"It's over for you Shmitt, nazis lost, now they will put Constitutional Court in every european country"
"It maybe so, Kelsen, but Donald Tusk will avenge me"
"Who?"
"You'll see"
We’ve reached a place where the King of Jordan shows more genuine solidarity with and concern for the Christians of his country than the President of France shows for his.
Way too much modern Catholic moral argumentation boils down to nothing more than:
1. Human dignity, therefore
2. [Plug in desired conclusion]
It's lazy and intellectually unserious and utterly unconvincing to anyone who doesn't already agree with whatever conclusion one is trying to establish. It opens the door to all kinds of mischief, because the notion of "human dignity" is so vague and contested that it can be, and is, deployed to arrive at all sorts of conclusions, including conclusions that contradict one another. And for that reason, bare appeals to human dignity are inevitably question-begging, because what human dignity amounts to and what it entails are precisely what is in dispute between the different sides of the various issues to which the notion is applied (capital punishment, immigration, sexuality, or whatever).
This is one of the many high costs of having taken Catholic theology off of the Scholastic gold standard. Too many minds have turned to mush and simply don't know how to reason logically. They just repeat gauzy stock phrases and stomp their feet.
The heart of the difficulty since 2018 is that opposition to the death penalty would now seem to be a non-definitive authoritative teaching, but its emphatic defense (and even practice) for virtually all of Church history suggests that opposition can never be more than a prudential judgment. So people are understandably confused.
In this era of artificial intelligence, it is becoming urgent to distinguish human art from what machines produce. There is an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others. Algorithms lack the spark of humanity. For this reason, the Church wishes to renew an alliance with artists and cultural institutions to safeguard our humanity.
"Those who dwelt of old in thy holy land thou didst hate for their detestable practices...their merciless slaughter of children...these parents who murder helpless lives, thou didst will to destroy by the hands of our fathers..."
-Wisdom 12:3-6
Easy:
1 - The "right" to goon on the internet and sell pictures of my nether regions to others
2 - The "right" to gamble away my family's security through sports betting
3 - The "right" to defame public figures so long as I don't have "actual malice"
4 - The "right" to murder unborn babies
5 - The "right" to take out short term loans at 25%+ interest rates
6 - The "right" to lie about possessing military honors
7 - The "right" to worship Satan
8 - The "right" to maximize shareholder value at the expense of dignified work for the middle class of the country
9 - The "right" to smoke weed and rot my brain out
10 - The "right" to sell children like commodities through surrogacy
I could go on