It is my job to vote on items presented at council. I am also not going to rubber stamp everything that crosses the desk. Even if it is 14 - 1 vote.
Also you made a wild comment about not taking transit as an hvac technician. How is it proving your point that taking transit is not a sane thing to do considering the nature of the trade... that might be the wildest take I have ever seen on any platform.
Council wrap-up, Tue Nov 17. Full agenda completed in one day.
AGENDA AND MINUTES
• Two urgent CAO items added and Oct 20/27 minutes confirmed, both 14-0. No question period held.
CONSENT AGENDA (carried 14-0)
• Fieldhouse committee: Dec 18 meeting date set
• Open drug use rules: deferred to January 2027
• Community association charitable program: deferred to early 2027
• Downtown police station: deferred to early 2027
• Transit security pilot ($9M): sent back for a full accounting
• Green Line design ($16.6M): to be decided in the budget
• Off-site levies: new bylaw to a March 2027 hearing
ITEMS PULLED FOR SEPARATE VOTES
• Disaster risk report
Calgary averages about $700M a year in insured disaster losses. Received 15-0.
• MAX Green bus rapid transit
Directs a report by mid-2027 on curbside transit-only lanes from Keystone Hills to downtown, about $511M. Bus lanes on Centre St N would affect parking, loading and business access. Carried 12-3.
✅ For (12): Farkas, Tyers, Wyness, Yule, Kelly, Dhaliwal, Pantazopoulos, Atkinson, Schmidt, Clark, Ward, McLean
❌ Against (3): Johnston, Jamieson, Chabot
❗ Why no: The north needs a train line, not BRT. This is time and effort better spent getting the north Green Line in the queue as soon as possible.
• Transit-oriented development funding
Continues work on a levy model directing future property tax growth at CMLC transit sites to pay for infrastructure and parking there. Carried 11-4.
✅ For (11): Farkas, Tyers, Yule, Kelly, Dhaliwal, Pantazopoulos, Atkinson, Schmidt, Clark, Chabot, Ward
❌ Against (4): Johnston, Wyness, McLean, Jamieson
❗ Why no: This subsidizes private companies and disrupts the market. Let the market decide and get government out of the way.
• Prairie Economic Gateway committee seat
Governance only. Carried 15-0.
NOTICES OF MOTION
• Back-alley repair
Directs a framework to assess paved back lanes, with repair options from owner cost-sharing to City budget funding. Carried 14-1.
✅ For (14): Farkas, Tyers, Wyness, Yule, Kelly, Dhaliwal, Pantazopoulos, Atkinson, Schmidt, Clark, Chabot, Ward, Jamieson, McLean
❌ Against (1): Johnston
❗ Why no: A framework to resurface back alleys already exists.
• Large data centres
Directs bylaw changes by March 2027 giving council the power to pause applications in new and emerging sectors, aimed at large data centres. Carried 13-2.
✅ For (13): Farkas, Tyers, Wyness, Yule, Kelly, Dhaliwal, Pantazopoulos, Schmidt, Clark, Chabot, Ward, Jamieson, McLean
❌ Against (2): Johnston, Atkinson
❗ Why no: Council shouldn't hold a moratorium on any industry that has existed for decades in Calgary. Calgary Economic Development is telling people Calgary is open for business, but council is sending the opposite message.
The rest of the motion (define data centres, report on risks and water security) carried 15-0.
• Housing redevelopment (HARP)
Directs a study of redeveloping publicly owned housing sites. Funding options include municipal debt, property tax increment and a revitalization levy. No cost estimate provided. Carried 8-7.
✅ For (8): Farkas, Atkinson, Pantazopoulos, Schmidt, Yule, Kelly, Clark, Dhaliwal
❌ Against (7): Johnston, Ward, Tyers, Wyness, McLean, Jamieson, Chabot
❗ Why no: This creates a City housing bureaucracy that will cannibalize the market.
• Non-profit space
Directs a framework to lease City space to non-profits and community groups at below-market rates. Carried 11-4.
✅ For (11): Farkas, Tyers, Wyness, Yule, Kelly, Dhaliwal, Pantazopoulos, Atkinson, Schmidt, Clark, Ward
❌ Against (4): Johnston, McLean, Jamieson, Chabot
❗ Why no: Libraries already have plenty of space to host non-profits. City offices should be filled with City employees first. Too many staff work from home while Calgarians are told to come downtown to live and work.
CAO recruitment moved to its next stage. An inquiry on gambling ads in City spaces was tabled.
#yyccc #yyc
MAX Green: A report on a $511M+ curbside BRT (with options up to $2B) is not a plan. The north needs a funded train in the queue, not another expensive bus study that delays the real solution.
TOD levy: Directing future tax growth at CMLC sites to cover their own infrastructure and parking is still a special funding mechanism that expands CMLC’s role. We need to end the scope creep, not institutionalize it.
