@parsnipslut@migueldeicaza In Greece, we have a saying that knowing half the truth is worse than not knowing the truth at all. You are a case in point...
@akrokentrwos_2@chriszlatis αυτού του είδους τις τοποθετήσεις, τύπου κοιτάχτε πόσο ανοιχτόμυαλος είμαι τελικά φταίνε όλοι και κανένας, πρέπει πρώτες να τις λοιδορούμε ως στην καλύτερη για καφενοταξί και στην χειρότερη σκόπιμα δεκανίκια όσων δεν θέλουν να αναλάβουν τις σοβαρές ευθύνες που τους αναλογούν.
@SailorBillyBob @robbysoave That is a pretty uninformed and naive view of pretty much every country's relationship with speech at any time in history including the united states at the present moment.
@riskoriented@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave Who said that they took inspo from Greeks and not from Aquinas? It can be both you know. I don't know why you've switched to arguing over whether Aquinas read Aristotle or not (I'm pretty sure he did but it's immaterial to this discussion) when the topic about the enlightenment
@riskoriented@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave I'm confused by this, related to your earlier comment that Aquinas rediscovered free speech. Are you suggesting he was unaware of Greek thought on the matter and rediscovered something independently?
@riskoriented@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave that the Athenians didn't conceive of of (and write about) free speech, as a virtue and as a public good, which is the basis for even modern day defenses or the 1st Amendment (when balancing the individual right with other concerns).
@riskoriented@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave I think I understand your taking issue with the "Greeks invented it". You are focusing on the individual right aspect of free speech protections, which is indeed a modern invention. Even Socrates didn't have a concept of an individual right. But you are definitely wrong to say >
@riskoriented@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave Seems like a bait and switch though to talk of how many french revolutionaries knew about classical Athens. The more important point is how many french intellectuals of the enlightenment, leading up to the revolution, knew. And the answer is most likely all of them.
@riskoriented@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave I think you misunderstood my original point, which is why you think Wikipedia refutes it. I didn't say that Greeks thought free speech was a natural right. Or an individual right. It was considered an important virtue though that Athenians collectively cherished.
@Patrick_am_I@marmadukebj16@CoreyWriting@robbysoave Maybe take it easy with the policing of who should comment and who not. Why are you supposing I do not know about those decisions? Maybe explain how discussing them would impact my point?
@PersephoneK@robbysoave Did I say we shouldn't be proud of free speech protection in the US? However being proud doesn't mean one should use simplistic understandings to disparage others who have differing approaches.