okay so this might be complete clown behavior, but hear me out.
what if Merry Go Round is telling us that the HYYH loop never actually ended?
that scene with the maknae line sitting among all those doors has been stuck in my head. if we view the doors as timelines, possibilities, or loops, then Jin entering that space feels significant. he’s finally back with them. they’re laughing, they’re together, and for a moment everything feels normal.
but then Taehyung leaves.
and that’s where my brain started spiraling.
in HYYH, Taehyung and Jin have always had a strange relationship with the timeline. Taehyung is one of the first people to realize something is wrong. his actions become the catalyst for everything that follows. if there’s a butterfly effect in HYYH, Taehyung is the butterfly.
so what if they’re still in the loop?
just not in the way we think.
throughout the MV, Jin and Taehyung stand out to me because they’re laughing more than anyone else. not in a random way, but almost like two people who know something the others don’t.
what if Taehyung has been helping maintain the loop while Jin was gone?
when Jin enters the room, Taehyung leaves because it’s his turn to rest.
almost like a shift change.
Jin has spent years carrying the burden of trying to save everyone. now he’s finally back with the members, and Taehyung is letting him enjoy that time. he’s stepping away because for the first time in a long time, Jin doesn’t have to do it alone.
but then there’s Jungkook.
and honestly, this is where the theory gets insane.
Jungkook is always watching.
in HYYH, Wings, Love Yourself, even the Fake Love trailer, he’s constantly positioned as an observer. windows, hallways, doorways, cameras. he’s always watching the story happen.
and Merry Go Round literally starts in Jungkook’s room.
what if we’ve been looking at the wrong person this entire time?
everyone assumes Jin is the one controlling the loops because he’s the one we follow.
but what if Jin is just the one who remembers them?
what if Jungkook is the one keeping them running?
Jin openly knows Taehyung. their connection is visible. but what if Jungkook has been helping Jin behind the scenes for years, so quietly that even Taehyung doesn’t fully realize it?
suddenly all the observer imagery feels different.
not someone witnessing events.
someone overseeing them.
which brings me back to Taehyung leaving when Jin arrives.
because what if Taehyung isn’t leaving out of sadness?
what if he’s leaving because he trusts that Jin is back?
because the timeline is stable.
because Jungkook is still watching. (This also brings me to a question, how is Jk always there when Yoongi is about to d*e to save him, part of it is because Jin tells him but the rest, he just happens to be there…sus)
because for once, Jin gets to laugh with the members while someone else carries the weight.
maybe I’m completely wrong.
but the more I think about it, the more Merry Go Round feels less like the end of HYYH and more like a glimpse into what happened after they learned how to survive the loop together.
In this mv, Members showed them reflecting on the years they spent separated from their real world, while asking whether the cycle that shaped them is a prison or a home.
I thought it in 3 parts.
1. The literal layer: military service
The endless corridors, identical rooms, flickering lights, repetitive movement, monochrome palette, and the carousel all mirror military life.
A merry-go-round moves constantly but never truly goes anywhere.
You wake up. Repeat the routine. Another day passes. Repeat.
The ride keeps moving, but you have no control over its speed or direction.
This is why the military imagery and carousel imagery feel fused together.
2. The psychological layer: each member confronting his own "shadow"
This is where the Jungian theory and Fake Love connections become important.
The rooms don't feel like physical locations.
They feel like internal spaces.
RM → awake room, insomnia, endless thinking.
Jimin → chasing the carousel/old memories.
Yoongi → storm, flying papers shows chaos, public scrutiny.
Jin → crossing the corridors while darkness follows him as if He's trying to get rid of smtg (pain/past self or pathetic memory) but it keeps following him. Cause The black liquid is probably not a monster.
It resembles what Jung calls the shadow: fear, guilt, loneliness, grief, exhaustion,entment.
You can leave the room.
But the shadow follows.
Notice how it never truly defeats them.
It simply exists.
That's a very BTS message.
Not "we conquered pain."
More:
★We carried it with us and kept moving.
3. The meta layer: BTS's entire career as a loop. This is where HYYH, Spring Day, YNWA, Fake Love, Monochrome, Proof, and even the solo era connect.
The carousel isn't just military service.
It's BTS itself.
A cycle of:
★debut
★growth
★success
★sacrifice
★separation
★reunion
★new beginning
over and over.
The spaceship, infinity imagery, doors, corridors, alternate rooms, and references to past eras suggest BTS are traveling through their own history.
Not escaping it.
Revisiting it.
BTS constantly open doors themselves.
Throughout their career:
HYYH
Wings
Love Yourself
Map of the Soul
Proof
now Merry Go Round
doors appear whenever a new chapter begins.
The message seems consistent:
★Nobody opened these doors for us. We walked through them ourselves.
In Merry Go Round, the doors feel like eras, memories, and possible futures.
Each room contains a different version of BTS.
Jin and Taehyung
This is the most interesting part.
If viewed through HYYH:
Taehyung is often the first to sense something is wrong.
Jin is the one burdened with correcting the timeline.
In Merry Go Round, it almost feels like a passing of responsibility.
Taehyung disappears as Jin arrives.
Not because they're enemies.
Because their roles are changing.
Almost like:
"I've been holding this place while you were gone. Now you're back."
Considering Jin was the first member discharged, this reading works both symbolically and emotionally.
Why Jimin follows the carousel?
Not because he's trapped.
Because he's afraid of losing what the carousel represents.
The carousel is:
BTS
youth
memories
togetherness
He isn't chasing a ride.
He's chasing a promise.
The same promise from Spring Day:
No matter how long winter lasts, we'll meet again.
The actual ending
This is where I disagree with the "they escaped the loop" theory.
I don't think they escaped.
I don't think they wanted to.
The final message feels closer to:
★We discovered that the loop itself wasn't the enemy.
The military years ended.
The loneliness ended.
The waiting ended.
But BTS will always be riding another merry-go-round:
new albums, new eras, new challenges, new universes.
The difference is that now they're riding it together again.
That's why the MV feels strangely hopeful despite all the darkness.
The ending doesn't say:
"The ride stopped."
It says:
"We're all back on it now."
& for BTS, that is home.
The horse is the seventh animal of the zodiac and has long symbolized strength, freedom, movement, and vitality in Korean culture.
In ancient myths & historical records horses often appear as divine messengers. They bridge worlds, carrying souls between life and the afterlife
BTS having the big dipper constellation on their bodies, at the end of the merry go round mv now, their vinyls, their concerts and literally everywhere related to them oh it’s always and forever going to be SEVEN