WPM pros:
- Longer average mine lives
- Larger company so a slightly lower % of revenue goes to overhead
- More growth is already built in
- Slightly better tax rates
RGLD pros:
- More diversified
- Better political risk profile
- US investors don’t have to worry about complicated and costly PFIC tax issues
- Eligible for S&P 500 inclusion
- Higher margins
Both are very high quality companies and WPM deserves a slight premium in my opinion. But not this kind of premium.
Thanks for that chart, I just chose a couple of random companies that had been around for a long time. In the royalty space your only options for that are WPM and RGLD if you want a stock chart that goes back 20 years. Very early Barrick holders had opportunities for great returns, yet the stock has gone almost nowhere in 30 years. At the beginning of your chart Royal Gold was still an oil and gas E&P company: Later their plan was to become a gold mining company. I think the mid 90s is approximately the time they figured out their business model, though at that time they were still doing their own exploration and royalty generation.
In 2025, when B2Gold exceeded their AISC guidance, they were eager to let us know that the miss was mostly because of the higher gold price leading to increased royalty payments.
In their 2026 Q3 earnings, when they lowered their AISC guidance, not a peep about how a lower gold price contributed to ~50% of their AISC reduction.
From reading the Q3 earnings press release and MD&A, they attribute the AISC reduction to operational performance several times while never talking about how lower gold prices led to lower royalty expenses and a lower AISC. (To be fair, they did mention lower royalties at Fekola on a single line in another context. But they didn't specifically attribute the lower AISC guidance to this.)
In their own guidance from February 2026, they said that their AISC was based on a gold price assumption of $5,000 per ounce and for every $100 change in the gold price, AISC would increase/decrease by about $12.
The average gold price for the whole of 2026 is tracking to be about $4,425. It's higher than that for the first three quarters but the lower gold price in Q4 is set to bring down the full-year average.
Based on B2's own sensitivity analysis, this means that approximately $70 of their $140 AISC reduction is thanks to the gold price averaging lower than their $5,000 assumption.
The CEO quote from their press release "The reduction in our full-year AISC guidance reflects the leverage in our business, where strong production performance and consistent execution translate into lower costs on a per-ounce basis."
This is probably happening in other companies too, it's just that B2Gold is where I noticed it.
The AISC sensitivity to the gold price was already built into my valuation model so I only have to lower my forecasted AISC by ~$70 vs their $140 official reduction. So on a quantitative basis, it slightly helps my valuation.
Looking at it from another way, it’s one more thing in a line of evidence that tells me I have to try to sleuth out the whole truth about B2 in ways other than listening to what the management team says.
Every company chooses selective sharing to some extent, B2 more than some others.
I sat down with Steve Barton to discuss why I’m cautious on some "Big Three" gold majors while doubling down on specific royalty companies.
Some things we covered:
👉 The $300M quarterly cash flow catalyst for $BTG.
👉 Why the market is mispricing $RGLD.
👉 $WPM vs. $FNV: Which royalty giant wins?
👉 Security risks & the patience needed with $VZLA in Mexico.
Watch the full breakdown here:
https://t.co/WaH0kqrzBJ
I just had a great chat with @jessebday that I recommend watching. We get into some things that we've never talked about before such as my latest research into the likelihood of a recession.
*Credit Card Risk* = Rising
*Buy Now Pay Later Risk* = Very High
*Student Loan Risk* = High and set to get much worse in July
*Auto Loan Risk* = Very High and a significant risk to bank balance sheets
On today's Commodity Culture, @miningstockguy is seeing signs that an economic crisis of epic proportions is brewing and if that proves to be the case, he brings a lineup of mining stock picks that he thinks will weather the storm ahead.
Get 50% off Mining Stock Monkey VIP for three months. Limited to the first 30 subscribers: https://t.co/9S0D0LLHvt
Disclaimer: Commodity Culture was compensated by Mining Stock Monkey for producing this interview. Nothing contained in this video is to be construed as investment advice, do your own due diligence.
Shout out to @miningstockguy whose service discovered a billing error that I didn't even notice myself and made it right automatically. Learned a lot about how the service analyzes mining stocks. I am subscribed to the basic service, but I totally enjoyed and learned how to look at mining stocks better. Definitely worth taking a closer look!
As someone who was recently a buyer in the diamond market, it made no sense for me to pay significantly more for a natural diamond than to get a lab grown diamond that’s the exact same thing. My wife agreed and preferred getting a larger lab made diamond for much less money. Although I’m typically a buyer in crashes, I think this is a rare market that remains depressed because lab made diamonds are here to stay.
@Tonyforever2003@RealRickRule@JamieHeard5@grok At one point recently it was above $85 about a year out. And right around 80 about 2 years out (Might have been high 70s in those latest months). I didn’t write it down but did track it on a daily basis. These are approximations, not exact numbers.
Why RICK RULE is stockpiling cash
In this interview with @RealRickRule, he shares his thoughts on oil stocks, gold, and copper.
Historically, Rick has been a buyer during market corrections but this time is different; he talks about why he's stockpiling cash instead of buying equities that have gone on sale.
We also get into how to build good money habits, things that contributed to his success as an entrepreneur, and why firing some of your customers (as a business owner) can be a good thing.
It was in backwardation during the entire Iran conflict but there were times when they could judge at or above $85-90 about a year out, above $80 2 years out, and above ~$70 three years out. The futures market isn’t as generous today as it was a few weeks ago but there was a window for companies to guarantee outstanding cash flow for as long as 3 years into the future
@miningstockguy@HerculesMetals One of the best educated deep dive interviews I’ve watched. Very thorough analysis of the company, to the point questions asked by Jordan, excellent replies by Chris. Explained geology processes that were unknown to me.Brilliant work Jordan, after my own DD I’m now invested 👍