If anyone is interested in this topic, I'd love to collaborate with you! I had a great time presenting on this topic, and looking forward to continue building in this direction.
https://t.co/NQ1FPYs3c9
I've put a lot of thought into how blockchains can become adopted by governments to improve their operations, and I've seen many of the pilots that exist ranging from verifiable credentials, identity, bonds, procurement, etc.
@randw Yeah, but I also think it’s about finding what each level of scale unlocks and what benefits it provides.
I can create an onchain verifiable credential, and I can validate that it works for 2-3 organizations and their users.
@randw That’s what we have to illustrate, and to do that, we have to understand a new governance regime for institutions that they must perfect. We’ve done it with our current government. Even with all the bottlenecks.
@randw things like disaster response and other “whole community” approaches within public policy.
Minimizing trust reduces friction in bureaucracies. Drastically. People need to understand that it’s a step change improvement over how we currently operate.
@randw Which is also why I think that pilots simply using blockchains for a single use-case seems the wrong way to go.
It needs to be a full on system of exchange between institutions and the public. The problem is that funding pilots at this scale is extremely hard.
@randw I agree, if they're using the same substrate.
A lot of experiments shroud the benefits of a potential larger system because that is where their pilot ends, and the host evaluates its function w/o considering the significant potential benefits it can bring to others.
But given the capital requirements of its buildout, the interests of those building the technology overlap nearly 1:1 with those who already hold power, so there’s an extremely strong incentive gradient selecting toward concentration.
No amount of “should” changes this reality.
“To those who have everything, more will be given…”
Scaling blockchain pilots is a governance challenge because Institutions have to learn how to share responsibility & resolve disagreements to collectively maintain it. Thats' the challenge in front of us, and its something we should at least acknowledge when building solutions.
In the pilots, early participants bear the costs, while the benefits are dependent on broader adoption.
Network effects alone won't establish a case for blockchains. They need to be able to also test the value of independent verification, distributed control, and shared rules.
A new era of tooling for Governments will vastly improve our methods for real-world governance.
Some will be truly novel, & they will require a more distributed form of collective control.
However, the biggest challenge we face is mastering the social behaviors around them.
I don't know exactly what getting this right looks like, but I'm sure there are people here with ideas worth considering.
How we learn to do this together is one of the most valuable things Ethereum gives the world. real talk.
Decentralization requires a different set of assumptions and therefore a different set of behaviors that need to be learned. Behaviors we are still learning.
We have to practice, fail, and practice some more. And it starts with those closest to the protocol.