I'll be happy to help you and (many others) understand the point of a Sign Language interpreter even if a video has subtitles.
It is like saying what is the point of:
- Music if I can read the lyrics
- Watching TV or Movies if I can read the script
- a Phone call if I can just text
(other analogies)
- Eating Ramen if i can just have pasta
- Driving a Tesla if I can just drive any car
- Starlink, if I have dial up internet
The difference is the experience.
Subtitles are great tool, but it's hard to compete with spoken words that convey, context, feelings, jokes and sarcasm through "Tone of voice".
Sign Language interpretation provides "Tone of Voice" visually and in a 3D communication style that encapsulates what the speaker is trying to convey.
I hope this helps bring a little more understanding about the difference between subtitles and a Sign Language Interpreter.
@1NativeSoilNerd Last week, our faculty started plans to hire consultants to review our materials, to ensure they are culturally appropriate & we didn’t overlook something. That’s too much to ask of students for free—that would feel exploitive. #PowerDynamics
@_noahbuchholz Powerful image! May we use this when discussing the Deaf experience/culture with students in Idaho State U’s sign language studies and interpreting programs? @ESchniedewind@curt_radford
@Robb4DC@tamdmvo Love this. Generally, I don’t use my voice when traveling or out with Deaf family or friends. Always willing to if fam/friends indicate they’d prefer something interpreted, but my voice is not for hearing people’s convenience.
Here's the interview with captions!
"For the 1st time in history, the @WhiteHouse has full-time ASL interpreters who help bring the president's message to everyone. @edokeefe takes a behind-the-scenes look at the women providing this important service." https://t.co/8xQf0UEEw1
Pretty striking that even today in Kyiv, the Ukrainian government press conference had sign language interpretation. Something the UK government still can’t seem to manage.
@meganmajocha As interpreter, this happens often (unsolicited). I redirect with a friendly smile, “That was __’s presentation; all accolades are theirs. I’ll interpret so you can let them know…” I’m in the kill-with-kindness camp; do you recommend a different approach?
@Swilua @surliertexan @peatonx@MarkJEngleson@HelenaMontana14@JellybeanNco I teach interpreting; most of my students have no idea how to dress for where they will work. During the course I teach about a smorgasbord of interpreting settings, we take class time to discuss professional appearance for each of those settings. Grads say it’s helpful.
@MarieCoppola68 We are about to open one, but I’m having a hard time convincing administration the salary they want to offer is too low. Are you including salary/range in the announcement? Looking for comparisons we can provide
Pls share-ISU hiring Deaf project manager for recently awarded grant. Full-time, remote, 5-year temp position with benefits. Hopes to secure ongoing position funding. https://t.co/GMDagdD9rJ
@VegHistory When we’re using ASL, it’s distracting to students who can hear if it’s noisy in the hall. It’s usually construction noise in our building.