Let’s correct the corrective:
The Shah actually traded away longstanding Iranian claims on Bahrain and acceded to whatever a UN mission (not technically a plebiscite or referendum) to the island would find, which ended up being that the residents wanted an independent and sovereign Bahrain.
And when the Shah did intervene militarily in the Arab states of the Persian Gulf, it was in defense of the status quo and pro-Western order, as was seen in the case of the military support to Sultan Qaboos (along with the British) to put down the communist Dhofar rebellion backed by the Marxists in South Yemen.
And in the Shah’s criticisms of Israel (vs the deep intelligence, economic, and security cooperation that existed between the states despite those criticisms), we have to look at where is there breadth and where is there depth. How did the Shah pursue a sovereign foreign policy within the contours of the Cold War and the alignment there? And where did his personal views about the Arab-Israeli conflict fit into that? And why or why not did or didn’t these statements factor into Israeli thinking or perceptions of Iran at the time? That is what matters most for the contrast/comparison IMHO.
Zooming out, I think it’s fair to say Israel would welcome any government in Tehran today where the missiles stop flying and money/munitions stop being transferred to terrorists. And the GCC would welcome any non-irredentist and status quo oriented Iranian foreign policy in the Persian Gulf.
A deeply personal substack piece for me.
Are Iranians not the ‘right’ kind of victims?
Four years after Mahsa Jina Amini’s death, I find myself asking a question that has weighed heavily on my mind: Why does the suffering of Iranians so often seem to come with conditions attached?
A deeply emotional conversation with Azadeh Afsahi, who helps survivors of torture and political imprisonment rebuild their lives, made me wonder whether Iranians simply don't fit the world's idea of what a victim is supposed to look like.
My interview with Masoud Nourmohammadi, whose 19-year-old twin cousins face death and decades in prison after joining protests in Iran, left me asking why their names have not become known around the world.
And my friend Zineb Riboua's brilliant work on Third-Worldism helped me understand a deeper ideological contradiction: When opposition to Western power becomes the defining measure of moral legitimacy, what happens to the people oppressed by governments that claim to resist the West?
What happens when Iranians reject the Islamic Republic's ideology and demand the very freedoms that some of its Western sympathizers associate with the powers they oppose? Does their suffering become less worthy of recognition because their aspirations challenge a preferred political narrative?
In my latest piece, I explore why solidarity with Iranian victims can become entangled in geopolitical loyalties, why the extraordinary achievements of Iranian survivors can make them harder to recognize as victims, and why the people of Iran deserve to be heard on their own terms.
Iranians should not have to be the right kind of victims to deserve the world's compassion. They should simply have to be human.
@MasoudNour@Azadeh_Afsahi@zriboua
My latest on Iran Unfiltered 👇
Link to READ: https://t.co/woDxPeX6CH
Negar Propaganda Motazavi fails to mention why Iranian protestors needed help. The regime that she has been white washing for over 15 years shot and killed 50,000 protestors in two days.
Syrian President Ahmad al-Sharaa:
I don’t believe that it’s an appropriate time to discuss things that happened 25 years ago. I was at a different age, and the conditions in the region were different.
Some people are getting needlessly steamed up about this disinformation centre. Yes we must guard against over-reach, but greater capacity to counter state-sponsored disinformation from Russia, Iran and China is needed against their concerted campaigns undermine faith in our country.
It’s a bit dodgy for British politicians to suggest it’s not a problem.
This was a recommendation from my 2024 review, Protecting Our Democracy from Coercion. I was sceptical about the tendency to restrict freedom of speech in the Online Harms Act. There is a limit to what we should do when British people say stupid things online. But we should all want to cut out Russian bots pretending to be British people to stir things up.
Sanctions are rightly meant to target the Islamic Republic, not Americans pursuing their law degrees.
NUFDI supports Congressional pressure on @LSAC_Official to restore the accounts of U.S. citizens suspended over their heritage.
MEK is a terrorist death cult, much like the Islamic Republic, and is unequivocally despised by Iranians. They pay people to attend their events and pay off shameless politicians to speak at them.
Do not fall for their sponsored promotions!
#MEKterrorists
گزارش مرکز آمار درباره کوچک شدن دهدرصدی اقتصاد ایران در بهار امسال نکات مهمی را درباره مسیر اقتصاد ایران در تابستان و پاییز روشن میکند که اثرات سیاسی مهمی خواهد داشت. در این یادداشت به این گزارش پرداختهام.
https://t.co/MYSZa24nJn
This picture is not from today's protest in New York. I was there. The only group present were the supporters of NCRI. Please take this photo down.
#NCRIAlternative
@HeatherJ_Israel The MEK/NCRI are NOT the voice of the Iranian people. They are the same Islamo-Marxist cult who helped pave the way for Khomeini in 1979.
@77WABCradio He’ll go down in Court as falsely testifying when there’s video evidence to prove he had thrown the first punch and kick, then proceeded to entice the anti-MEK protester. You should really do your due diligence 😬
This is a false narrative and video evidence proves otherwise.
The MEK/NCRI/whatever name you call yourselves these days do not have legitimacy inside of Iran or outside. You’re nothing but a Islamo-Marxist cult who brought in this cancerous regime in 1979 and now want to “replace” it with a 2.0 version of the same crap. You are not the voice of Iranians.
Hey Anita,
Canadians also urgently need food, healthcare and housing too.
- 2.2 million monthly food bank visits
- Tens of thousands died while waiting for healthcare last year
- Most unaffordable housing in the G20
The Liberals always seem to find taxpayer money to send overseas.
When will they find savings for Canadians here at home?
@Dave_Eby What does a snap election achieve for BC’ers? What does Trump have to do with the rising housing inflation in BC? What does Trump have to do with the rise of homelessness? Or the taxes that are killing hard-working families in BC?
@PalPress24@realrabbilinda You mean journalism on behalf of Hamas? Like your friend, @motazazaiza9 who recently admitted that’s who all the “press” in Gaza work for?