Deputies in Georgia went to check on a 33-year-old disabled woman her aunt hadn't seen in two years. Her younger sister led them to a bedroom door twisted shut with a wire coat hanger. They brought her out in a sheet, skin and bone. As deputies detained the sister, she asked:
"What about my kids? Y'all going to take them too?" That's Bobbie Jo Barber, 32, on November 28, 2023, outside the house she shared with her husband Jerry in Milledgeville, Georgia. The woman in the sheet was her older sister, Stacey Gunter.
Their mother died in 2021, their father in July 2022. Stacey, who Bobbie Jo said has seizures, stayed in the house with Bobbie Jo, Jerry and their two kids. Bobbie Jo later told a detective she collected her sister's disability check, a little over $900 a month. She said it went to rent and food.
The aunt called for a welfare check. When a deputy asked Bobbie Jo to show him her sister, she asked to wait for her husband and said she didn't want to go to jail. He asked why. "For the way she looks," she said.
The room had no bathroom. A second door to it was tied shut with a cord. A deputy had to break the door to get to Stacey, who was curled in a chair in a fetal position, soiled with her own waste. A deputy at the scene estimated she weighed 50 to 60 pounds. When Jerry got home, he told deputies: "We don't want her here."
In the video below, deputies help Stacey out of the room wrapped in a pink sheet and ask if she can walk. Bobbie Jo, in handcuffs, asks about her kids and is put in the back of a patrol car. Then deputies walk the yard and talk through what they found. The last line: "She's sitting in a chair curled up in a ball terrified."
A Baldwin County grand jury indicted both of them in January 2024 for exploitation and intimidation of a disabled adult, neglect and false imprisonment. A year later, Bobbie Jo took a plea deal under Georgia's First Offender Act. Jerry entered an Alford plea. Each got 30 years, the first 10 in prison and the rest on probation, and no contact with Stacey.
Under First Offender, Bobbie Jo can leave with no conviction on her record if she completes the sentence. Is that fair, or should it never apply to a case like this?
A 32-year-old Texas woman got stopped by a cop over a Dollar General shoplifting call. She told him he couldn't detain her. Minutes later she was on the ground with her hand on an officer's holstered pistol, and the gun went off. In handcuffs, she turned to the officer and said:
"Better hope they give me life, 'cause I'mma make sure you die." That's Brianna Erwin, 32, on May 11, 2025, in Tyler, Texas, a few minutes after the shot. Nobody was hit.
It started around 2 p.m. on a Sunday. Mother's Day. Police got a theft call from the Dollar General on Gentry Parkway and found two women nearby. One stopped. Erwin kept walking.
According to the arrest affidavit, she twisted out of his grip and ran. She tripped. On the ground she thrashed, bit and pulled her arms away while he tried to cuff her, and a second officer ran up to help. She kept screaming that she was three months pregnant.
Then she got a hand on an officer's pistol. The affidavit says she worked a finger into the trigger guard while the gun was still in the holster. The round went out through the bottom of the holster.
An officer punched her in the face. Police called it a closed-hand strike to keep things from escalating. Videos of the arrest spread online, and the Tyler NAACP called the force excessive. Erwin later told the NAACP president her pregnancy test came back negative.
She already had an outstanding warrant for aggravated assault with a deadly weapon when the officer stopped her.
In the video below, two officers pin her on the pavement while one shouts "Let go of my gun!" and the shot goes off. Afterward an officer says, "She's lucky she's alive." She yells that she didn't do anything, and an officer answers, "Yeah, I did punch you in your face." The threat comes at the patrol car.
On October 27, 2025, Erwin pleaded guilty in a Tyler courtroom. Judge Kerry Russell gave her 40 years for aggravated assault of a public servant, 8 years for harassment of a public servant and 1 year for drug possession, all running at the same time. She was 33.
Was 40 years justice for firing a cop's gun, or too much for a fight that started over a Dollar General theft?
A 32-year-old Texas woman got stopped by a cop over a Dollar General shoplifting call. She told him he couldn't detain her. Minutes later she was on the ground with her hand on an officer's holstered pistol, and the gun went off. In handcuffs, she turned to the officer and said:
"Better hope they give me life, 'cause I'mma make sure you die." That's Brianna Erwin, 32, on May 11, 2025, in Tyler, Texas, a few minutes after the shot. Nobody was hit.
It started around 2 p.m. on a Sunday. Mother's Day. Police got a theft call from the Dollar General on Gentry Parkway and found two women nearby. One stopped. Erwin kept walking.
According to the arrest affidavit, she twisted out of his grip and ran. She tripped. On the ground she thrashed, bit and pulled her arms away while he tried to cuff her, and a second officer ran up to help. She kept screaming that she was three months pregnant.
