그래요 니가 하는게 캐 비판이고 ㅈㄴ쓸모없는데 뭐라도 되는척 가상의 인물에게 도덕적 잣대 들이밀면서 안격척.하는거 너무너무 찐따같은거 인정하셨으면 됐습니다 이와중에도 욕들으셨다고 많이 슬프신가본데 그런 정신머리로 트위터에서 캐 비판 잘 해나가실지 정말 걱정이 되는 마음이네요
One of the most ironic details in Harry Potter is that Snape’s attempt to save Lily may have created the exact circumstances that destroyed Voldemort. Snape begged Voldemort to spare Lily after learning that the prophecy had put her and her family in danger. Voldemort ultimately honored that request enough to give Lily multiple opportunities to step aside when he reached the Potters’ house. James was killed immediately because Voldemort had no reason to spare him, but Lily was different: Voldemort explicitly wanted her out of the way rather than dead. The books make clear that this choice mattered, because Lily’s death became a willing sacrifice rather than simply an ordinary murder.
And that is where the irony becomes almost perfect. Lily refused every chance to save herself and placed herself between Voldemort and Harry, triggering the ancient protection that caused the Killing Curse to rebound. Harry survived, Voldemort lost his body, and the chain of events that eventually destroyed him began that night. Even the official Wizarding World has pointed out the possibility that Snape’s plea inadvertently caused his own master’s downfall. Snape wasn't planning some masterstroke he wanted Lily alive, nothing more. But Voldemort's decision to honor one Death Eater's personal request gave Lily the choice that made her sacrifice possible. Snape asked Voldemort to spare Lily. Voldemort granted the request. Lily chose Harry. And that choice ultimately created the boy who would destroy Voldemort.
essa cena me surpreende até hoje.
voldemort, além de ser um dos bruxos mais poderosos e perigosos, tinha o dom de ler mentes e mesmo assim não conseguiu perceber que a narcissa mentiu.
essa cena me destrói sério, o harry querendo continuar sob o efeito dos dementadores de uma forma quase masoquista porque estava descobrindo as memórias dos pais dele morrendo e para ele isso era melhor do que não ter nada.........
Hermione waited 7 whole years just to drop this exact line back on him: 😂
(Harry, Ron, and Hermione arrive panting at the Whomping Willow, dodging its swiping branches as Harry searches for the knot on the trunk.)
Ron: “How..how’re we going to get in? I can see the place, if we just had Crookshanks again”
Hermione: “Crookshanks? Are you a wizard, or what?”
Ron: “Oh right, yeah”
I can only imagine the relief and triumph Dumbledore must have felt when he realized Voldemort had used Harry’s blood.
Harry tells him that Voldemort said his blood would make him stronger because it carried the protection Lily left in him meaning Voldemort could finally touch Harry without being hurt.
And for just a fleeting moment, Harry notices something like triumph in Dumbledore’s eyes.
Then it’s gone.
Because by this point, Dumbledore already had the diary, knew Voldemort had made a Horcrux, and strongly suspected there were more. He was already putting the pieces together.
I can’t help but wonder if Dumbledore had started considering the possibility that Harry himself might be a Horcrux and that destroying Voldemort might ultimately require Harry to die too.
Then Voldemort made the one mistake Dumbledore needed.
He used Harry’s blood to resurrect himself.
And suddenly, Harry’s survival became possible.
That tiny gleam of triumph in Dumbledore’s eyes hits very differently when you know what he was probably beginning to understand.
영화에서 다 짤려서 그런듯
해리 말포이 첫만남은 말포이가 친구신청 거절당해 마상인게 아니라 해리가 패드립당해 마상인 지점이고ㅠ
납작분류법의 예외를 엄청 많이 보여줬음
1권에서 슬리데린만은 안돼!했던 해리가 나중엔 자기 아들한테 슬데도 좋은데라고 말해주게 됐다는 점이 좋아
This is such an important reading of the series because Harry’s hatred of Slytherin begins before he has any real experience with what Slytherin actually is.
His first real introduction to the house is Draco Malfoy, a boy who immediately insults Ron and treats Harry like a celebrity he can recruit. Then Harry meets Snape, hears that Voldemort was a Slytherin and spends years watching the story place most of its villains in green and silver. Of course Harry and by extension the reader learns to associate Slytherin with danger.
But the books themselves constantly prove that the House isn’t the problem. Pettigrew was a Gryffindor. Quirrell was a Ravenclaw. Lockhart was a Ravenclaw. Slughorn, Regulus, Narcissa and even Snape show completely different sides of what a Slytherin can be. Ambition and self-preservation aren’t evil. They’re just traits that become dangerous depending on what someone chooses to do with them.
And that’s why the Battle of Hogwarts criticism is so uncomfortable. The series spends years teaching us that judging people by their House is shallow, then gives us a moment where Slytherin students are essentially treated as a collective threat. The Sorting Hat never created good people and bad people. The wizarding world just became very comfortable pretending it did.
This is such an important reading of the series because Harry’s hatred of Slytherin begins before he has any real experience with what Slytherin actually is.
His first real introduction to the house is Draco Malfoy, a boy who immediately insults Ron and treats Harry like a celebrity he can recruit. Then Harry meets Snape, hears that Voldemort was a Slytherin and spends years watching the story place most of its villains in green and silver. Of course Harry and by extension the reader learns to associate Slytherin with danger.
But the books themselves constantly prove that the House isn’t the problem. Pettigrew was a Gryffindor. Quirrell was a Ravenclaw. Lockhart was a Ravenclaw. Slughorn, Regulus, Narcissa and even Snape show completely different sides of what a Slytherin can be. Ambition and self-preservation aren’t evil. They’re just traits that become dangerous depending on what someone chooses to do with them.
And that’s why the Battle of Hogwarts criticism is so uncomfortable. The series spends years teaching us that judging people by their House is shallow, then gives us a moment where Slytherin students are essentially treated as a collective threat. The Sorting Hat never created good people and bad people. The wizarding world just became very comfortable pretending it did.