The targeting foul against @zackorr20 of @football_ncc has been overturned, and he will be eligible to start in Saturday's #d3fb National Semifinal vs. @SURiverHawksFB at 3:30pm EST / 2:30pm CST.
I spoke with Steve Shaw, the NCAA's National Coordinator of Officials, about the overturn this morning. Note that the provision in question is whether or not @_SCFootball QB Drew Heenan qualified under the rules as a "defenseless player," as the following is one such definition in the NCAA Football Rulebook: "A ball carrier already in the grasp of an opponent and whose forward progress has been stopped." If a defenseless player is hit in the neck or head region by an opponent, then targeting is a proper call under the rules. Steve said:
“We’re very clear that he's not defenseless until he is down. And if you go back and look at the video on the play…he's wrapped up and he's going down. And the contact is with [the] runner just as he's going to the ground.
So he really has not transitioned to a defenseless player yet. You know, you can make the argument that, well, if he's wrapped up, he's defenseless and he can't really defend himself. But from a replay perspective, we needed a bright line that that was not a judgment, but a bright line.
And that is, [he] has to be down, considered down before he's defenseless….He's just beginning to go down and be down.
And so we wouldn't consider him down at the time that he's hit. And there's no crown of the helmet involved. The helmet is clearly to the side.
And so, from a replay perspective, rules are very clear. You've got to be able to confirm all aspects of targeting for it to be targeting.
You couldn't confirm that he was down and then hit. So we didn't give him defenseless status....And that's why the targeting was overturned.”
Steve also taught me about something that is important. While regular replay reviews can come out as "confirmed," "overturned," or "stands" (which means that there is not conclusive evidence to overturn, but there isn't a full confirmation of the original call either), targeting calls do not have a "stands" option when they are reviewed. In other words, they are viewed anew and either every element necessary for targeting must be confirmed, or it is overturned. Think of it as being innocent until proven guilty in the review process for targeting.
In this case, he was clear to underscore that the elements could have been argued to have existed, but it would have, at best, been a "call stands" decision, which is not sufficient to uphold a targeting call.
Steve also expressed the hopes that the instant replay model that has been developed and used in Division 2 will become more utilized in Division 3, related to more-universal instant replay using a coaches' challenge approach (except for targeting), much like we saw in the Centennial Conference this year. He understands the challenges, but he also feels that having two HD camera angles plus the normal web stream (basically at least three cameras) is sufficient to embrace the needs of instant replay. He is not in favor of a D1 type of replay at the lower levels because of the desire to not have constant game interruptions and more technological challenges at the lower levels than we see at D1 -- he stressed his support of a coaches' challenge system in our conversation multiple times.
@D3FBHuddle and I give thanks to Steve for his transparency, which is always on display in the CFO training videos he releases on YouTube. I always learn something when I watch his videos, and today was no different in our conversation.
SIGNED: S Julian Bell will join Roosters this season ✅
He played at North Central College last year and started all 15 games at safety, ranking second on the team in tackles (73). Bell was selected First Team All-CCIW in 2023.
#roostersfamily#jenkkifutis#vaahteraliiga
.@football_ncc's BJ Adamchik, Luke Lehnen & Jeske Maples have been named First Team Academic All-Americans by @CollSportsComm.
It's the highest number of honorees the Cardinals have had in a single season.
📰https://t.co/lknMYrpI74
#WeAreNC#d3football 🏈
.@football_ncc tight end Bobby Behmer is the winner of the @NCAA Elite 90 Award, presented to the student-athlete with the highest cumulative GPA at each national championship.
A Cardinal has won the award each of the last three seasons.
#WeAreNC#d3fb@NCAADIII@rrstar_sports @23WIFR
Hey @D3FBHuddle@d3football…you guys might wanna see this. Can’t wait to broadcast from the left side of the dorm room!
Can’t even see the scoreboard or about 30% of the field…
CARDS BY 90.
Five football student-athletes from North Central and Wheaton have represented the CCIW on the 2023 American Football Coaches Association Division III Coaches’ All-America Team announced on Monday.
@football_ncc | @WheatonFB | #CCIWwins
https://t.co/MbnGaIuf3A