@ericomtavares@DanBurmawy You have to believe in a single god and Mohammed was his messenger, who transcribed the Qaran exactly as God intended. That's a lot easier to grasp than Jesus being God himself and that the god of the Holy Spirit compelled his followers to write the Bible separately.
@ericomtavares@DanBurmawy Islam doesn't claim Mohammed is God. Christians claim that Jesus is God but different to the god in heaven and that the Holy Spirit (that's also God but different to Jesus and the god in heaven) inspired the Bible.
@AllisonPearson The youth mobility scheme is to work for a max of 2 years. And it goes both ways, British youth can travel the other way.
There are more opportunities for British youth in Denmark, Belgium, Holland, Germany and Norway. And they don't even expect you to learn the language.
@FalloutOfLine@CatholicAce@rovabtw This is not evidence of the existence of race. You can accurately differentiate the heart/lungs of a black person from a white person, but that's because blacks usually live in cities where the air quality is poorer, hence different development.
@SarahLudford The gender-critical movement set up the essentialist trap that the racists are now using to further their cause.
Who could have predicted that!
@edworx1@LiamDeacon Why has he lost his ethnic identity? Could it be that your ancestry doesn't dictate how strongly you identify with a nation, and it's more about where you grow up?
@edworx1@LiamDeacon Argentina demonstrates why ancestry definitions don't work. What's MacAllister's ethnic identity? If it's ancestral ties then he should feel the British Isles are his homeland, right?
Should he be ticking White British in our census? Is he an immigrant to the UK or is he native?
@edworx1@LiamDeacon Because what you're saying is ludicrous to the point of making the concept meaningless. Do you actually think he thinks of himself as ethnically British? Or is it more likely he just considers himself Argentine?
@edworx1@LiamDeacon So if you moved to Spain and your children spoke Spanish, practised catholicism, ate paella and tapas every day of their lives and supported Real Madrid then they wouldn't be even a tiny bit Spanish? They would be as 100% English as if they'd grown up in Norfolk?
@edworx1@LiamDeacon But he's not in any meaningful sense British. He doesn't think he's British, nobody in Argentina thinks he's British, nobody in Britain thinks he's British.
@daveyravine@edworx1@LiamDeacon For the Jews it's about a common religion - both language and geography are irrelevant.
For Native Americans, it's about common historical experience of colonialism despite different ancestry, geography, religion and language.
For most nations, it's a mixed of all these things.
@daveyravine@edworx1@LiamDeacon In Eastern Europe ethnicity is defined by language. If you're of Polish ancestry but can't speak the language then you ain't Polish.
But for the Swiss, language is irrelevant -you can speak any language and be Swiss. It's about Alpine geography.
@cfdownes_ This is just really fucking weird mate. I thought the problem you had with migrants is because they have a different culture and don't assimilate?
Now you're saying any culture can be English if the people have English ancestry?
Batshit, the lot of yous.
@RupertLowe10 Since when is "Northern Irish" a historic ethnic identity? The two communities hate each other. In Northern Ireland you're either Irish or British, that's it. Not "Northern Irish".
@edworx1@LiamDeacon Most of us consider English to be growing up in the same English towns, going to the same schools, following the same football team, speaking the same language etc to be what we have in common with each other, not because our ancestors fought together in the Battle of Brunanbuhr
@edworx1@LiamDeacon Native American simply denotes anyone who was living in America on 11 October 1492 and the people descended from them. What they have in common is that they predate Christopher Columbus. That's all they have in common with each other.