Otherwise the helpless addicts can go gamble in another state
The real solution is a federal list those folks can get added to to protect themselves
Until then Kalshi and Novig are trying to help the gambling addicts by reflecting the list of each state so folks can’t digitally or physically move to a neighboring state and sign in
All of our taxes would need to rise soooo high to cover the gaping hole in tax revenue collected caused by the mass exodus of high paying employees that work there and live here that would have to leave the state
Your stance is very anti-Oregon. You need to rethink it instead of talking anymore
Four circuits, eight opinions, no agreement on why prediction markets are or aren’t swaps.
@a16zfrontier supports the CFTC's rule confirming that event contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges are swaps under the CEA.
One national market, not fifty.
there are laws around any negative externalities folks may engage in though
why prevent folks who have strong impulse control / make good decisions from doing what they want in order to coddle and "protect" a minority of folks who haven't improved their impulse control? that strikes me as an incredibly illiberal approach
you having a problem controlling your impulses doesn't mean others have the same problem man
glad you got yourself sorted out, but stop infantilizing others (and yourself) by making it seem like PMs are "forcing" folks who lack impulse control to "relapse"
it's a pathetic mindset that absolves the individual of poor decision-making and impulse control. only you control what you do; not the existence of any other substance or thing
lol. 18 yos can trade stocks and futures not to mention volunteer to go fight in war and die
18 yos can gamble at tribal casinos and buy lottery tickets and bet on sports in some enlightened states
casinos serve alcohol, so entry is 21+
the only shame i can see is how patchwork this state of affairs is and the confusion it causes
@JeremyRubin think they'll end up removing the gambling-like products (e.g. parlays, prop bets, spreads) but keep the top-level sporting events since those actually carry the economic and financial consequences of other non-sports event contracts
the dumbest parts of history really do repeat themselves
"“Nothing more than a wager.” Just another “species of gambling”. While these quotes may sound like modern references to prediction markets, they come from a 19th-century judicial opinion about something that now seems uncontroversial: agricultural commodity futures...In 1890, Senator John Ingalls of Kansas said grain futures trading at the board was “just as reprehensible as . . . the poker-table”."
https://t.co/oPY2gQVF1I
@AdviserCounsel yeah, in general, I would agree with you on that latter point. tbh, that feels like a much more constructive avenue to direct the debate and discussion around this topic
How do you tell if a forecaster is any good?
Ask two things:
1) how often were they right?
2) how good were their probabilities?
Being wrong at 95% should hurt more than being wrong at 55%.
That’s what a Brier score measures. @Shira_LES and @amphib0ly on how we use it to score Q (our AI forecaster).
@ctjlewis@mwfowlie the CFTC was created by Congress specifically to mitigate against the threat of a patchwork of different state regulations though. states like utah are trying to re-write history
@GurdyalMatthew@djb1112@JovyDedaj so why are you in favor of shutting down prediction market exchanges? it's fine for you to speculate on futures of *checks notes* $trump coin (LMFAO), but it's not ok for other legal adults to trade exchange traded contracts involving sporting events? make it make sense man
you can own shares of a specific prediction market too that represent one of at least two outcomes around a specific event you believe to have a percentage chance of being correct that you can sell into the market
you own stock that may represent ownership in a specific company that you believe has a percentage chance of doing good in the future such that your stock value appreciates that you can sell into the market
is there something intrinsically wrong with the former vs the latter?
you could lose $300 betting on the future performance of a specific company by buying their stock on a stock exchange, though
should we make that sort of speculation illegal too? or should we let every single state weigh in on whether a specific company's stock can be traded within their geographic territory?