@MagnusLSchmidt Fair. I wouldn't sell anyone on the backlinks either. The useful part is getting found where people browse for tools, and catching weak copy before the big launch.
Before you launch on Product Hunt, get listed on 5β10 smaller directories first. You get early reviews, a few backlinks, and you find the bugs in your copy before the big day.
@Ionkosm@patrick_kuhnke_ Tip from doing this at volume: check each one's robots.txt and whether listings are indexed (site: search) before filling the form. Lots of the 100+ are dead or noindex the free tier. Happy to share our checked list if useful. (I run ListedProof.)
@ahab_developer@emaann28 Honest answer: almost none bring buyers directly unless they're category sites your buyers browse (e.g. a Mac app directory for a Mac app). General launch boards mostly bring other founders. (I run ListedProof, a submission service, and tell customers that up front.)
@mynameisaniket@alexwestco Mostly not traffic. They're the third-party pages search engines and AI assistants read to confirm you exist. A handful with real communities send launch-day visitors. Anyone selling them as a traffic channel is overselling (I sell submissions, and I'd say the same).