To every Jew, and to every non-Jewish friend who seeks the truth:
Please stop fighting antisemitism.
We fight it because we assume people don’t know the facts, and that if we only told them the truth, they would understand. Since the Holocaust we have spent billions trying to inform the world and buy its love and understanding. It has backfired, and it pains me to watch my brethren discover, once again, how disposable the Jew is in every generation.
What is worse is why our ship is sinking. It isn’t the torpedoes fired at us. It’s that we left the hatches open in the storm. While we tried to educate the world, we failed to educate millions of our own children about their faith and their glorious heritage.
I implore you: stop pouring resources into those who wish us harm, and start investing in Jewish children, each of whom could one day save our people.
More than 1.5 million Jewish children in the Diaspora receive no Jewish education. Let’s save them. Please join me in this fight.
Shabbat shalom,
Barry
I wrote to you and I never received a response please let me know what you think of the response I sent to you ! The Guards of Chelm
I keep thinking of the night watchmen of Chelm. They catch sight of a thief climbing into the town treasury, and instead of raising the alarm they start laughing. The poor fool actually believes nobody has seen him. The guards find this so funny that they roll about on the floor, swearing to each other that they have never seen such a clueless thief, and they are still laughing when he walks out with everything.
I thought of them when I read Jonathan Tobin asking why American Jews vote for candidates like Abdul El-Sayed. Tobin answers his own question in his subtitle: for many Jews, politics has taken the place our faith once held, and their Judaism is now liberalism. He is right. But here I have to be honest about all of us, myself included. We are the guards of Chelm. We see the thief perfectly, we describe him brilliantly, and we are so pleased with the description that we forget he is still inside.
Consider how good we are at it. The claim that nearly three in five Michigan Jews voted for El-Sayed rests on a poll of early voters, the most Democratic slice of the electorate, and those same voters gave the Democrat for governor 78 percent. In New York last year, Brooklyn's observant neighbourhoods rejected Zohran Mamdani by 77 to 16 while Park Slope went the other way. Every word of that is accurate, and none of it has ever stopped a thief.
And then there are those who are not guards at all. When four hundred Michigan Jewish Democrats backed El-Sayed's opponent, Andy Levin put on a "Jews for Abdul" T-shirt and blamed AIPAC. Levin is not laughing at the thief. He is holding the ladder, and he uses his Jewish descent as the credential that lets him do it.
What is being carried out of the treasury is not an election. It is Jews. A person of Jewish descent who was never given a Jewish identity, never taught that he belongs to God, Torah and Israel, will vote against the Jewish people without the slightest sense that he has done anything wrong. Nobody ever told him there was something to betray. He votes this way, his children vote this way with even less hesitation, and within a generation or two nobody counts them as Jews anymore, themselves included.
The trajectory is already measured. Among observant Jews, whom the Pew survey counts under the Orthodox label, 98 percent of the married have a Jewish spouse. Among all other Jews who married in the last decade, 72 percent do not. I do not doubt for a moment that these are Jews, and Jewish blood runs in their veins. But descent has never carried the chain from one generation to the next. Only identity does that, and identity has to be taught.
Look, by contrast, at the man they voted for. Abdulrahman Mohammed El-Sayed carries his faith in his name and will carry it into the United States Senate without apology. He praises God in public before the entire country, and nobody in his community asks him to be quieter about it. I say this not in praise of his politics, which I do not share, but as a description of an upbringing. Somebody taught him who he is, and it held. I envy his parents.
Now look at our own children. Millions of Jewish children in America are growing up without any meaningful Jewish education. They do not know the language of their ancestors or their story, they do not know their prayers, and nobody taught them to love our ancient homeland, so when they are told it is a crime they have nothing to answer with. We are raising a generation that knows what was done to the Jews and has no idea what the Jews are for. That is not an inheritance. It is an obituary.
Meanwhile we spend our strength on the battle we cannot win. We write the columns, run the campaigns, fund the museums and convene the conference on the Jewish vote after every election, and each time we ask what happened. Nothing happened. A generation became what we taught it to be, which in most cases was nothing at all.
There is only one investment that has ever kept Jews Jewish, and it is the transmission of our heritage through authentic Jewish education. We have left it to chance for three generations, and this week we read the results.
The thief is still in the treasury. We can keep laughing at how clumsy he is until we are robbed blind, or realise the joke is on us and wake up.
Expecting affinity from people who were never helped to understand or connect to their faith and heritage is simply self-deception.
Let us fight for Jewish education for all our children, with the same resources we have spent over the last eighty years fighting antisemitism.
No Jewish child without a Jewish education.
Danke, dass Sie mir folgen. Ihr Text spricht mir in vielem aus dem Herzen, deshalb will ich kurz erklären, wofür ich schreibe.
Der Punkt mit der „Israelkritik“ trifft. Kein anderes Land braucht ein eigenes Wort für seine Kritiker. Das Wort existiert, weil es eine Aufgabe erfüllt: Es macht eine sehr alte Haltung gesellschaftsfähig.
Zwei kleine Korrekturen, weil gerade wir uns keine Fehler leisten können. Die Konferenz von 1967 war in Khartum, und die drei Nein kamen von der Arabischen Liga. Die PLO hat Israel 1993 formell anerkannt; die Verweigerung lebt heute vor allem in der Hamas weiter.
Meine Überzeugung ist, dass wir diesen Kampf mit Empörung nicht gewinnen. Seit Jahrzehnten reagieren jüdische Organisationen auf Hass mit Widerlegung und Entrüstung, und der Hass ist trotzdem gewachsen. Wer sich nur über seine Feinde definiert, überlässt ihnen auch die Erzählung. Was fehlt, ist unsere eigene Geschichte: eine dreitausend Jahre alte Zivilisation, getragen von Gott, Tora und dem Land Israel. Wer diese Tiefe kennt, sieht in Israel keine Kolonie, sondern eine Heimkehr.
Daraus folgt auch die eigentliche Schwachstelle. Was Judenhass heute respektabel macht, ist der Satz „Sogar Juden sagen das“. Jede Kampagne gegen Israel findet ihren jüdischen Kronzeugen, und fast immer ist es ein Jude, dem die Verbindung zu seiner eigenen Tradition verloren gegangen ist. Deshalb setze ich mich für jüdische Bildung ein: Kein jüdisches Kind ohne jüdische Bildung. Ein Volk, das seine Geschichte kennt, muss sich nicht ständig rechtfertigen.
Einige meiner Texte (auf Englisch):
The Genocide Lobby: https://t.co/SYH7A2WzXp
Mamdani’s Jews: https://t.co/os4IktCJWj
Certainly a Jew, but not Jewish: https://t.co/Nm0BPjjyK5
My Heart Is in the East: https://t.co/OFnumGPzFU
Herzliche Grüße
Barry Mellinger
@deborahlipstadt He is right we need to say it more clearly anyone claiming that this is a Genocide is an antisemite ... We can not win against the Genocide-Lobby https://t.co/u9ytL8lnWY