For those that want a “15 years later” update on whether fracking was safe:
- Since 2010, 300,000 shale wells were fracked all across the United States
- No groundwater issues
- Nobody got sick
- Hotspots of drilling are thriving
You were lied to.
@AmbroserayRay@kimi20200503 Vit is saying the per unit of heat is worth 10x if it’s geothermal vs gas.
Regardless, a geothermal well produces about 10% the energy as a shale gas well over its life. So revenue may be a wash, but geothermal costs are 4-5x that of a shale well. That��s the problem.
Ooooof. Short report from Morpheus research on $FRVO Fervo Energy released last week looks brutal.
Deep technical breakdown, interviews with ex-employees. Very thorough.
Haven’t read the full report (long read), so won’t lazily share it. But it’s google-able if interested.
@kimi20200503@AmbroserayRay That short report highlights the importance of keeping water losses in check. Valid to flag them but think most are in wait and see mode on actual numbers.
Investors should be pounding the table demanding the company to show the data that matters. Not drilling days ffs
@Its_theT Lock up doesn’t expire until next month.
Those losses (if there are any) may pale in comparison to the lost opportunity from those that expected power. Wild setup
2.5 years since this post.
Only now are geothermal investors starting to get a glimpse of what they’ve actually invested in.
Long way to go until the risks are fully understood by the market
The Geothermal industry is currently going through the biggest promotional pump I’ve seen in the energy space in the last 10 years.
Not saying all of these geothermal startups will fail, but the unsuspecting + non-technical investors are going to get their faces ripped off.
Got through it. Worth sharing now.
Certain questions in the report are possibly addressable over time. The bigger technical concerns that aren’t “fixable” (if real) are pretty spot on.
https://t.co/9KRqWqLcdQ
@Albertagarbage@Undead_marcus Marcus, seems as though your focus is on the surface, but the downhole challenges are vastly greater. Vets in the oil and gas industry have seen the variety of results from hundreds of thousands of wells and are skeptical the necessary conditions downhole can be reliably created
Hold on. So you’re telling me:
A company tasked w/ needing to achieve perfection in well to well communication in the harshest, most costly, most erratic geo environment… AND has no cost data, long term production history, or OPEX info…
They’re NOT worth $10 bn??
$FRVO
@chrisangelo667@slocumfortexas Obviously it’s not free in the sense you can go out there and plant a flag like it’s the 1700s.
The university still owns it.
It’s “free” as in for < $200/acre a licensed operator can lease it. Which in the oil and gas industry is as close to zero as possible. Yet, no bites.
@SerenityStnu Public data and basic algos will get commoditized to zero. Only true moat will be the ability to maximize use of unique data. If a 3rd party can do that best for every operator, great. They win. More likely, companies themselves are best equipped to work their own data
For a one time cost of $500 I built a much worse version of a $30,000/yr software.
It has 10% of the features, but it’s 2x better for my specific workflows.
The age of single use software has arrived. And productivity is about to skyrocket.
@MichaelAviatir I said Fervo was the only enhanced geothermal systems company you moron. As in, exclusively relying on horizontal wells with modern frac jobs to circulate water in a way that’s never been done.
Not the same thing as what ormat is doing which is proven conventional geothermal.
1/2
Fervo Prediction - Megathread
Alright. Here’s my guess on how the enhanced geothermal thing plays out. A focus on Fervo given they’re the only public name in the space. $FRVO
Before I get into it, just have to say - I hope this plays out differently than I think it will. I do hope it works. The world will be a better place if it does.
But the reality is, at this pivotal moment in time, missed deadlines on power delivered has a larger impact than just “dinging” the companies responsible for the misses. So, rigorous critique is necessary.
My view is a company like Fervo and enhanced geothermal is wildly more uncertain than anybody realizes. And yes, this means companies like Google, a search engine company, doesn’t quite understand the technical dynamics of a power plant that is 8000’ below the surface. So, here’s my best guess on how Fervo plays out. It is the ultimate case of building a plane while flying it.
— 2026 —
2026: Fervo continues to show a good hand prior to any projects coming online. The story sounds good when the go-to metric is drilling days per well vs actual volumes of power delivered. The show starts when those electrons are expected to flow.
— 2027 —
2027: First power from their first project is delayed by a few months due to things largely out of their control. Not a huge deal. People largely look past it. Actual operational issues aren’t mentioned until the project comes online.
1H 2027: Once the project is technically online, reaching “full capacity” will also be delayed. But this time the delay is longer (6-12 months) due to a mix of unforeseen downhole issues (well issues, circulation issues, water loss issues) and surface issues. The downhole issues will be downplayed due to the lack of insight and investor understanding. The surface issues will be harder to downplay (investors can see and understand this better, thus more questions). The focus will be to direct attention on the parts of their project that work (the occasional spot rates of good deliverability). You will not hear about total production over a quarter or forecast for the year, or any project level costs. Expect actual production to be 50% of what was expected. Think “we exceeded our nameplate capacity this week” instead of saying “we expect to deliver 42% of our nameplate capacity for the year and spent an extra $200 mil to do that”.
2H 2027, market has turned from elated at the potential of EGS to now spooked. Fervo says they’ve identified the issue and have learned how to fix it.
2H 2027: The initial project continues to perform at <50% of expected power production while the “fix” is in the works. And again, this refers to total power produced over a long period. Beware of the company reporting spot rates. They try to focus attention on the next project while the first project limps along. They have moments of strong deliverability (days/weeks), but actual quarterly power delivered is nowhere near what was promised.
2H 2027: The “fix” (as communicated, not reality) drill new wells and hope that works (they promise it will). What few wells they do have online and producing, some must be shut down during drilling and completions of the new wells for safety and operational reasons. Project power goes down even more during these fixes (12+ months)
FY 2027: Project produces a total of < 50% of the expected power, and due to the additional cost of the fixes they are > 50% over budget. Meanwhile, the next project is being drilled. None of these numbers will be communicated clearly. It is up to investors to ask these questions directly.
@MichaelAviatir If you actually read the post you’d see what I think will happen is companies like Fervo revert to developing rock that is closer to conventional (ie, what ormat is doing) vs the more challenging EGS rock.
So, it was a nod to companies like ormat, dumdum.
Those Tamboran Australian shale wells…not good. $TBN
Based on IP results, well productivity looks like Barnett (1 bcf/1000), but with costs similar to Western Haynesville (>$20mm)…. And no market to sell the gas.
Mgmt will hype this another 36 mos and then this will all end.
@chrisangelo667@slocumfortexas Christopher, the post above shows the land has been abandoned. No companies would take ownership of it for free, let alone pay for it.
The entire orogrande is yours if you want it. It’s just sitting there for free.
@GreyHairOpsGuy That’s 1 of a few critical unknowns. And I couldn’t agree on the eventual messaging.
Geothermal investors generally don’t have an appreciation for just how easy it is for downhole companies to redirect the conversation to other things.
@oldtimerhand@Albertagarbage These companies care less about price and more about having reliable power. That reliability goes away, so does your marketable product