@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 We're talking 2021 here.
No equipment attributable to RU army was detected Donbas in 2021, besides those EW trucks.
You responses are either factually false or irrelevant (like the one above).
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Read Minsk2: UA was NOT supposed to provide or organize elections in Donbas. Elections there were supposed to held by Donbas folks, following UA law, under Intl observation, with no Ukraine involved at all, besides, perhaps, as observers.
So many false statements from you!
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Zelensky's statement is not an opinion
Report on Nationalists' protests is not an opinion.
UA nationalist's threat is not an opinion.
You have a problem using correct terms.
2021 was a very calm year in Donbas; a perfect start for the settlement. Zelensky chose to block it.
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 In 2021 Donbas saw about 15 civ casualties, so the war was pretty much over. NYC saw ~450 homicides that same year.
There obviously WERE elections in Ukraine in 2019, during the so-called war time.
The ceasefire wasn't an issue. Zelensky's refusal to follow Minsk2 was.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 I cited:
* Johnson's explanation that it was Zelensky who failed to make peace;
* Western report on the same;
* Zelensky's own statement on the same;
* UA nationalist's physically harm Zelensky (attached).
https://t.co/e1jJscwnEq
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 That's exactly right: they didn't state that the forces were RU-related. Additionally, they didn't report any equipment typical for RU army, besides those EW trucks.
No evidence of RU army in Donbas. Plenty of evidence of UA violations of Minsk2.
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Upon invasion there were 3 armies fighting in Donbas: UA army, RU army and People's militia of Donbas. The latter was 30-50K folks and reportedly more efficient than the RU army.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 I'm citing official documents by UA and Western press. This is not a fantasy, those are facts. You're not citing anything of verifiable value, besides your "obviousness". This is your fantasy, not mine.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 That's right: OSCE saw NO RU forces in Donbas in 2021. Hence RU wasn't in violation of Minsk2 in 2021.
They in fact did observe a couple of RU-related mil vehicles, which were anti-drone trucks, purely defensive equipment, but nothing else which could have been attributed to RU.
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 This is a lie: withdrawal of RU forces wasn't an issue, at all.
The real issue wasn't even shelling (which both UA and Donbas armies did), but rather refusal to run the elections, in principle, whether with shelling or not. There's Zelensky's own statement to this effect.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 This reality is in your head, but not in real reality.
OSCE observers' job was specifically to monitor violations, and they did. No RU army was found there in 2021.
Zelensky had a chance to avoid the invasion, he only had to follow Minsk2, as signed. But he didn't.
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Almost all fighting men in Donbas were locals, not RU citizens. They were likely ethnic Russians, by most part.
Upon invasion of 2022, it turned out that Donbas sent more troops per capita to fight Kiev-controlled army than UA did to fight the invasion.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 There's no manipulation on my part. Observers stated that there was some firing, but RU wasn't mentioned. Both UA and Donbas were in fact mentioned as far as placement of weapons in "protected" areas is concerned.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 This is a bunch of rubbish.
Minsk2 clearly stated responsibilities of 2 sides: UA and Donbas govs. Those are explicitly mentioned in the treaty, RU wasn't.
In reality, per Zelensky HIMSELF, he was in violation, but at the same time he lied that he wasn't.
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Zelensky was elected in 2019 on his promise to end Donbas debacle. And he absolutely violated his promise, refusing to follow Minsk2, as per his own official statement. He's done that under pressure and threats of UA nationalists, as reported e.g. here:
https://t.co/wggHhwpIAT
@AntekGoldstein@i_corgihuahua@spg007@SwapnilSG009 You're retranslating BS.
Even in 2014, after the hot phase of the war there was over, UA intelligence had a record of 56 Russians being there, and even that record wasn't presented as evidence.
https://t.co/Mt3UD8Fz0o
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 What you write is based on nothing but your fantasies. Nobody reported seeing the RU army in Donbas in 2021.
And for a good reason: the war was over then. There was no sense in maintaining RU troops there.
I don't discuss fantasies, only facts.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 The official observer (OSCE) never reported RU shelling anything. You're spreading your fantasies or lies, whatever you call that.
@AntekGoldstein@spg007@SwapnilSG009 Not one item of Minsk2 mentions RU at all. One item of Minsk2 which was tangentially related to RU was withdrawal of foreign troops from Donbas. There were NO RU troops there, per OSCE observers.
UA was in violation of several items of Minsk2 in 2021, while RU wasn't.