Israel's own Declaration of Independence explicitly promises equal social and political rights to all citizens, regardless of religion, race, or sex, while affirming Israel as the Jewish state.
We can and should demand that Israel honor that promise. We should also defend Palestinian dignity, rights, and self-determination. But none of that requires denying the Jewish people's right to national self-determination.
Equality for all citizens and Jewish sovereignty are not mutually exclusive.
History matters, Mr. Abdul. And I encourage the Jewish voters who supported you to revisit their own history and consider the implications of your words.
Peace cannot be built by asking one people to surrender the national identity we accept in so many others.
Best regards,
Loay Alshareef
Jews lived in Israel long before Muslims, and many were subsequently expelled or dispersed. So if indigeneity is your argument, Jews have an ancestral claim to the land going back thousands of years. They aren't random Europeans with no connection to it. This is not even close.
When the UN voted to partition the land in 1947, the plan provided for an Arab state and a Jewish state. Arabs living in the Jewish state would have received citizenship, equal rights, religious freedom and protections for their property, just as Jews living in the Arab state would have. Jewish leaders accepted partition. Arab leaders rejected it, and war followed.
Hundreds of thousands of Arabs fled and were displaced during the war, some were expelled, and others left expecting to return when the fighting ended. Many lost their homes and were subsequently prevented from returning. That's one of the tragic consequences of war. Meanwhile, the Arabs who remained became the foundation of Israel's Arab citizen population, which today enjoys citizenship, voting rights and religious freedom, with hundreds of mosques throughout the country. The same can't be said for Jews in Muslim countries.
Before WWI, the land had been part of the Ottoman Empire for roughly 400 years. And there had never been a sovereign Palestinian state. Of see determination was so important to the Arabs, why didn't they seek it from the Ottomans?
When the Ottoman Empire collapsed, Britain took control, and the UN eventually proposed two states. Empires fall and borders change. That doesn't mean the Jews, whose ancestral homeland this was, had no right to self-determination.
As for your claim about Israelis looking different, you should know that a substantial portion of Israel's Jewish population is Mizrahi or Sephardic, descended from communities in the Middle East and North Africa, many of whom faced severe persecution or were forced to leave and lost their homes and businesses. They often look no different from their Arab neighbors. This was never simply a case of Europeans arriving and displacing people who looked different.
And comparing Israel to Nazi Germany ignores the fundamental differences between a conflict and the Nazis' systematic extermination of Jews. Under the Nazis, the Jewish population dropped by about 35%. The Palestinian population at least tripled since 1948. That's just an absurd comparison on every level.
Finally, there are roughly 50 Muslim-majority countries, many in territories conquered by expanding Muslim empires. Islam spread through conquest across vast parts of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. If you're going to condemn historical conquest and colonization, you should at least apply the same standard consistently. Otherwise, it's hypocrisy of the highest order.
Putting aside the fact that there is no genocide, he's not dumb enough to say that explicitly, but his actions speak volumes.
Zohran Mamdani rapped in support of the Holy Land Five, convicted of providing material support to Hamas.
Repeatedly refused to condemn “Globalize the intifada.”
Refused to recognize Israel's right to exist as a Jewish state.
Linked NYPD police brutality to Israel.
Initially responded to October 7 by criticizing Israel without naming Hamas.
Revoked executive orders adopting the IHRA definition of antisemitism and restricting boycotts of Israel.
His wife, Rama Duwaji, liked posts celebrating the October 7 Hamas attacks as Palestinian resistance.
Liked posts defending demonstrations that justified Palestinian violence immediately after October 7.
Liked a post calling reports of Hamas's sexual violence a hoax.
Shared claims that Tel Aviv should never have existed.
Shared material praising Palestinian militants associated with terrorism.
Liked posts praising protesters who occupied Columbia University buildings.
I mean, why is he obsessed with Israel? Why not Darfur? His selective outage alone demonstrates his antisemitism.
For as long as I have been around, New York has made Jews feel accepted and felt safe. Your experience tracks.
I'm talking about the election of an antisemitic mayor. That said, there has been a meaningful rise in antisemitism, which is not an opinion, it's fact.
As someone who works on Wall Street, you should appreciate the data. Hate crimes are up about 15% since Mayor Mamdani took office and 53% are against Jews, despite being only 10% of the population.
As for Israel and Palestine, that's hardly the only conflict going on around the world. The reason everyone is taking about Israel and not, say, Darfur, is antisemitism plain and simple, starting with the media which amplifies and distorts every story about the conflict.
They don't. Here's some perspective: If your house is standing and the one down the block of on fire, are you going to ask why all FD's focus is on the burning house and why the news is covering that house and not yours?
This is a mayor who despises Jews, and who governs the city with the largest population of Jews outside of Israel. If he hated whatever religion or ethnicity he hated, this would be a different conversation.
@_itzsammy Actually, the pied-a-terre tax was invalidated by the court and the budget could only be balanced with an $8B bailout from the state. But whatever helps you sleep at night, knowing deep down you support a con man.