do i think anya is 100% innocent? no.
will i defend her for everything? yes because poor girl was dealing with 5 difficult situations at once while running around high as shit with undiagnosed anxiety the whole time
for me the show would be 12968368 times more interesting if there is no supernatural element because truly what is more disturbing than humans just doing stupid and/or evil shit #thebody
also when she was trying to blackmail anya the things she asked for were protection for her and her brother, a place to live and 100 dollars a week....this is not an evil mastermind, this is a child permanently stuck in survival mode