Oban Times last week covered the ongoing saga of Argyll & Bute Council's plans to put traffic lights at the historic Clachan Bridge, which some people think will defile a national monument.
Visitor levy and why it would damage Argyll & Bute. Nothing material has changed, so there is no need for a 2nd consultation. https://t.co/Ne8hquJi1G
Argyll & Bute Council's traffic light works on Clachan Bridge described as a 'profanation' by French press. And they are right! It's a defilement of a national monument.
Activist: "Your cows are putting carbon into the atmosphere."
Farmer: "Where did they get it?"
Activist: "What?"
Farmer: "The carbon. Where did the cow get it before it put it anywhere."
Activist: "From... eating?"
Farmer: "From eating grass. And where did the grass get it."
Activist: "The soil?"
Farmer: "The air. The grass pulled it out of the air last spring. The cow ate the grass. The cow breathed some of it back out. It went back into the air it came from."
Activist: "But it's still going into the atmosphere."
Farmer: "It's going back. There's a difference between a thing going somewhere and a thing going back. You've described a circle and you're frightened of it."
Activist: "Then just don't have the cow."
Farmer: "The grass still dies in autumn. It rots where it falls. The carbon goes back into the air either way, just without anyone getting fed in the middle."
Activist: "It's not that simple."
Farmer: "It's grass, cow, breath, grass. Or it's grass, rot, air, grass. Same circle, fewer dinners. If that's complicated for you I'd stay away from the water cycle. That one's got clouds in it."
Fiona Campbell MBE, Chief Executive of @ASSCnews, said: “There is zero evidence that Planning Control Areas increase affordable housing, reduce rents, or solve the housing crisis. None.
"@HighlandCouncil is attempting to sell the public a fantasy through this sham consultation while knowingly risking enormous damage to local tourism economies and small businesses.
"This is not evidence-based policymaking, it is political theatre."
The ASSC also accused Highland Council of disregarding established legal precedent.
"Despite repeated public assurances from councillors that existing operators have nothing to fear, the ASSC has spoken directly with officials who remain adamant that any secondary let within a control area will require planning permission because of mandatory Condition 13 attached to short-term let licensing."
This position flies directly in the face of the landmark Muirhead judicial review from 2023, which was successfully argued before the Court of Session.
If Highland Council requires 24,000 new homes across the Highlands by 2034, repurpose the 7,500 economically impotent empty homes and build some new ones. Don't damage a sector that represents £200m to the local economy!
https://t.co/PGyQ7OSZOv
#Scapegoating #Disingenuous #Unlawful #JudicialReview #LegalAction
@H_F_S@st_alliance@scothospgroup@SaveSCScotland
@FionaCampbell74 A@BC regards STLs as 'ineffective stock' “... 421 have been brought back into active use (sold, let or occupied as a main home)…” and “13% of dwellings remain “ineffective stock”, including empty homes and self-catering conversions.”
@FionaCampbell74@JackHouse My one is regarded as a second home by Argyll & Bute Council, appears on their stats as a second home, and I pay council tax not NDR, and I occasionally rent it out via Airbnb.
@FionaCampbell74@Ross_Greer ScotGov's national study on 2nd & holiday homes in rural Scotland reported that residents often believed second homes were a main cause of housing problems, but data showed that the real drivers were demographic change, low build rates, and limited economic opportunity.