@BebopJosh I’ve answered all day. There are nearly 100 comments on this post. Half of those are me responding to people like you. It’s been 20-30 to 1. I’ve already answered. You want to keep arguing. I have no desire to do that. You have rejected Jesus Christ as He has revealed himself.
Well, He did. It’s called the Bible. 😂
And yes, Christian denominations disagree about plenty of things. Church governance, baptism, communion, and other theological questions. But Catholics, Orthodox, and Protestants have historically agreed on the foundational truths about who God is and who Jesus Christ is.
That’s the distinction I’ve been making all day. The existence of disagreements doesn’t mean God failed to reveal Himself clearly. And adding another book doesn’t automatically resolve those disagreements, especially when it introduces an entirely different understanding of God’s nature.
You’re making the same mistake again. Just because a theological term isn’t explicitly written in Scripture doesn’t mean the truth it describes isn’t taught there.
The hypostatic union simply describes what Scripture teaches: Jesus is fully God (John 1:1) and fully man (John 1:14). We didn’t invent those truths by giving them a name.
And please read ALL of Psalm 82, not just verse 6. God is addressing those called gods who are being condemned for injustice. The very next verse says they will die like men. Jesus quotes this passage in John 10 to defend His claim to be the Son of God, not to teach that humans can become gods.
Again, I’m not denying glorification or theosis. I’m distinguishing between sharing in God’s life by grace and becoming what God is by nature.
We will always be His creation. He will always be our Creator. That’s the distinction.
You’re making an assumption that simply isn’t historically accurate.
The Trinity wasn’t invented at Nicaea. Christians were teaching the divinity of Christ and distinguishing the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit long before that council. Nicaea addressed disputes about those existing beliefs.
And yes, Joseph Smith prayed, citing James 1:5. But that passage doesn’t mean every claimed revelation is automatically from God. Scripture explicitly tells us to test those claims (1 John 4:1).
That’s exactly what I’m doing.
You say Nicaea followed the philosophies of men, while Joseph Smith followed God. But that’s the very claim you need to prove.
The question remains: Does what Joseph Smith taught agree with what God had already revealed in Scripture?
That’s the standard I’m applying to both. Not tradition, not councils, not Joseph Smith. Scripture.
And once again, I’m not claiming the creed has authority over Christianity. Scripture does. Christ does.
The Nicene Creed is a statement of what the church understood Scripture to teach about the nature of God and Christ. It didn’t invent those teachings.
You don’t have to accept the creed’s authority. But you do have to reckon with the Scriptures it’s summarizing.
That’s been my point all day. We’re going in circles here, my friend.
That’s a fair question. Interestingly, the Book of Mormon contains passages that sound quite consistent with historic Trinitarian Christianity. Look at 2 Nephi 31:21 or Mosiah 15:1–4.
The clearer contradictions emerge in Joseph Smith’s later revelations.
Doctrine and Covenants 130:22 describes the Father and Son as separate embodied beings. Abraham 4 speaks of multiple Gods participating in creation.
Compare that with John 1:1–3, Isaiah 43:10, and Colossians 1:16–17.
The disagreement isn’t simply with the Book of Mormon in isolation. It’s with the broader LDS understanding of God’s nature, including its later revelations.
And that’s why I keep asking how these teachings can be reconciled with the Bible.
I’m genuinely starting to wonder if you’re reading what I’m writing. 😂
You argued that the Trinity wasn’t taught in the New Testament because its formal formulation came later. I applied your own reasoning to Joseph Smith’s teachings. Now you’re asking whether I think Christians existed before Nicaea?
Of course they did. That’s literally my point. The creed didn’t create Christianity. It clarified what the church believed about Christ.
You’re arguing against a position I never took. I hope the True Christ reveals Himself to you. Sincerely.
I appreciate you taking the time to explain your position. Sincerely. This is the kind of conversation I’m happy to have. I understand that LDS theology teaches worship of the Father through Christ and that you don’t worship other gods. But that’s not quite the distinction I’m making.
Scripture doesn’t simply teach that there is only one God relevant to our world. Isaiah 43:10 says, “Before me no god was formed, nor shall there be any after me.” Isaiah 44:6 says, “Besides me there is no god.”
And even if we agree that Isaiah is speaking of Christ, that actually reinforces the question: How can there be other gods if Christ Himself declares there are none besides Him?
The Trinity doesn’t teach three separate gods. It teaches one eternal God in three distinct persons.
That’s the theological difference I’m asking you to reconcile with Scripture.
I really appreciate your post and your willingness to discuss respectfully.
I agree that I shouldn’t tear people down, and if I’ve done that, I’m happy to be corrected. But there’s a difference between judging someone’s heart and examining their doctrine against Scripture. We’re actually commanded to do the latter (1 John 4:1).
I’m not claiming to know anyone’s eternal standing before God. That’s His judgment, not mine. But I can absolutely examine what someone teaches about Christ and whether it aligns with Scripture.
And I’d encourage you to do the same with everything I’ve said.