It was not chance. That is what makes it break my heart even more.
That pin started with Tam Amber. He carved it for Maysilee. She wore it into the 50th Games. When she died, it went back to her family, and years later her niece Madge gave it to Katniss.
So when Haymitch sees Katniss wearing it on reaping day, he is not just seeing a random girl with a pretty pin. He is seeing the girl who just volunteered for her little sister, wearing his dead best friend's pin, the pin from the girl who died trying to protect him.
Of course he thought it was a sign. Maysilee was the moral compass of his Games. She was the one who kept him human. And now here is this girl, doing the exact thing Maysilee would have done, wearing her pin.
It is Collins telling us the rebellion was never just Katniss. It was Tam Amber, and Maysilee, and Haymitch, and all the people who came before her, passing that one small act of defiance down until it finally landed on the right person.
Haymitch did not fight for Katniss at first. He fought because for a second, he thought his sister in everything but blood was telling him to try again.
Encouraging gamers to be empathetic on top of making them learn how to maintain a relationship means it might actually be the greatest Trojan Horse of all time.