had an onboarding call yesterday with a commercial insurance agency client
here's what I ask on every onboarding call before I write a single cold email, and you can ask your own team the same:
1. who actually is the target decision maker. for them it's the owner 90%+ of the time, 5 to 50 employees. no CFOs or HR dept yet at these tages
2. which deals are the easiest for you. trade contractors and auto repair shops, "tons of markets for these, those are easier deals"
3. what's the hardest part of the sale. "just getting them open to consider the review". once they're in the room they win most of them
4. what can you stand behind in terms of offers//promises. clean claims for 3 years and they can always find a better coverage plan for least dollars
5. the 3 buyer types you want. neglected by their agent, price creeping up for years, or a claim that wasn't paid the way they expected
6. then the stuff only they know as industry experts. for auto repair shops its the garage limit was set years ago. fire with 10 customer cars at 50-120K each vs a 50K limit = the owner isn't covered
one line like that is worth more than anything I could write myself, that's for the insight driven campaign where you prove your expertise and provide something useful even if they never work with you
next I turn this into ~8 offers for them to approve, to test fast side by side, and find a winner within first week
a group health agency owner told me he was paying $1,200 a month for 12 phone appointments
"that didn't work"
"all they arranged was a phone appointment, they didn't arrange a personal appointment"
he signed with us anyway, for 5 a month instead of 12, but in-person ones
so here's how we're booking his 5, starting january:
1. cold email the owner, HR lead or CFO inside his serviceable area and desired group size
2. if they say yes, we call them before anything gets booked
3. on that call ask when does the plan renew, how many people are on it, and what they are paying now
4. book 30 minutes in person, which is what the client asked us for
5. make sure they show up: confirmation when it's booked, 24 hours before, the morning of, 1h before
a group health agency owner hired us because every referral his team brings in is a 10 to 15 person company
his words: his account execs "get referrals from their current clients and most of usually the groups that they bring in are in the 10 to 15 person range"
he wants "decision makers in the 25 to 250 space"
referrals can't fix that
a 12-person company refers you to their friends, and their friends run 12-person companies too
so here's what we're doing for him starting january:
1. every employer within ~50 miles of his office, sized by headcount (linkedin and /team page)
2. cold email to the owner persona, HR lead or CFO
3. when they say yes, we call and ask when their plan renews and how many people are on it
4. only then book 30 minutes, in person, which is what he asked for
why the size matters, at 10% commission and ~$9,300 per enrolled life a year:
a 12-life group is ~$112K premium, ~$11K a year for agency in commissions
a 50-life group is ~$465K premium, ~$46K a year
one 50-life group = four referrals
if you're stuck at your referrals' size, run literally this
referrals feel amazing, they're layup deals
you just service your book well and chill
the renewal list is actually free and gives you some control over your growth
an agency owner, on a call with me
so open with the work comp review, not the whole package
the package usually renews the same day anyway
do it when they trust you already, not on the first call
"we'll start prospecting in January" is great advice
also great: missing every January 1st renewal of the year
2 out of 3 agency principals tell me that
but January 1st gets quoted 90 days before
80% of new business works off a renewal date 90 days out for most insurance
so start in January, and you're prospecting April renewals
what I do instead:
1. today, start sending cold emails to accounts that look qualified on paper (industry, location, company size)
2. to everyone who's not ready now, ask them "when is your renewal date?"
