@murray777777@ReveriefitRae 2. I did not claim she has survived off one song. It’s very clear to me that all her music generates royalties from multiple streaming platforms among ticket sales and other metrics. However, when you think of Carrie Underwood, the average person thinks of only one song. This one
@murray777777@ReveriefitRae If you read the original post, I compare her performing a song from 20 years ago to Madonna doing the exact same thing. This is an adequate comparison, both artists are employing the same commercial strategy.
@murray777777@ReveriefitRae This was a 72 show residency. Celine Dion’s residencies totaled 1,141 shows. Other artists who’ve sold out residencies greater than hers Shania Twain, Katy Perry. I didn’t say she’s not successful, but her platform is not as large as the numbers you use claim to make it.
@murray777777@ReveriefitRae Also, 14 of those songs were ones she co-wrote. Not all performed or produced entirely by her. Using my comparison to Madonna, she dwarfs underwood in terms of her significance to music history. Underwood’s scale is the country genre giving her leverage, not billboard hot 100
@murray777777@ReveriefitRae Fact: Before He Cheats was released in 2006
Fact: Confessions On a Dance Floor was released in 2005
Fact: Madonna released the sequel to her 2005 album last week
Art is meant to be criticized. My comparison is simply an opinion but the context is all true.
@JadreCarter@ReveriefitRae You were* dropped on your head one too* many times. I possess a bachelors degree, the ability to argue, and basic literacy. You have a wonderful day now
@murray777777@ReveriefitRae Looks like you’re on an adult floor hockey team. You got knocked around a few times and lost some brain cells. You can tell me I’m stupid but can’t elaborate.
@2fabgabb@ReveriefitRae Yes I am, because Madonna is still performing songs from 20 years ago and making a sequel to her past project released in 2005. The point is, they’re both still singing songs from the same time period, one is doing commercially way better
@mwash1983@ReveriefitRae Like actually it’s so bad 🤣 Chappell Roan could do a better job and spike views. Put it behind a paywall or subscription and that’s revenue, Mike. I love it.
@caliginousomber@ReveriefitRae Everything about this is bad for the respect that Carrie demands in pop culture spaces, of which she doesn’t deserve. Why has everyone only ever seen her perform this song? She hasn’t innovated with her sound. Beyonce did once and sonned her whole set babygirl.
@susanmorte59@ReveriefitRae Art is meant to be criticized, Susan. Carrie is a performer and thus subjects herself to criticism because she’s in the music market. If this CU concert is meant to be enjoyed, that’s disappointing. I’ve only ever seen her perform this one song.
@Unstablystable0@TRIGGERHAPPYV1 And what makes being a delivery driver not a real job? I work for a firm and not Instacart. I also don’t get tips either just wages and I still would’ve done the same shit.