Plain-English analysis and reporting on national legal affairs. Former federal prosecutor. Bylines: NYT, WSJ, Politico, NYMag, and more. MS NOW, CNN, and more.
You’re going to see a lot more of this sort of thing
Now that the public has expressed its revulsion with this administration, conservative media figures are going to try to adjust to stay relevant
It’s really wild to see one of the most distinguished and long-serving hosts on Fox News say that JD Vance “never should have been vice president.” That’s one of the strongest critiques I’ve seen in a while
America’s most famous reverse-DEI hire testified before Congress today
Clayton has zero experience or qualifications for this job, and people wonder why the country’s tech infrastructure is falling apart right before our eyes
This guy is wildly unqualified to be a federal judge — has he ever examined a witness, or even been on his feet in a trial court? — but all the WSJ Editorial Board cares about is that he’ll issue rulings that they like
If the alternative to confirming T. Elliot Gaiser is lame-duck dithering that cedes the seat to Chuck Schumer’s whims or even a future Democratic President, that sounds like a worse outcome for Texas conservatives.
https://t.co/U05lHsjlno
It’s exceedingly generous to frame Marco Rubio’s attack on the ICC as an effort to protect US service members
What’s actually happening is that Rubio, Hegseth, et al are afraid that the ICC will prosecute them
https://t.co/nZk6YAf7AS
In recent speeches, Marco Rubio seemed to be engaging in the same kind of nastiness that the public just rejected from his boss, @davidfrum argues. https://t.co/ayRbmdReb9
@nyttypos I promise I’m done, but I really can’t get over you bragging about getting courtesy copies of SCOTUS cert papers — they’re not even merits briefs!
@nyttypos Do you have any idea what federal prosecutors do? Evidently not
I did SCOTUS work in the private sector, like a million other lawyers. It’s not some amazing thing
@Michael93991631 You think it was “without a shred of evidence”?
This is why this debate is such nonsense
People are just out here lying and pretending to know what they are talking about and because this website sucks so bad, they think they can get away with it
Just say it's debatable -- and it has been the whole time -- and move it along
This effort to pretend that the NYT violated some obvious rule of legal writing is an insane lie
@openfilehq (This doesn't apply to you, but I also referenced it as it's useful for non-attorneys reading, which includes the NYT author, who are unfamiliar with signals or the rules for their usage)
@legalstyleblog This is hackery -- you either care about writing accurate things, or you care about trying to score bankshot points based on things you said about things other people said that other people weighed in on
This is inane, and it isn't how respectable lawyers comport themselves
Then what were the quotation marks for?
This is not normal legal writing, and the style guide excerpt in the picture below does not establish that it is
@NYTimesPR Well no, it isn’t a fact, because as you yourself say, instead of citing sources sans signal for the quote, which would indicate they contained it, he used a see signal before a list of 12 sources, which actually tells the reader they do not necessarily contain those words.
Donald Trump “doesn’t have policies,” John Bolton tells @JeffreyGoldberg. “He doesn’t do national-security grand strategy. He does transactions. He does what’s right in front of him.” https://t.co/WPUBhrv6yz
Gaiser has this job because he worked on Trump's effort to overturn the 2020 election
He had never worked anywhere in the federal government -- much less DOJ, much less OLC -- before this
He's done nothing to distinguish himself except support Trump, and this is wildly corrupt
Scoop: Trump's fast-tracked judicial pick Elliot Gaiser proposed a memo as DOJ OLC head that would've activated Comstock Act to criminalize abortion pill transport. Then-DAG Todd Blanche rejected it out of concern it would amount to federal abortion ban. https://t.co/guiPGWqBnO
@kathoh But that is a claim that Scalia never made. It isn’t even clear how he means “and” given his seeming concession above that English law banned dangerous or unusual weapons, and he definitely doesn’t say that satisfying both was a necessary condition for prohibition.
@legalstyleblog You're responsible for the things you write. Have you changed your position?
I would gladly entertain a debate about the NYT story if the participants weren't people like you pretending like it's obvious that they were wrong
@Rybo1278421 This line of argument is incoherent, since plenty of lawyers (including me) have told you all that we sincerely disagree
If someone quotes language and puts a "see" citation behind it, I can absolutely see why people would think the first authority is the source of the quote
It’s frustrating to see people claim to be experts and then be so confidently wrong
The style guide does not remotely establish that the NYT (and everyone else) is wrong