3. set a reminder 90 days before that date and reach back out
one $50K account at 10% is $5K a year
miss its renewal window, and it's like a gift to your competitors
you're not bad at prospecting, you're just positioning yourself as a commodity
agency principal told me his own pitch is "we could save you money"
then: "these things sound kind of cliche because they are"
he still uses it because it's what gets him in the door
the problem is the prospect's current agent can say the exact same thing
give them a reason to talk that isn't price. a few ideas:
1. a work comp mod review before the renewal, a high mod costs them for 3 years
2. a class code check
3. a fleet schedule review for anyone with trucks
each one is a 15 minute review, not a quote. the quote comes after
use your social proof to make this review sound interesting
- how many years you've been writing these lines
- how much in premium you've saved over the years
- how much in claims you've saved over the years
- how many accounts trust your agency
- success story of similar business that did review with you and achieved X outcome
- etc
and this gets even better when you only work with a specific industry
group health agency owner told me 4 meetings a week would "overload the staff"
then took 5/month and paid on the call
his words: "if we were successful with one out of four, that means we're making a new sale a week... four sales a month and might overload the staff, to tell you the truth"
another owner signed the day before, same thing
"15 phenomenal prospects in a month, there's probably eight or nine that I won't even have time to call"
he asked for 5/mo too
the limit is how many new accounts your people can quote and onboard next to the book they already have
how to plan it:
1. ask each producer how many new meetings a month they'd really run next to their book (both of mine said 5)
2. use that producer's real close rate, a new guy closes way less than your best one
3. multiply by commission per account
4. that's your new business ceiling, anything above it rots in a CRM
the math
a 30-person group pays about $280K a year in health premiums ($9,325 per employee, KFF 2025, single coverage)
at 10% that's about $28K a year to you in commissions
close 1 of the 5 meetings a month = 12 groups a year = about $336K in agency revenue added
"you can't tell which business is unhappy with their broker" vs. OSHA publishing how many people got hurt at every one of them:
an agency owner told me "somebody that has a super high mod is prone to be a shopper"
and claims start as injuries
OSHA publishes the injury log (300A form) for workplaces with 250+ employees, and 20+ in high-hazard industries. cases, hours worked, per location, free download
this week we built a territory list for an agency, 100 miles around their town, 5,407 companies
then ranked it by injury rate
545 came out at 4+ injuries per 100 workers or 3+ cases. median of that group is 6.9
those go first
their mod is more likely to go up, and their premium with it
how to do it:
1. download OSHA's injury tracking (ITA) 300A data, it's a csv
2. filter to your states, match to your list on company name + zip
3. injury rate = cases x 200,000 / hours worked
4. start with 4+ in manufacturing, construction and trucking
5. email the owner about getting the mod down, ask for a work comp review only
100 accounts at $50K work comp and ~8% commission is $400K a year before the package of other lines they'll likely ask you to quote them
btw do not forget to scrub out your own clients first, this agency principal fired a calling service because "they were cold calling our clients in a lead list"
the federal government publishes which insurer covers every for-hire trucking company in the US, plus the date the policy was filed. updated this morning
it's FMCSA's insurance filing data ("Motus Insur" on data.transportation gov), I pulled it today
138,723 carriers with an active liability filing
12,950 of those filings are dated Dec 2025 to Feb 2026, so they're coming up on a year
so you know who they're with and roughly when they renew before you send a single email
how to use it:
1. pull active liability filings (form BMC-91X) dated 9-10 months ago
2. join the USDOT number to the FMCSA census for state and truck count
3. keep 5+ power units, that's roughly where auto premium crosses $50K
4. email them 60-90 days before that date
67 fleets like that at $50K and ~12% commission is $400K a year
honest caveat, a filing date isn't always the renewal date
an agency owner in the south asked me on our first call "how are you going to get appointments with your accent?"
fair question lol
I told him "you're on the google meet with me right now"
he said he gets bombarded with solicitations and ignores most of them, mine stood out
then: "if you're able to lure me in, then you may just be able to lure these other guys in"
12 days later he paid on the call
even no case study objection
my methodology that worked on him was enough to believe it works
"give the new leads to the new producer, he needs the reps" is great advice
also great: needing 250 meetings instead of 67
an agency owner told me on our first call his best producers close about 75%
the newer ones close about 20%
his plan for the meetings we'd book was a rotation, "it's your turn, go work this one"
so I ran the math with him on the next call
one account is about $50K premium, ~15% commission, so ~$8K to the agency
$400K a year in new commission is 50 accounts
at 20% you need 250 meetings held
at 75% you need 67
same lists, same emails, 183 meetings of difference
he paid on that call
if you're buying or booking meetings:
1. pull each producer's close rate on new accounts from last year
2. send first meetings with new accounts to your top 1 or 2
3. size the meeting target off their close rate, not the agency average