@ultramiraculous@GergelyOrosz I agree that's legitimate criticism, it's kinda wild they didn't do this. But it only protects against other users on the same machine, and only if disk encryption is enabled (if not they can access disk contents anyway). Does not help against malware. Just for context.
@GergelyOrosz No worries, appreciate the discussion too! It definitely makes things worse incrementally but mostly just reflects the existing (outdated) permission model in Windows. Wish there was more nuance in coverage, but on the other hand the spotlight may lead to change for the better.
@GergelyOrosz Oh and I'm actually sympathetic to the view that the increased amount of info that Recall makes available does present a security risk, but that's also an argument against using a local email client which stores your emails offline. Yet I'm not sure this is a guideline anywhere.
@GergelyOrosz Is this terrible optics? Yes. Did they make stupid mistakes? Yes (e.g. no opt-in, no encryption, no handling for PII or private tabs). But ultimately this is mostly bad optics and less serious security risk. If you have malware you are fucked anyway.
@GergelyOrosz I hope we get better access controls in Windows out of this, as the permission model is really quite outdated (system files are locked down but private user data isn't), but I hope this backlash won't lead to the system being completely locked down like mobile.
@GergelyOrosz Yes there are issues in this regard, and they should've handled it better. But it's the status quo. Sensitive info? Cookies. Credit cards? Saved in auto-fill. Credentials? Shell history. All in plain text. If you get malware on your desktop OS, everything is tainted.
@GergelyOrosz For example Google location history is super cool and useful (I looked into third-party apps doing this but they all sucked in comparison) but if they announced it today it would be torn to shreds. Once a journalist writes a big expose on it it will probably be gone.
@GergelyOrosz At this point big tech companies literally cannot implement normal useful features anymore without getting huge amounts of backlash unless it's 100% perfect and secure and there's no potential for abuse. Even if they are not really at fault.
@GergelyOrosz I think I remember it being killed but it was after I stopped using it because I switched away from WP.
The HTC weather animations were always my favorite, Weather Flow kinda came close. Everything else looks bad in comparison but meh, just using the stock Samsung app nowadays.
@GergelyOrosz Not unexpected for Win32 stuff but yeah kinda surprised that they bothered for WinRT apps. Not like there were ever many high-quality ones. Really liked your Weather Flow app from back in the day though 👍
@AthanSpod @danluu Well I'll happily swallow that cost on my end if it allows people to get a little side income from their passion projects, or corporations to provide useful services for no additional charge.
@frioux@danluu No, that was the right tweet. My principle is people put stuff on the web for free, with ads being their source of income, I respect that and will not deny them that. Apart from super sketchy sites that I don't regularly visit anyway I find ads to be a minor inconvenience.
@danluu I don't use ad blockers out of principle 🤷♂️ I find it very weird how ads are seen as this super evil thing by so many people. And I doubt disadvantaged folks would be better off having to pay to use Google. In fact ads being annoying screams first-world problem to me.