@derek82279649@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media This is similar to the Bill Russell vs Wilt Chamberlain conversation. Your team winning does not make you the better player. Clearly they were at least evenly matched, if not KG having the edge, but it was not TD vs KG, it was Spurs vs Wolves
@derek82279649@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media The reason is called being on the Minnesota Timberwolves
Even Duncan’s biggest proponents recognize Duncan was fortunate to go to the Spurs with Robinson and Poppovich already in place
WCF 6 game loss to LA is a big lift
Ring in 1st season outside Minnesota
@derek82279649@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media Tony Parker, Bruce Bowen and David Robinson were all better/more important than Stephen Jackson and Manu was also already better but still working his way into more minutes
@derek82279649@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media TD was physically more capable of posting up because he was stronger and heavier but he didn’t make the ball go in the basket any better in the aggregate, their TS% are neck and neck from 02-04. What separates them was their teammates and coaches.
@derek82279649@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media Timberwolves didn’t lose to LA in 04 because of KG’s scoring, that was the least of their issues. Duncan’s efficiency consistent in being just under or just over 50% with him often not* being first option. KG had to make his own shots in Minnesota. Boston KG more efficient.
@SgtSchulzED@dash_r_media@DevonBirdsong O2-03 Duncan on the left, 03-04 KG on the right
It’s an argument many have made and it’s important to note KG was marooned at a mismanaged franchise while TD was with the greatest head coach of the era on a team that could win 60% of their games with him on the bench.
@thelinedrive@DevonBirdsong 35
The narrative in the league at the time and all along has been that KG was stuck on the Wolves, he was leading a bad team, bad franchise, a team who had no chance without him. Nobody ever said that about Tim Duncan & San Antonio. They were always good, 60% win pct without him
@DevonBirdsong@dash_r_media Ultimately since he won a Ring that’s the easy and conventional take. KG was better at every individual facet of basketball. He was a better scorer, a better rebounder, a better team and individual defender who could guard all 5, and he was great on the break where TD was slow.
@dash_r_media@DevonBirdsong Duncan’s peak was 01-02 and it was weaker than KG’s peak in 03-04 by any measure. I don’t care about longevity, I care about how good a player was at their best. Duncan was an incredible player but people are putting him like #6 all time routinely and that’s too high.