I'm Muhammad Bilal, a small creator from Pakistan. YouTube permanently terminated my channel 'Storyy Loversss' over an AI cartoon STORY. This thread is my evidence. Read it, then judge for yourself. 🧵
@YouTube My pinned thread has the full evidence — watch my video and name the exact scene that violated policy. A real review can answer this. #FairReviewForCreators
@YouTube@TeamYouTube Watch my video and tell me my mistake. It was my FIRST mistake from my learning days — I didn't know the policy. A first mistake deserves a warning, not a lifetime ban. The same video runs fine on TikTok. #FairReviewForCreators
@YtubeGuard@TeamYouTube Thanks for the guidance — I already appealed twice, both rejected with boilerplate. The email cites child safety but never names the exact scene. That's all I'm asking: @YouTube, watch my video and tell me the mistake. #FairReviewForCreators
@nealmohan@YouTube My evidence is pinned on my profile — watch the video and name the exact violating scene. Which second? A human review can point to the frame. #FairReviewForCreators
@YouTube@TeamYouTube If my video was truly reviewed by a human, name the exact scene that violated the rules. Which second? Which frame? The same cartoon runs fine on TikTok. A real review can answer this. Tell me the mistake. #FairReviewForCreators
@YouTube@TeamYouTube — if a HUMAN actually reviewed my case, tell me: what exactly was wrong in my cartoon rescue video? And why does the SAME video run fine on TikTok with zero issues? A first mistake deserved a warning, not a lifetime ban. #FairReviewForCreators
@UpdatesFromYT@youtubemusic@YouTube — my full evidence is pinned on my profile. Watch my video and tell me: what exactly violated policy? If a human reviewed my case, name the problem. The same video runs fine on TikTok. #FairReviewForCreators
Same day, two emails from YouTube. First: "This is just a warning — it's your FIRST time, keep uploading." Hours later: "SEVERE violations — channel PERMANENTLY removed." Same video, two opposite verdicts. Robots shouldn't judge creators. #FairReviewForCreators
@UpdatesFromYT While you celebrate #MadeOnYouTube, your robots terminate small creators with no human review, no warning, no explanation. New features mean nothing if your enforcement system executes creators first. #FairReviewForCreators
@YTJP_creators1 10-minute rejection = a robot, not a review. Same story — my cartoon channel terminated, appealed TWICE, both rejected by templates. 100K views and @TeamYouTube still silent? Follow me, let's demand #FairReviewForCreators together. @YouTube
I'm Muhammad Bilal, a small creator from Pakistan. YouTube permanently terminated my channel 'Storyy Loversss' over an AI cartoon STORY. This thread is my evidence. Read it, then judge for yourself. 🧵
@nealmohan@YouTubeCreators@YouTube I'm not fighting for revenge — I'm fighting so no small creator faces this again. Follow me, share this, use #FairReviewForCreators. Find me on TikTok: https://t.co/A0NNCPzqyI. One voice is ignored. A thousand can't be. 💪