Then she got a hand on an officer's pistol. The affidavit says she worked a finger into the trigger guard while the gun was still in the holster. The round went out through the bottom of the holster.
An officer punched her in the face. Police called it a closed-hand strike to keep things from escalating. Videos of the arrest spread online, and the Tyler NAACP called the force excessive. Erwin later told the NAACP president her pregnancy test came back negative.
She already had an outstanding warrant for aggravated assault with a deadly weapon when the officer stopped her.
In the video below, two officers pin her on the pavement while one shouts "Let go of my gun!" and the shot goes off. Afterward an officer says, "She's lucky she's alive." She yells that she didn't do anything, and an officer answers, "Yeah, I did punch you in your face." The threat comes at the patrol car.
On October 27, 2025, Erwin pleaded guilty in a Tyler courtroom. Judge Kerry Russell gave her 40 years for aggravated assault of a public servant, 8 years for harassment of a public servant and 1 year for drug possession, all running at the same time. She was 33.
Was 40 years justice for firing a cop's gun, or too much for a fight that started over a Dollar General theft?
The morning after her car was stolen, a 23-year-old mom in South Carolina stood against a brick wall and told a TV reporter what the carjacker did. He had a gun, she said, and her two little boys were still buckled into the back seat. She said she begged him:
"Please let me take them." That's Susan Smith on Oct. 26, 1994, in Union, South Carolina. Her sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, had been missing since 9 o'clock the night before.
She told police a Black man jumped into her car at a red light, made her drive a few miles, pushed her out in the middle of the road and drove off with the boys. Helicopters flew over the county. She sat with a sketch artist. The drawing went national.
For nine days she cried on camera with her estranged husband David beside her, asking the man to bring the boys home.
On the morning of Nov. 3, the couple gave interviews to three network morning shows. That afternoon Sheriff Howard Wells confronted her, and she confessed in a handwritten statement.
There was no carjacker. She had let her car roll down a boat ramp into John D. Long Lake with both boys strapped in their car seats. Investigators later recreated it. Six minutes to go under. That night divers found it on the bottom with the boys still inside.
Prosecutors said a man she was seeing had told her the children were the reason they had no future together.
In the video below, recorded the day after the boys went into the lake, she tells the whole story in one take: the red light, the gun poked in her side, the car seats he said there was no time for. A minute in, she says she's "just praying" they'll be okay.
In July 1995 a jury convicted her of two counts of murder and spared her the death penalty. She got life, with a chance at parole after 30 years. At her first hearing in November 2024 she cried on a video link: "I know what I did was horrible." The board voted no, unanimously.
On Nov. 19, 2026, she asked again by video from prison. The board turned her down again, unanimously.
She has served 32 years for Michael and Alex. Is that enough for two boys left in a lake, or should she die in prison?
A 28-year-old nurse in Virginia missed two shifts in a row, so police went to check on her. Her husband opened the door with their baby daughter on his hip. He said his wife had destroyed her phone and left for New York or Texas. Then, as the officer was wrapping up, he added:
“She has some mental issues as well. She’s the nurse.” That’s Naresh Bhatt, 37, on August 2, 2024, on the porch of his home in Manassas Park, Virginia. Police later said his wife had been killed four days earlier.
Her name was Mamta Kafle Bhatt, a registered nurse from Nepal who worked at a hospital in Manassas. Their daughter was about one.
About five months before she vanished, prosecutors say, Naresh texted her: “The days are coming that you will regret a lot.”
Within three weeks, detectives searched the house. They found pooled blood in the main bedroom, more in the bathroom, and her blood on a handheld power saw. Cameras caught him in gloves, dropping trash bags into dumpsters around town. Some of those trips were at night.
He was arrested on August 22, 2024. Mamta’s body has never been found.
For two years he told police and TV reporters he had no idea where she was. Then this November, at his murder trial, he took the stand and changed the story. He said he found her dead on the bedroom floor and claimed she had swallowed a pesticide. He admitted he cut up her body with a saw and threw it out in three kitchen trash bags. He still says he never killed her.
In the video below is the first time police ever spoke to him. The baby stays on his arm the whole time. Watch him go from “she left” to his wife’s mental health as the officer is about to leave.
On November 10, 2026, a jury took about four hours to find him guilty of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body and defiling a dead body. Prosecutor Sarah Sami said: “The defendant murdered Mamta Kafle, the defendant dismembered Mamta Kafle, and the defendant got rid of her like garbage.” Her family still has no remains to bury.
He will be sentenced on March 12, 2027, and faces 20 years to life on the murder count. Should he get life, or is 20 years enough for a man who admits hiding her body but denies killing her?