Republicans and Democrats agree: America's top AI chips shouldn't go to China.
"The policy's quite clear," ARI president @bradrcarson told @DeadlineWH. The Commerce Department needs to enforce it.
Clear rules only work if they're enforced.
Watching football and reading takes on the imminence of RSI, I thought I'd put together my own list of what I want A\, OAI, and GDM provide to the public and to the gov't. I haven't seen many similar lists like this (Elasticity Inst) and so I hope this can kick off a discussion. A couple of these might be invasive, but most are not particularly so, IMO.
Trump just said he and Xi agreed to joint guardrails on AI. That's big.
Here's where US-China talks can start:
✅Keep nuclear decisions human.
✅Agree on AI risk definitions.
✅Open a dedicated risk reduction channel.
Our letter to the Administration: https://t.co/jDYc5ROsAL
Enormously excited by this effort. CRI under @justinbullock14 will be thinking about next-generation issues, those matters that we can see - at least dimly - as confronting us over the next few years and decades.
And, TODAY is my first day in the new role of Head of Research for The Center for Responsible Innovation!
No socials yet, but CRI is re-launching as a policy ideas lab and I’ll be developing (in collaboration with many of you!) a new research agenda with plans to bring on a handful of dynamic researchers to help create what I believe are needed new ambitious AI policy proposals.
I’ll have more to say about this in the coming days and weeks, but for now I just want to say this:
It really is true that the capabilities of AI (or SI if you’re @hamandcheese) are dramatically improving. One need look no further that @EpochAIResearch’s various graphs to confirm this. However there is still an immense amount of uncertainty (as the brilliant @sebkrier is often reminding us) as to what form increasingly intelligent machines will take, how they will coordinate together and with us, and what sorts democratic policy responses are needed as this unfolds and is redirected by our collective efforts.
AI, AGI, ASI, SI (take your pick) all bring immense potential to improve our world, but it’s gonna take a lot of specific hard choices around incentives, institutional design, experiments, and excellent governance to get the good world.
So let’s do it! Let’s do the hard part to get the details right!
And finally, it’s gonna take the hive mind, the collective intelligence of you all, to have any shot at rising to this immense moment of promise and peril.
I hope you’ll indulge me and join me in trying to do our part…. To make sure we handle this moment of great innovation…you guessed it…. RESPONSIBLY. 😏🎉🥳
Proud to call @JustinBullock14 a friend, colleague, and partner and I’m grateful for the opportunities I’ve had to both work for and with him. I’m a national security professional by training, and I could not have had a better tutor and guide to the AI policy space than Justin. Immensely grateful for the time we’ve spent together and can’t wait to keep collaborating in your new role!
Today is my last day in the role of VP of Policy for @americans4ri!
It is a role I assumed early last year, just as ARI was beginning to further ramp up its efforts. At the time, I knew very little about the ways of DC, but I knew that the wave of advanced AI capabilities was upon us and that there was so much policy work to do!
Now, as the waves of advanced AI do indeed crash all around us, it’s incredible to see the needed policy responses taking shape. CA and NY continue ramping up their efforts, the Executive Branch has begun stepping up their efforts with the SI Oversight and Accord Committee, and just today a new bipartisan AI caucus has formed in Congress and the bipartisan SAFE AI Act was unveiled.
I’ve now been schooled in DC politics and have observed the policy response beginning to rise to the moment. And, hopefully I’ve done my own part to move US AI policy forward.
It’s fun to “go out” on a big day!
Keep up the excellent work everyone!
Also my deep appreciation for the opportunity to work with and learn from the best leadership team in town @bradrcarson, @egastfriend, @DougCalidas, @mcplummer1789, @MitchKominsky, and Adam Pastrich!
More on what’s next very soon! 😏
Did I mention the SAFE AI Act is a good bill? 🫡
NEW: ARI endorses the SAFE AI Act, a bipartisan plan from @RepSaraJacobs, @RepMaloyUtah, and @RepDonBeyer to set binding safety rules for the most advanced AI.
Safety can't rest on promises companies can walk back. Under the plan, leading AI companies would have to:
➡️Meet safety standards set by government, not by companies
➡️Have new models evaluated before release
➡️Report safety incidents
The bill proposal also includes critical whistleblower protections and allows states to go further in regulating AI.
https://t.co/AhCYMH8Pls
Today is my last day in the role of VP of Policy for @americans4ri!
It is a role I assumed early last year, just as ARI was beginning to further ramp up its efforts. At the time, I knew very little about the ways of DC, but I knew that the wave of advanced AI capabilities was upon us and that there was so much policy work to do!
Now, as the waves of advanced AI do indeed crash all around us, it’s incredible to see the needed policy responses taking shape. CA and NY continue ramping up their efforts, the Executive Branch has begun stepping up their efforts with the SI Oversight and Accord Committee, and just today a new bipartisan AI caucus has formed in Congress and the bipartisan SAFE AI Act was unveiled.
