Critical thinking, if it means anything, means not just questioning the theories you doubt, but also those you subscribe to - not just thinking about why others might be wrong, but why *you* might be too
@ZvonimirFras@paulg@wyounas I sometimes find that reading the same text in different formats can reveal weaker points. Sometimes I email stuff to myself so I can read it on my phone, as alternative to printing out, eg if I'm on the move.
@paulg Same applies to speeches/ presentation scripts. When read out loud to oneself, often whilst walking around. (But: only off printed version, and with pen in hand!)
"When we allow ourselves to be over-influenced by those with an agenda, we erode our free will and that is the gradual erosion of a free society."
From 'How Spies Think: Ten Lessons in Intelligence' (2020)
Timely words from Sir David Omand:
"... the values that give legitimacy to liberal democracy: the rule of law; tolerance; the use of reason in public affairs and the search for rational explanations of the world around us; and our ability to make free and informed choices. 1/2
@ahaspel There is something to that. I've found when people are naturally good at something, they tend to be puzzled that others aren't. In fact that's probably a good way to tell what you're good at. What do other people seem puzzlingly bad at? (Being right doesn't count.)
Interesting how an apparently innocent yet stupid belief is found alongside a deeply abhorrent stupid belief. (Something about the way they both float free of good sense and reason, that enables one to coalesce in the same minds with the other?)
๐จ"one of the first questions Iโd find myself asking a flat earther who approached me after an event was what they thought about the Holocaust. After more than 40 lectures, and dozens of flat earth audience members, I met only two who believed the Holocaust was a real event."๐ฑ
@KurtisScaletta@jedshug @vin34dmb Have no idea if you work in academia so not aimed at you
However what ppl in academia need to realise is how this looks from outside
Our experience is of creeping problem of intolerance (perhaps exacerbated by S-M)
We then see an article complaining about this
We think: -
Of course we want a society in which people do not say cruel, hurtful, evil things.
But we would rather achieve that via persuasion and education -- to make people voluntarily accept those limits -- rather than coerce them if we can.
@hyperplanes This still the best suggestion I've heard so far (perhaps it's old news now and there are better ideas doing the rounds)
https://t.co/fvjF8fKE4J
@DreadPhil1@PhillipsPOBrien Heard what seemed to me a v good suggestion by a US historian on BBC radio yesterday: somehow guaranteeing Ukraine not joining NATO
(obvs Ukraine may not like this and its a bit of a weak victory for Putin compared to fully taking over Ukraine, but perhaps offers him something?)
@KurtisScaletta@jedshug @vin34dmb This is at v least *plausible*
We then see thread after thread angrily or snarkily deriding it
This helps create an impression looking in that is perhaps not one you (speaking figuratively here) actually desire
@KurtisScaletta@jedshug @vin34dmb Have no idea if you work in academia so not aimed at you
However what ppl in academia need to realise is how this looks from outside
Our experience is of creeping problem of intolerance (perhaps exacerbated by S-M)
We then see an article complaining about this
We think: -
@Seahag4life @DreadPhil1@PhillipsPOBrien I'm not sure that is what he really wants. What he wants (i believe) is to possess Ukraine, integrate it into greater Russia. As I understand it, the NATO thing was a bit of a red herring. But it means he can save face by making out he got something he wanted.
@Seahag4life @DreadPhil1@PhillipsPOBrien Sure, although I wasn't talking about what they're *justified* in doing so much as what could actually offer a way out. Pure pragmatism.
@itaisher (Have even seen the word 'weirdos' used in one thread as a way of referring to ppl who claim they like to debate everything. I was surprised that this was deemed appropriate coming from ppl who I presume consider themselves progressive!)
@itaisher Not in academia so can't comment re prevalence, but what strikes me from a lot of objections to this is that this is minority view and therefore can be dismissed as absurd. Surely even if it were a minority view, that doesn't mean it ought to be ridiculed.