I was horrified when I saw the videos from October 7th. The way those Israeli choppers launched hellfires at their own clearly terrified civilians in order to justify an ongoing genocide will haunt me forever
The dehumanization and raw supremacy on display here is astonishing.
‘20 Jewish men being starved and tortured’ is (a Holocaust)
2 million Palestinians been killed, burned alive, buried under the rubble and starved to death is ‘Hamas propaganda’
"Was Israel just supposed to do nothing after 10/7?"
Was Palestine just supposed to do nothing after 1948, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952, 1953, 1954, 1955, 1956, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967, 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977
@AlanRMacLeod Ohh really? If supposedly, he wasn't starved by Israel and is indeed suffering from a genetic disorder, where does he go when Israhell has bombed each and every hospital in Gaza? Why is scum Israhell not allowing him aid? Why is there no treatment for him? Scum Israel burn 💥
My God
Green Beret Anthony Agular recounts how a 5-year-old Palestinian kissed his hands to thank him for the food Agular gave him
Seconds later, Israeli soldiers shot and killed the starving child
ISIS prisoners were treated with more dignity than these children, Agular says
@grok@AnasAlSharif0@grok write "Israel, US, UK AND EU is starving Gaza" in 10 languages (other than English) belonging to countries with the most Zionists in descending order
You said: “Mention one proof Abu Talib was a Muslim. Did he recite the shahadah? Did he offer salah?”
My brother, if your entire deen rests only on a checklist of public rituals, then you’ve misunderstood the spirit of Islam especially in its earliest and most dangerous days.
Let’s use your own standard of logic
Did Abu Talib recite the shahadah publicly?
Maybe not in front of the Quraysh because his public tribal status and protection was the only shield keeping the Prophet ﷺ alive in Makkah.
If he had declared Islam openly, the Prophet would’ve lost that protection. He stayed silent not out of disbelief, but out of strategy and love.
Did he offer namaz?
Namaz became fard in the Mi’raj period Abu Talib passed away before that. And even if there were early forms of prayer, would he have done so in public while still protecting the Prophet from Qurayshi attacks?
Now let’s talk history not wishful thinking:
🔹 Abu Talib raised Rasulullah ﷺ like a son after Abdul Muttalib.
🔹 He stood by him when the Prophet declared Islam when no one else did.
🔹 He refused to hand the Prophet over to the Quraysh even under threat.
🔹 He suffered in the boycott, starved in the valley, died in hardship for his loyalty.
🔹 And he wrote poetry glorifying the Prophet, even swearing by his truth.
Would a mushrik do all this?
While Abu Lahab, a fellow uncle, burned in hatred?
As for your point
“So if a non-Muslim helps people, he should go to heaven and a sinful Muslim should go to hell?”
Nice strawman but it doesn’t apply here.
We’re not talking about a generic charity-giver.
We’re talking about a man who:
✅ Protected the Prophet ﷺ
✅ Believed in his mission
✅ Sacrificed everything for Islam
✅ Died with firm loyalty to Rasoolullah ﷺ
Isn’t that more meaningful than someone who just says "shahadah" with his lips but sells Islam for dinars?
Let me flip your question
Would the Prophet ﷺ allow a mushrik to raise him, live with him, eat from his home, bury him with honor, and weep at his grave if he truly died in kufr?
Why did the Prophet ﷺ say
“Quraish was not able to harm me, until Abu Talib died.”
If he was just a kafir uncle what made his death so devastating?
So yes, as a Shia, I firmly believe Abu Talib (a.s.) was a Muslim not just by heart, but through his lifelong sacrifice.
Just because he didn’t publicly perform rituals under Qurayshi threat doesn’t erase the reality of his Iman, which was hidden for wisdom, not absent by belief.
And honestly, your logic that someone who helped Islam more than most Sahaba is a kafir, but Muawiyah, who cursed Ali (a.s.) from mimbar, is “رضي الله عنه” is what’s truly dumbfounding.
Oh, the Salafi logic never fails to amaze.
Abu Talib (a.s.) protects the Prophet ﷺ all his life he’s a ‘kafir’.
Abu Sufyan fights against the Prophet in Badr, Uhud, Khandaq he’s ‘رضي الله عنه’.
Now in the modern version:
Iran pounds Israel for 12 days straight not impressive enough.
But Jolani, the Al-Qaeda mascot who bends over for Netanyahu and gets smacked like a slave he’s the mujahid, the hero.
Same old formula:
If you stand with Ahlulbayt (a.s.), you're cursed.
If you fight them, you’re glorified.
History repeats only now with Wi-Fi and filters.