@Diogostosa_@TalI_guy P4 fan calling p5 goyslop as if p4 wasn't the most cliché Sol anime ever made.
Maruki is a perfect argument actually, since the actual gods in p4 fucking sucks writing wise
@Diogostosa_@TalI_guy -each p5 arc pushes the story forward
-it doesn't focus on the mystery since the gang already knows who the traitor is, hence the lack of red herrings
-Maruki
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ Overall I love p4, but the game is definitely not a good murder mystery, and while I appreciate the themes explored it's hard to deny that the writers find any way to use them for comic relief, even when it opposes the message like with Yosuke's comments and Naoto's fanservice.
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ As for Izanami I dislike the low amount of details that foreshadow her but I've always thought she was a nice idea but badly implemented gameplay wise
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ Marie is another issue of mine, she just doesn't fit neither in the story nor with the group. Her inclusion ruined the already-fuzzy rules of p4's pantheon and forced her as a member of the group without having any moment with the cast outside her sl.
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ The killer is imo a great character, but the fact that his social link clashes with his schedule is really off putting. You can't tell the player that someone is busy working and then tell that they just laze around all day or skip it.
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ I personally hate how crucial pieces of info are coincidentally omitted and brought up just to push the narrative forward. Add to that Naoto, who I love, but it's hard to deny that she was included because the party didn't want and manage to do anything important.
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ —after the first two months. The next weeks are filled with basically pointless discussions that end up in nothing of value for the story and culminate in Mistuo's arc, which I personally find the worst arc in all of Persona considering when it is positioned in the story.
@miscellainous@eviacrowe_ Oh don't I love a peaceful exchange.
I went too far with my original post lol, I still love p4 a lot, especially the characters, but what I dislike the most is the murder mystery aspect.
The mystery has a great introduction but after that it doesn't progresses in any way—
@The_M_S_E@FLIPY70@ArtoriasBenoit Yeah I can see that. Definitely keep an open mind since every modern persona game shares the same issues at the end if the day, what matters is how you relate to the casts and storyline. Since the flaws are structurally identical
@The_M_S_E@FLIPY70@ArtoriasBenoit Hyping something up whether it's done by you or anyone else is the biggest mistake you could make. Before I played p4 I was told that it was perfect, after I played it I found a lot of bullshit that actively dislike but it was a good game.
@The_M_S_E@FLIPY70@ArtoriasBenoit I mean doesn't sound like you hate it so far and again as I said any of your criticism in some form will be addressed, doesn't sound like the same thing tbh. Just play it.
@The_M_S_E@FLIPY70@ArtoriasBenoit The gameplay is great, as for anything else keep an open mind. Playing any sequel in an anthology series like that is setting yourself up to disappointment, p5 fortunately has a different scope, theme and characters and story. View it as its own thing.