ang observation ko sa pbb collab ngayon
- weak story
- walang chemistry as a group ang mga housemates
- hindi nakagroup ang gawaing bahay so the same lang lagi ang nagwawalis etc
- hindi proportionate ang mga pagkain
- ang boring ng mga tasks
#PBBCollab3point0
1. Aina doesnโt deserve the hate w/ whatever her countryโs jury did.
2. She still deserves the 12 points. Filipinos love good singers.
3. TV3 censoring Vice is a network issue. Not hers.
4. Carmelle and Aina are friends. Weโd love to see them collab in the future.
โค๏ธ๐ต๐ญ๐ฒ๐พ
[DISCUSSION ABOUT THE WEEKLY TASKS]
Are the tasks really easier, or are the housemates simply struggling with execution?
For reference, I will compare the difficulty and nature of the weekly tasks in PBB Collab 3 with those in PBB Collab 1 since yan ang kinukumpara ng original poster.
My main argument: Hindi lahat ng failed weekly tasks ay kasalanan ng production. We need to distinguish task difficulty from housemate performance.
WEEK 01: Christmas Tree Building Task
Difficulty: Easy to Normal
Since bagong bahay ang pinasok ng mga housemates, I would excuse this one.
It makes sense for production to introduce a relatively manageable task while the housemates are still adjusting to their environment and learning how to work together.
Nothing particularly controversial here.
WEEK 02: Verti-Drama
Difficulty: Normal to Hard
Comparable to: One-Shot Wonder (Collab 1)
Both tasks required creativity, coordination, planning, and execution.
Result: I would argue that Collab 1 simply produced a better output because of the creative contributions of Esnyr and the other housemates.
That doesn't automatically mean Collab 3 received an inferior task.
The concepts were comparable. The difference was largely in how the housemates utilized their creativity and resources.
I wouldn't blame production for this.
WEEK 03: Solar ng Pasko
Difficulty: Hard to Almost Impossible
Comparable to: Twinkle Twinkle Big Star (Collab 1)
Both tasks revolved around precision, coordination, and positioning a large object within a specified area. However, the nature of the difficulty was different.
Collab 1: Required speed, agility, precise movements, and synchronized teamwork.
Collab 3: Required endurance, sustained coordination, patience, and CONSTANT communication.
I would argue that Collab 3's task was particularly unforgiving because small mistakes could undo significant progress.
Result: Again, I wouldn't immediately blame production.
From what I observed, the bigger issue was the housemates' approach to the task.
Instead of systematically testing strategies, identifying what worked, and adjusting when things started going south, the situation became increasingly dominated by clashes of ego and ineffective communication.
Where were the proper trial runs? The discussions about alternative strategies? The willingness to abandon an ineffective approach?
At some point, parang nilaro na lang nila ang weekly task instead of treating it as a problem requiring a coordinated solution.
A difficult task is not necessarily an unfair task. And poor execution does not automatically mean poor task design.
WEEK 04: The Waiter Task
Preliminary Difficulty: Normal to Hard
Comparable to: Rampa Ampar (Collab 1)
Disclaimer: Waiting for the complete mechanics before making a definitive assessment.
Based on the concept revealed so far, both tasks revolve around balance, practice, precision, and mastering an unfamiliar physical skill.
Collab 1: Rampa Ampar - The primary difficulty involved walking backwards while maintaining balance and following a designated line.
Collab 3: Waiter Task - The apparent challenge involves walking while balancing a tray, possibly with additional movement or footwear restrictions depending on the full mechanics.
Both tasks test coordination, muscle memory, consistency, and the ability to perform under pressure.
Of course, the final difficulty assessment will depend on the complete rules, restrictions, and success conditions.
But conceptually? The comparison is reasonable.
MY OVERALL TAKE
So far, I don't see sufficient reason to conclude that Collab 3 is being given significantly easier weekly tasks than Collab 1.
There are differences in the skills being tested, but these differences don't necessarily translate into easier or harder task design.
And here's what I think some viewers are overlooking:
TASK DIFFICULTY โ TASK EXECUTION.
A task can be reasonably designed and still fail because the housemates lack preparation, communication, creativity, or coordination.
Conversely, a seemingly impossible task can become manageable when the housemates develop effective strategies and actually listen to one another.
Production should absolutely be criticized when mechanics are unreasonable, poorly communicated, or structurally unfair.
But we cannot keep blaming production for every failure when the housemates themselves are responsible for how they approach the challenge.
Sometimes, the task isn't the problem. Sometimes, the problem is how the housemates work together.
And I, thank you!
@bloom_racesh pareho ba tayo ng napanood haha
I deeply remember yung babaeng representative ng Thailand, unang yinakap yung backup dancer sa bandang kanan ni Carmelle. Katabi nung Manager na Babae.
The narrative that Jeo or Gehlee donโt deserve to be Big Winners just because they have careers waiting outside PBB doesnโt sit right with me. This is a competition, not an MMK storytelling contest. Letโs not use the pity card as an advantage.
#PBBCollab3point0