I’ve now been schooled in DC politics and have observed the policy response beginning to rise to the moment. And, hopefully I’ve done my own part to move US AI policy forward.
It’s fun to “go out” on a big day!
Keep up the excellent work everyone!
Also my deep appreciation for the opportunity to work with and learn from the best leadership team in town @bradrcarson, @egastfriend, @DougCalidas, @mcplummer1789, @MitchKominsky, and Adam Pastrich!
More on what’s next very soon! 😏
Did I mention the SAFE AI Act is a good bill? 🫡
NEW: Over a dozen NatSec and AI experts are urging the DOJ to investigate Nvidia's knowledge of chip smuggling operations.
Protecting America's technological edge depends on enforcing the law.
Read the full story:
https://t.co/NL6XZH5wMa
I don’t have any children, but there is something in building an organization that is at least analogous to parenthood. Raising @WarontheRocks from birth to teenager has been both difficult and the privilege of a lifetime. But I don’t think anyone should run an organization for as long as I’ve run this one. The measure of this project will be what it can be after me. And I believe War on the Rocks will become better in its next phase. It is time for the precocious but still unruly teenager and me to put some distance between us. I will still be available from my perch on (and here is where the analogy stretches) the board of directors to advise.
It is hard for a founder to turn over his business, but I view it as an important achievement because it is hard. For me, it is hard because I’ve poured so much of myself into it and because it is what I am known for. But I am looking forward to being known for other things. More practically, I needed to put together the right team: people who can take over and improve what War on the Rocks does across the key roles I’ve occupied from the start, from editing to podcasting to the running of it as a business, which encompasses a great many things.
The person who will be responsible for those great many things as our new CEO is Nick Hanson, a Marine reservist, a graduate of the Naval Academy as well as the Harvard Kennedy School and Business School, and my friend. Nick (who is not on X, wisely) has been our chief operating officer for about two years now, adding immeasurably to our team. He brings to every conversation a sense of purpose, intellectual curiosity, and moral seriousness. He has a gift for reframing hard problems in new ways, often revealing possibilities others miss. I am excited for you all to discover this about him.
I will write more at a later date about others joining the team, and other matters, but for now I would be grateful if you would extend your congratulations to Nick.
His note, which he posted on LinkedIn, is below:
-------------
After two years as chief operating officer, I am honored to step in as CEO of War on the Rocks.
I was an active-duty Marine officer when Ryan Evans founded War on the Rocks, and I remember how rapidly it became the forum of choice for serious debate on the most complex challenges in national security. It brought together the scholars who study war, the diplomats who work to prevent it, the congressional staffers who write the laws that govern it, the intelligence professionals who warn of it, and, above all, the servicemembers who fight it.
Ryan has given War on the Rocks more than a decade of his life. I am grateful he is trusting me with its future and glad he will stay on our board.
The mission is not changing. In 2013, shortly after War on the Rocks' founding, Frank Hoffman wrote an article with a passage that Ryan made our mission statement:
"[I]n a world in which relative power levels are narrowing and means are diluted, America’s historical black hole, a bifurcation between policy and operations, must be closed. Given that our country expects great sacrifices from those toiling at the tactical level, much more can and should be expected at the summit. It is my expectation that War on the Rocks will help fill in the black hole."
The questions facing American national security are getting harder, as are the demands on those who are expected to deter and, failing that, defeat America’s enemies. These challenges demand debate that challenges the national security community, which is not always a comfortable experience, but it is a critical one. We will keep providing it, with the same independence and rigor our readers expect.
My focus will be on growing the community that makes this work possible, online and in person, and building an organization that can sustain it for the next decade and beyond.
This has always been a team effort. Our authors, contributors, and podcast guests bring the ideas, and our editorial and content teams sharpen them into arguments worth your time. More news about additions to the team will be coming soon.
Thank you to everyone who reads, listens, writes, and shows up to make War on the Rocks the community it is today.
Teachable moment here. This is the industry playbook, distilled to its essence:
1) Fight new tech regulation
2) Yell that existing laws are already in place
3) Decry enforcement of any existing laws (“not this law”)
4) Point to recently enacted laws you fought
Rinse, repeat. Again and again and again.
"What we're seeing in cyber today is just auguring what the future will bring."
@bradrcarson joins Brett Baier on Fox to share what we know after a week of cyber incidents: America's critical infrastructure is highly vulnerable to the sweeping risks posed by AI cyber threats.
Some initial takes after reading this announcement from OpenAI on new embedded assessments:
These seem like reasonable collaborations and I'm glad OpenAI is doing them. All four of these orgs care deeply about AI safety and have talented researchers, and aren't just corporate rubber stamps. But none of the collaborations seems to clearly involve "employee like access," (desks, badges, laptops — not set by the minimum info the evaluations need) to prevent catastrophic risks as Sam promised in September.
