@greg_doucette What do you think of the claim that there was no "actual controversy" in the case, since it was all about something the 303 Creative owner was "worried" that the government would do? That sure sounds like an "advisory opinion" to me, but IANAL.
@EHPlimsoll1 @tmcrittenden@AndrewRCraig@joshchafetz@AkivaMCohen@wrdcsc@PWashTX22 If you refuse to print Mein Kampf for anyone, then fine.
If you refuse to print Mein Kampf for someone because you don't like them as an individual, fine.
If you agree to print it for some people but not others because of their membership in a protected class, then not fine.
@tmcrittenden@AndrewRCraig@joshchafetz@AkivaMCohen@wrdcsc@PWashTX22 The law can't force them to sell you pork chops because that's not something on their menu. But they equally can't refuse to sell you something that's on the menu because of your race, sex, etc. If a wedding web site is "on the menu", they shouldn't be able to refuse that.
3/2+
@tmcrittenden@AndrewRCraig@joshchafetz@AkivaMCohen@wrdcsc@PWashTX22 I think there's a difference between not wanting to print "God Hates <x>" banners and not wanting to print things specifically for Westboro Baptist. It's like the examples that get dragged out about forcing a kosher restaurant to sell pork chops.
2/2+
@tmcrittenden@AndrewRCraig@joshchafetz@AkivaMCohen@wrdcsc@PWashTX22 I'm pretty far from convinced that a largely-boilerplate web site that's not very different from the site the proprietor would do for any other wedding is on the "you can discriminate" side of that line. 2/2
@tmcrittenden@AndrewRCraig@joshchafetz@AkivaMCohen@wrdcsc@PWashTX22 There's got to be a spectrum. If I hire someone to make a painting of a garden because I like their previous expression (paintings), that's clearly their expresson. If I hire them to paint my house blue, that's clearly not. There's a lot of gray area in between. 1/2
@questauthority What do you think of the position that there was no "actual controversy" in the 303 Creative case because no one had actually asked the proprietor to do the thing she was suing for the right to do?
@baseballtwit The interesting thing about that is that it doesn't look like there's anyone currently on the list with any sort of chance of catching himn.
@coolfacejane People who don't think this will happen forget that cable TV was driven by people wanting to watch porn at home, camcorders by people wanting to make porn at home, and 900 numbers by people wanting to talk sex from home. The sex->tech link has a long history.
Went to my local independent league team game tonight (Tri-City Valley Cats). Saw the umpires call a fly ball down the right field line foul, convene and reverse the call, then convene again and un-reverse it.
That's a first for me.