Back alleys: The current process already exists, residents who want a paved alley can organize enough signatures from their neighbours and cost-share the work. It’s a local luxury, not a city-wide obligation. Streets that chose not to pave shouldn’t be forced to subsidize those that did.
Data centres: Single-pass water cooling is already banned in Calgary. New installations connected to the City’s water supply are prohibited. Modern designs use closed-loop or air cooling. A new pause power is regulatory overreach on top of existing rules, not common sense.
HARP: The study already came to council in September. It risks displacing hundreds of existing low-income residents to clear land for subsidized redevelopment that benefits developers. We’ve seen this movie with Midfield I won’t support another version of it.
Non-profit space: The City already has limited resources and core responsibilities. Municipal buildings should be occupied by municipal staff doing municipal work. Work-from-home policy is a separate issue; under-pricing City space for external groups is not the priority.
Six votes against expanding spending, scope, and risk without clear taxpayer benefit. That’s accountability, not “bullshit.”
That is procdure to pull items to vote against or to reflect a vote from committee, no debate is necessary... also....it would be pretty difficult to carry a 90 pound furnace, 150 pound ac, an evap coil, 60 feet of venting, chimney liner, fittings, lineset, 40 lb roll of wire, condenser pad and hundreds of hand and power tools on a bus or train.....
I accept my staffs stance on the music industry. Doesn't change the fact that we need to find cuts across the board to make Calgary more affordable. I would love to hear your ideas of other areas we could cut if you think the arts are essential. Here is the link to the proposed budget. Let me know what you find. https://t.co/H2lw8CMX4h
The same argument gets made for almost any government spending. It still comes down to whether arts operating grants are essential right now, with a 15% property tax hike and higher water rates on the table, while we catch up on core MGA priorities like roads, water, and public safety. We can cut or pause the discretionary subsidies. The private creative sector will keep going without them.
Arts. Are they essential?
Calgary's published arts funding for 2026 comes to about $28.5 million. That covers the arts development authority grant, operating grants to two major arts venues, and the public art program.
The proposed 2027–2030 budget does not show what that number becomes. Arts is folded into a larger civic partners total that also includes libraries, sport and tourism, rising from $154.3 million in 2026 to $208.6 million by 2030.
Before council decides whether to maintain, cut or increase arts funding, the first question is whether it is an essential service or a priority at all. Water, roads, transit and public safety keep a city running.
With property taxes and water rates both going up, every dollar outside those core services deserves a hard look. #yyccc #yyc
Budget deliberations start next week. I will be bringing enough amendments to drop the overall taxes for Calgarians while protecting essential services. I figured it would be good to get an idea of what is essential vs non-essential when we are facing the largest tax increases since the 90's.
Just today my staff and I were making plans to meet with the local school trustee and NDP MLA on getting a long overdue school built in the ward. We are also trying to figure out how another non ucp mla was able to get a sound barrier built for there community. As a councillor I am not married to a party or an ideology and will always accept good advice no matter the source. I believe I made that clear as well with nate that we have to be better at finding common ground to do better for everyone.
I guess I would ask you if would you make the same case if you learned that other political staffers at cityhall are close to other political parties? The thing is that all my staffers were chosen on the fact they live in the ward and they put customer service first. I don't care who there friends are.
I seriously appreciate the questions. I can't tell you who authorized the attendances within any meeting with the ab government. My employee wanted to go on a vacation and that is where my involvement ended. She was not representing my office at the event. I apologize if I did not portray that clearly enough in the interview.
As for the confidential leaks. I still fully believe if the minister were to have investigated the case he would have seen that the documents should have never been identified as confidential in the first place. That is the abuse of the system that I was trying to draw attention to and to hopefully get fixed. Even if it meant dealing with the consequences.
Civic Partners.
City funding for Civic Partners, the independent groups that run libraries, arts venues, the zoo, tourism, economic development and other programs, is proposed to grow from $151 million in 2026 to $191 million by 2030 in operating grants alone. The overall Civic Partners budget reaches $209 million.
On top of that is $245 million in capital over four years. Most of it sits in pools that don't name which organizations will receive the money, including a $60 million major partners fund and a $44 million grant for nine unnamed partners.
How should council prioritize the spending on these civic partners? Should we revisit the civic partners as whole?
#yyccc #yyc
City Council and many City events have opened with land acknowledgements for over a decade.
These are framed as showing respect and supporting learning. They take time in every meeting and appear in reports, parks, and programs.
Have they achieved the intended results; better understanding, practical partnerships, measurable outcomes, or have the become routine?
Is it time to end them or potentially limit them to one deliberate time a year (e.g., National Day for Truth and Reconciliation or Treaty 7 anniversary) and focus energy on concrete results instead? Does ending LA put us in reverse or is it the next step in the process?