For instance, the details of the collaboration with METR seem extremely narrow, only focusing on evaluating misaligned behavior from a large RL run. OpenAI also say that they have "preliminarily agreed to conduct another monitor assessment which we intend to be broader, but this is pending mutual agreement on the assessment scope"
A footnote on the post also says more explicitly regarding the collaboration with METR on their RL run:
"This scope is less expansive than what METR outlines in their alignment assessment proposal, which envisions a broad survey of misalignment."
From this section it seems quite clear that this is not an announcement to give METR employee level access - the other collaborations are fewer on details but also appear sufficiently narrow in scope that I don't expect them to have much of an effect at identifying areas where OpenAI's current safety and security practices are insufficient or dangerous.
Apollo made a similar point in a tweet after the announcement today:
“This pilot is an ambitious first step towards the goal of obtaining those strong guarantees, but its access and disclosure rights don't yet meet our bar for full embedded evaluations.”
It's possible that this announcement literally fulfills the letter of Sam's prior commitment (insofar as e.g. OpenAI is basically hiring Goodfire staff to do interpretability research internal to OpenAI), but it does not at all meet the spirit of having independent researchers with broad access able to identify and address imminent risks to the public. In Dario's underlying post that Sam favorably commented on and offered his commitment, Dario describes the role of embedded evaluators "whose role is to verify adherence to safety practices and commitments, report incidents, and help assess the alignment of not just completed AI models but training pipelines and processes." It is extremely unclear to what extent any of these evaluators will be performing those functions. (To be clear, i’m not sure that Anthropic is fulfilling these commitments either, at least in their announcements to date and the draft legislation they have put forward.)
This only more clearly shows the need for these practices to be mandated, instead of entirely voluntary and on the company's terms (and remember of course many of OpenAI and Anthropic's competitors are just not doing anything at all in terms of strong independent evaluators with meaningful access). Even as I was writing up this post critiquing this announcement, I was very aware of the fact that OpenAI people may reasonably react “what is the point of doing this at all” if people are going to criticize whatever we do as not enough and orgs doing nothing get a free pass. So let me be very clear that OpenAI is doing much much more here than Google, xAI, Meta, or any of the Chinese developers (some aspects of this are better than what Anthropic has done, some - like the amount of access given to METR - is worse).
I also realize that getting even these limited (but extremely valuable) collaborations across the line took an immense amount of work internally and i'm grateful for everyone who worked to make them happen to give, both within and outside the companies. But I also think its worth being very clear about areas where this still falls short, both from OpenAI's own commitment and above all what is objectively needed for sufficient transparency and safety.
Very, very strange statement tonight from @CommerceGov and @TheJusticeDept about Megaspeed. The facts here just don't add up, and this does nothing to explain why Commerce did not cut Megaspeed off from chips. In fact, it raises even more questions about what happened here.
BIS claims that it started an investigation into Megaspeed in 2024, and following an end-use check in June 2025 it handed off the criminal investigation to DOJ. It also said that in June 2025, Nvidia put Megaspeed on its own internal no-trade blacklist--implying this solved the issue and cut them off from Nvidia chips.
The problem with this story, is that Megaspeed kept buying chips after Nvidia put them on their no-trade list. @mackhawk reported in December 2025 that Megaspeed imported 17,544 GB300 AI chips in November 2025, worth about $787 million. There are multiple other reports that say Megaspeed continued to receive chips into 2026.
If Commerce was so concerned about Megaspeed smuggling chips to China that the DOJ opened a criminal case after an end-use check in June 2025, and Nvidia also put them on an internal blacklist, why didn't Commerce also put them on the Entity List? That is literally the entire purpose of the Entity List, to list companies in situations like this! If it had done that--and also put Megaspeed's affiliates and subsidiaries such as Speedmatrix (its Malaysian subsidiary) and PT Megaspeed International (its Indonesian subsidiary) on the Entity List--Commerce could have actually cut Megaspeed off from chips!
Instead, Commerce appears to have outsourced Entity List restrictions and export enforcement to Nvidia. That is insanely irresponsible! Does @USTreasury outsource sanctions enforcement entirely to US banks? Of course not, OFAC sanctions entities that are violating US sanctions. How is "we didn't act because Nvidia acted for us" the best defense Commerce can muster here?
And also, why was Nvidia's blacklisting action so ineffective? Did Nvidia also place Megaspeed's subsidiaries such as Speedmatrix and PT Megaspeed International on its blacklist? I would bet they did not! If they kept shipping to them after blacklisting Megaspeed, that would be very concerning. What is the point of Nvidia blacklisting Megaspeed if they continue to allow their chips to be shipped to Megaspeed's subsidiaries in Malaysia and Indonesia?
It's hard to decide who screwed up more here, @CommerceGov or Nvidia. Just a total failure all around. How could both sides have agreed that Megaspeed represented a national security risk, but completely failed to prevent Megaspeed from buying $787 million worth of chips just five months after it was blacklisted? And undoubtedly more chips in 2026.
Maybe instead of writing defensive press releases that don't add up, @CommerceGov could write a rule finally placing Megaspeed on the Entity List. But maybe they're waiting for Treasury and NSC to write that rule for them as well.