@rdgrongoodnet1@PHfloor So there would be no Canada. It would be something else, but not a wealthy, sovereign, industrialized nation.
There's lots of examples of other countries that did not invest in themselves; they are poor resource colonies controlled by foreigners. Is that your preferred vision?
@MarkMcGrathCFP@J6531521316274 The actuary sees CPP expenses overtaking tax revenue sometime in mid 2040's. Although, the actuary has a history of pessimism.
So that's over 40 years of taxpayers building up an investment fund of largely foreign assets without reaping any of the profits. It's pretty absurd.
@MarkMcGrathCFP@J6531521316274 This is the problem with how the CPP is framed. Functionally, it's a tax and transfer program like OAS, just with a specific tax. But everyone thinks its like an investment account that has to provide a return like an investment account. It's never been that.
@rdgrongoodnet1@PHfloor If that's what had happened, Quebec would have been easily taken over by the Mohawk and later the USA. No Canada at all.
Of course the USA has never had a problem running up govt debt to build whatever they want, and they are consequently a very wealthy nation.
@rdgrongoodnet1@PHfloor Nothing NEEDS to be anywhere. But economic growth requires investment. Someone has to clear the land and plant the crops and build the homes.
The world didn't NEED Alberta's oil, but aren't we all glad that the govt funded oil sands development anyway?