You seem very keen to mistate my position and now you're making ad hominem attacks.
I've suggested there may be more nuance to consider in your approach and that appears to have led you to question my motives and seriousness.
I'm going to leave it there.
I would like to apologise for my "anecdote and Walliams" comment, I do think was snarky of me and since I said it I've felt guilty that I may have diminished your own personal knowledge of such cases.
But I do suspect further discourse would be a waste of both our time.
My motivating argument is precisely that, I don't know.
I assume grooming of the type you mention is happening but I don't know the scale and whether it justifies the change. I am genuinely open to perusasion on this.
I don't know how many 16 years olds have sex with 20 year olds and what the nature of those relationships are.
I instinctively become suspicious when people state their case with confidence, as you're doing, without supporting evidence.
I reject the framing of your question. My original point was around medical confidentiality being more nuanced that you stated.
My broader concern is about proportionality and unintended consequences.
I think you underestimate how cautiously institutions and professionals apply these rules when exposed to legal and regulatory consequences.
I would agree with you that that is not in itself a reason not to do something but it is a reminder that there can be unintended outcomes from well meant change.
I would want to understand what is the additional harm we think we're preventing, what's the frequency etc and balance that against the risk of criminalising consensual relationships between young people.
Perhaps you can tell me what the scale of the problem is? I honestly don't know if we've got a lot of 16/17 year olds being exploited by 21/22 year olds?
@PinchTwigs@OliDugmore I think you have a far more rosy view than I, of the government's ability to write legislation and for regulated institutions to implement that legislation in a balanced and reasonable way.
Doctors have a responsibility to report concerns about sexual abuse of children, not always the police but it's a Fitness to Practice issue if they don't report. See the GMC's Working Together to Safeguard Children and there is a possibility of such reporting requirements being strengthened in the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill.
This discussion around access to healthcare is happening also around that bill.
@BIGNOSELOVER Sent a tweet saying "Two Tier Kier". His door was knocked in less than 30 minutes later, helicopters flying over his house, snipers set up in buildings around him. He was Britain's most dangerous man until they took his phone off him. Fuck knows what could have happened.
@JeremyDuns I don't know if it's the algorithim at work or your own activity but I've noticed you more on X recently and been happier for it. It's always good to see you posting.
@NimkoAli You say that but I ended up involved with two married adult women when I was at college.
I have no idea how common it is but certainly I met two of them.
Quite. I think we need much a broader conversation about what we think it means to be 16 or 18 in our society.
The general consensus appears to be that 16 is still a child, and that's the legal view in most situations but there anomalies like consent and leaving home and there are others, so we should address them all together.
@Lachlan_Edi Right, but you said no sleepovers, suggesting you were unaware that currently 16 year olds can choose to live where they like.
The hyper focus on age of consent at the exclusion of a wider awareness of the legal framework risks creating some odd outcomes.